2021 Meron crowd crush

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

2021 Meron crowd crush
Police preparations for Simeon bar Yochai celebration in Mount Meron, May 2016
Tomb of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, 2016
Tomb of Rabbi Bar-Yochai is located in Northeast Israel
Tomb of Rabbi Bar-Yochai
Tomb of Rabbi Bar-Yochai
Date30 April 2021 (2021-04-30)
Timec. 00:50 IDT (UTC+03:00)
LocationTomb of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Meron, Israel
Coordinates32°58′50.3″N 35°26′25.5″E / 32.980639°N 35.440417°E / 32.980639; 35.440417Coordinates: 32°58′50.3″N 35°26′25.5″E / 32.980639°N 35.440417°E / 32.980639; 35.440417
CauseUnder investigation; includes over-crowding in Lag BaOmer celebration
ParticipantsHaredi and Orthodox Jews
Deaths45
Non-fatal injuries150
InquiriesOngoing

On 30 April 2021, at about 00:50 IDT (UTC+3), a deadly crowd crush occurred in Meron, Israel, during the annual pilgrimage to the tomb of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai on the Jewish holiday of Lag BaOmer, at which it was estimated that 100,000 people were in attendance. Forty-five men and boys at the event were killed, and about 150 were injured, dozens of them critically, making it the deadliest civil disaster in the history of the State of Israel.[1][2] The crush occurred after celebrants poured out of one section of the mountainside compound, down a passageway with a sloping metal floor wet with spilled drinks, leading to a staircase continuing down. Witnesses say that people tripped and slipped near the top of the stairs. Those behind, unaware of the blockage ahead, continued. The people further down were trampled over, crushed, and asphyxiated, calling out that they could not breathe.

The potential for such a calamity, given the tens of thousands of celebrants, had been reported by the state comptroller and the police chief. The local council had tried several times to close the site.[3] Reuters cited Israeli media outlets in reporting that, as a precaution against the COVID-19 pandemic in the country, bonfire areas had been partitioned off, which may have created unrecognised choke-points.[4] It was later pointed out that the bonfires were not all lit at the same time, as in the past; this allowed people who had seen one lighting go to see another, increasing crowds.

On 10 May 2021, police arrested the safety engineer who approved the Lag BaOmer celebration and his assistant. Investigators said that senior police officers should be questioned, as suspects rather than witnesses. On 27 June, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Israel, Esther Hayut, announced that a three-paneled  [he] will be chaired by her predecessor, former Supreme Court Chief Miriam Naor, with the other two members consisting of former Bnei Brak mayor Rabbi  [he] and Aluf (ret.)  [he].[5] In Israel, such a commission of inquiry has the powers to subpoena witnesses and issue recommendations to the government.

Background[]

Further information: Hillula of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
Many traditional Lag BaOmer events took place at the festival, such as dancing and lighting bonfires, preceding the crush.

On the Lag BaOmer holiday, the tomb of the 2nd-century Tannaitic rabbi Shimon bar Yochai at Mount Meron becomes a pilgrimage site for thousands of Jews, where they pray, dance and make bonfires.[6] Men and boys attend in sections different from those for women and girls.[7][8] Haaretz called it Israel's "biggest religious festival of the year".[9]

In 2020, the country restricted the pilgrimage due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Cabinet of Israel permitted the 2021 pilgrimage and waived the COVID-19 cap of 1,000 attendees as part of an agreement with Ministry of Religious Services officials which required attendees to be vaccinated against COVID-19.[10] The event was the largest to be held in Israel since the start of the pandemic in 2020.[11]

Additionally, for the first time in 13 years, the Mount Meron holiday took place on a Thursday and Friday, the significance being that Thursday night is seen as comparable to Saturday night in other parts of the world, with Friday being Israel's day of rest, as opposed to Sunday. Moreover, since celebrations are not permitted on Shabbat, the Jewish sabbath, which starts at sunset every Friday, the event was limited to a window of 14 hours, ending at sunset on Friday. Three bonfires were lit at the same time, each by an Admor. [12] The organisers estimated that approximately 100,000 were at the site—others estimate 50,000[13]—which was larger than the restricted crowd in 2020 but smaller than the hundreds of thousands of people in previous years.[11] Israeli media reported that, as a precaution against the COVID-19 pandemic, bonfire areas had been partitioned off, which may have created unrecognised choke-points.[4]

The crush was not the first time pilgrims at Mount Meron had been killed in an accident. On 15 May 1911, eleven people were killed when a crowd of about 10,000 filled the compound and a railing of a nearby balcony collapsed. About 100 people fell from a height of roughly 25 feet (8 m) to the ground below;[9] the deaths of seven were determined at the scene and those of four others in the days following the incident. There were 40 injured.[14]

Safety warnings[]

A 2008 evaluation of the site by the State Comptroller of Israel concluded that it is not adequate for its number of annual visitors.[15][16] A 2016 police report warned of issues with infrastructure and crowd control.[17]

In 2011, the state declared it would take control over the site,[18] but control was returned to owners in a court-approved settlement in 2020.[19]

In 2018, a journalist reported that the "exit passageway creates a bottleneck and causes risk of people being crushed" [20] and recommended that a larger exit way be constructed for safety after overcrowding at a funeral in Bnei Brak had led to one death and dozens injured.[21]

A week before the 2021 festival, during the Covid-19 pandemic, government departments limited the gathering to up to 10,000 people on the site, approximately 3,000 at each bonfire.[1][12] The Israel Fire and Rescue Services required that, for a crowd of 9,000 people, the site needed four different escape routes.[22] According to The New York Times, none of the government agencies took on the task of enforcing the rules,[23] and in the event an estimated 100,000 people attended.

In addition to the disastrous crush, the executive director at the National Coronavirus Taskforce expressed concerns about the possible spread of Covid-19 due to the huge, closely-packed crowds at the event. However, many restrictions were lifted in mid-February 2021 after most of the population had been vaccinated, and since then "things have gone amazingly well, even after events with very dense gatherings. ... we have to wait to see what happens".[24]

Crush[]

Crowd before the disaster

Four religious groups oversee different parts of the compound,[23] with the Toldot Aharon running the part where the incident occurred.[23][25] According to witness accounts, the event was held in a fenced area that was overly confining.[26] At the time, the restricted area was filled with as many as 20,000 people.[23] After the lighting ceremony, and as dancing began, hundreds of people left. The exit path was a narrow, steep slope with a smooth metal floor.[27] There were no police or rescue services managing the flow into the walkway.[25] With nothing to hold onto, the crowd leaned on each other. The path then leads to steps before a narrow tunnel.[27][28] Close to 01:00, some participants began to slip and fall, either on the metal slope or the stone steps,[6][11][26][27][28][29] and were trampled over and asphyxiated by those behind.[28][30][31] As the crowd moved to the gates, a crush started.[1][26] The crowd broke open side barriers of the path, creating rigged up exits for some to break free.[25]

According to one witness, security blocked the passageway and kept people from exiting. As people were starting to lose consciousness as the crush prevented them from breathing, police finally opened the gates to allow people through. The crush ensued as a large number of people tried to exit at the same time through the narrow passageway.[32] Other witnesses said the path was slippery from spilled water and juice. [26][6] Another witness recalled "hundreds of people screaming 'I can't breathe'".[6]

Survivors described being buried under heaps of people and thinking that they were going to die as they could not breathe.[33] Rescue workers spoke of "so many dead people ... on top of each other". Metal handrailings were bent and twisted by the pressure.[34] Emergency personnel tried to perform CPR on unresponsive victims, then realised that they were spending time on the dead while others were alive, but in danger of death. The first responders themselves were traumatised by the experience; group therapy was arranged to try to ward off PTSD.[35]

As medics were trying to reach the injured, former Israeli Chief Rabbi Yisrael Meir Lau remained on stage, urging calm and reciting psalms for the injured.[1] Three hundred rescue buses were prevented from entering the site due to blocked access roads.[36] Six helicopters were flown in to evacuate the injured. Cell phone service crashed due to the number of people trying to get in contact with their families.[1]

Victims[]

In the crush, 45 people were killed and about 150 more were injured.[1][28] [37] The dead included six Americans, two Canadians, an Argentine and a Briton,[38] and ranged in age from 13 to 65 years old.[39]

The Institute of Forensic Medicine at Abu Kabir completed the identification of all 45 victims by 2 May 2021.[40][39]

Investigation[]

Israel Defense Forces personnel after the disaster

Following an initial investigation, the Israeli police said the crush was not preventable and that the location was being inspected for structural flaws, but the scenario of people slipping on stairs was out of police control.[41] Police commander of the Northern district, Shimon Lavi, said however, that he "bears full responsibility".[42][43] The police released a statement that the passage had been authorized by all the relevant authorities and that they had understood the event would be abnormally large.[43] This was disputed by Mordechai Halperin, ex-mayor of moshav Meron, the local authority in which the site is located, who said that the passage which narrowed an escape route was constructed without any building permits and against his strenuous objections.[44] Many commentators also suggested the Haredi community's extensive autonomy in Israel was a major contributing factor to the catastrophe.[45]

On 3 May, State Comptroller Matanyahu Englman announced an audit of the events leading to the disaster, which would also recommend policy for future mass events. No decision was made on whether to set up a state commission of inquiry at that time. [46] Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu promised a thorough state investigation, but did not specify any details. [38]

On 10 May, the police arrested the safety engineer who had approved the Lag Ba'omer celebration and his assistant. Investigators also said that senior police officers should be questioned as suspects rather than witnesses. From the investigation at that time, it appeared that the main reason for the crowding and pressure at the Toldot Aharon bonfire compound, outside which the disaster occurred, was that police permitted the Hasidic court to hold its bonfire at a different time than the other bonfires at the compound. As a result, the crowd was not dispersed among several bonfires as was usual, but instead, additional thousands crowded in to see the Toldot Aharon bonfire. No police were stationed at the compound's exit; police only arrived 10 minutes after the crowd had pushed through the exit to the nearby walkway, causing the crush. At this stage charges of causing death by negligence were considered more appropriate than the more serious charge of causing death by taking an irresponsible risk.[47]

Commission of Enquiry[]

The newly elected government, which was installed on 13 June, and led by Naftali Bennett as the initial Prime Minister, committed to establishing a state commission of enquiry into the disaster.[48]

On 27 June, the cabinet approved the appointment of a three-member commission led by former chief justice Miriam Naor to investigate the disaster. The other two members of the commission are former Bnei Brak mayor Rabbi Mordechai Karelitz and former Israel Defense Forces planning chief Major General (res.) Shlomo Yanai. Current Chief Justice Esther Hayut appointed the members.[49]

The commission was allocated a budget of NIS 6 million (US$1.83 million) and given a broad mandate, tasked with conducting a detailed probe of the disaster and recommending specific changes to the holy site at Meron, and collaborating with the attorney general and other ongoing parallel investigations into how the disaster unfolded and the decision-making processes of government and police officials that authorized the event. These are reported to include the former public security minister Amir Ohana, former interior minister Aryeh Deri, and former housing minister Yaakov Litzman, who were in office at the time of the incident, and Israel Police Commissioner Yaakov Shabtai and Northern District Police Chief Shimon Lavi.[49]

Aftermath[]

Flags lowered to half-mast on 2 May

The crush was the deadliest civilian disaster in the history of the State of Israel,[27] surpassing the 2010 Mount Carmel forest fire which killed 44.[50] Netanyahu called it a "great tragedy" and said that everyone was praying for the victims.[50] He also declared 2 May 2021 a national day of mourning.[51] Several cultural activities were cancelled.[52] President Reuven Rivlin offered his condolences to the victims.[41]

Condolences were issued also by officials from many authorities, including several Arab governments (including Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas),[53] the European Union,[6] the United Kingdom[54] and the United States.[41]

Israel's Administration of Border Crossings, Population and Immigration declared that a "fast route" to enter Israel had been defined to allow families of the injured and deceased to enter Israel.[55][56]

Residents of the non-Jewish settlements of Beit Jan, Jish, Peki'in, Tamra, and Yarka arranged programs supplying aid to the survivors. Numerous Israeli Arabs offered condolences as a symbolic gesture.[57][58]

On 3 May 2021, the Israeli Authority For Sacred Locations had been given a decree requiring a permit from the Israeli police commissioner to hold any celebration.[59] Prior to the decree only a permit from the regional police chief was required.[59]

On September 2021, Toldos Aharon announced that their annual Simchas beish hashoeva, which normally attracts thousands of visitors, would be closed to the public to avoid overcrowding.[60]

See also[]

References[]

  1. ^ a b c d e f Joffre, Tzvi. "Israel works to identify 45 killed in Lag Ba'omer Mount Meron stampede". The Jerusalem Post. Archived from the original on 29 April 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  2. ^ ""There are casualties, the event is over!": The moment of the disaster, live from Mount Meron". Ynet (in Hebrew). Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  3. ^ Kingsley, Patrick; Kershner, Isabel (5 May 2021). "Deadly Stampede at Israeli Religious Festival Followed Years of Warnings". New York Times.
  4. ^ a b Williams, Dan; Rabinovitch, Ari (30 April 2021). "Israel seeks to identify many of 45 dead in crush at religious festival". Reuters. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  5. ^ "Mount Meron: Ex-chief justice appointed to head state inquiry panel." The Jerusalem Post, June 27, 2021.
  6. ^ a b c d e Kershner, Isabel; Nagourney, Eric; Ives, Mike (29 April 2021). "Stampede at Israel Religious Celebration Kills at Least 44". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 1 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  7. ^ "Israel crush: Israel mourns as festival crush victims identified". BBC News. 1 May 2021.
  8. ^ Liphshiz, Cnaan (30 April 2021). "Why do ultra-Orthodox Jews flock to Mount Meron on Lag B'Omer?". Times of Israel. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 1 May 2021.
  9. ^ a b Maltz, Judy (30 April 2021). "Why do Orthodox Jews flock to the Mt. Meron tomb of Rabbi Shimon Bar-Yochai?". Haaretz.com. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  10. ^ Schwartz, Felicia (29 April 2021). "Dozens Killed in Stampede at Israeli Religious Festival". The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  11. ^ a b c "Israel crush: Dozens killed at Lag B'Omer religious festival". BBC. 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 30 April 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  12. ^ a b "44 הרוגים ויותר מ-100 פצועים בהילולה בהר מירון". Ynet (in Hebrew). 29 April 2021. Archived from the original on 30 April 2021.
  13. ^ "44 people crushed to death, dozens hurt at mass Lag B'Omer event in Mt. Meron". The Times of Israel. 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  14. ^ Israel, David (30 April 2021). "The Tragedy on Mt. Meron, Lag B'Omer 1911". Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  15. ^ "מבקר המדינה מצא ליקויים בקבר הרשב"י כבר לפני 12 שנה: "אין לאפשר את המצב הקיים"". ynet. 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  16. ^ "News1 מחלקה ראשונה". www.news1.co.il. Archived from the original on 20 April 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  17. ^ JAFFE-HOFFMAN, MAAYAN (1 May 2021). "After Meron tragedy: How to survive a crowd crush". The Jerusalem Post. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 1 May 2021.
  18. ^ "הממשלה החליטה להלאים את קבר הרשב"י". Haaretz. 27 November 2011. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  19. ^ "המהלך להפקעת מתחם קבר הרשבי במירון נעצר; במקומו – הסדר ל-3 שנים". www.nadlancenter.co.il. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  20. ^ "Chareidi Reporter Warned Of This Very Tragedy In 2018!". Retrieved 30 April 2021.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  21. ^ "Thousands Attend Levaya Of Yungerman Trampled to Death at Rav Wosner's Levaya". Retrieved 5 April 2015.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  22. ^ "המסמך שחושף את המחדל במירון: "הדרישה - 4 דרכי מילוט"". ynet (in Hebrew). 3 May 2021. Retrieved 3 May 2021.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  23. ^ a b c d Kingsley, Patrick; Kershner, Isabel (4 May 2021). "Israel Had a Plan to Prevent Tragedy at Mount Meron. It Was Ignored". The New York Times. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
  24. ^ TERCATIN, ROSSELLA (6 May 2021). "We'll see Meron's effect on coronavirus next week, health official says". The Jerusalem Post.
  25. ^ a b c "Eleven minutes at Meron: Video shows how deadly crush unfolded". The Times of Israel. 6 May 2021. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
  26. ^ a b c d "Stampede at religious festival in Israel leaves at least 45 dead, dozens injured". The Washington Post. 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  27. ^ a b c d Breiner, Josh; Shpigel, Noa (2 May 2021). "Drone Footage: How Israel's Lag Ba'omer Disaster Unfolded". Haaretz. Retrieved 2 May 2021.
  28. ^ a b c d Kingsley, Patrick (1 May 2021). "Recriminations Intensify After Deadly Israel Stampede". The New York Times. Retrieved 2 May 2021.
  29. ^ "Stampede at religious festival in Israel kills at least 45". Stars and Stripes. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  30. ^ Lubell, Maayan (2 May 2021). "U.S. citizens killed in Israel festival disaster, anger mounts". Reuters. Retrieved 2 May 2021. The exact cause of the disaster is still not clear, but witness accounts and videos posted on social media suggested that some people had fallen down stairs leading out of a narrow passageway packed by hundreds of worshippers trying to exit the site, as a surge of people came down upon those ahead of them who had fallen, being trampled and asphyxiated.
  31. ^ Gross, Judah Ari (3 May 2021). "A steep, slippery ramp, uneven stairs: Walking the route of the Meron disaster". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 12 May 2021. The exit stairs were covered in candles on Sunday, some arranged in the shape of the number 45 — for the 45 people, many of them children, who didn’t make it out to that covered walkway, who were crushed to death on the stairs as masses of people fell on and trampled one another at 1 a.m. Friday.
  32. ^ "Justice Ministry To Open Probe Into Possible Police Negligence At Meron". 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  33. ^ Nathan Jeffay; TOI staff (30 April 2021). "Buried alive: 'I thought I was going to die,' says teen injured in Meron tragedy". Times of Israel.
  34. ^ Burgess, Sanya; Elms, Victoria (1 May 2021). "How the deadly Israel stampede unfolded". Sky News. Article with photograph of bent and twisted railing.
  35. ^ Jeffay, Nathan (3 May 2021). "'Broken': Meron tragedy reduced Israel's toughest rescuers to tears, trauma". Times of Israel.
  36. ^ ""המשטרה לא פינתה צירים; שוטרים הצילו חיים"". kikar.co.il (in Hebrew). Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  37. ^ "How the deadly Israel stampede unfolded". Sky News. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  38. ^ a b Rabinovitch, Ari (3 May 2021). "Israeli state watchdog to investigate religious festival stampede". Reuters.
  39. ^ a b "These are the 45 who died in Meron". Israel National News. 30 April 2021.
  40. ^ "Forensic Institute: All 45 victims of Meron disaster identified". Israel National News. Arutz Sheva. 2 May 2021.
  41. ^ a b c Shpigel, Noa; Breiner, Josh (30 April 2021). "At Least 45 Crushed to Death at Lag Ba'Omer Disaster in Northern Israel". Haaretz. Archived from the original on 30 April 2021.
  42. ^ "Meron exit route was known for years as bottleneck; police commander takes blame". Times of Israel. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  43. ^ a b "במשטרה הודפים האשמות: "כולם אישרו את שביל הגישה, המדינה אחראית"". Ynet (in Hebrew). 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 30 April 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  44. ^ ""מאשר האתר הוא רוצח, אני מאשים את היועמ"ש"". 103FM (in Hebrew). 2 May 2021. Retrieved 2 May 2021.
  45. ^ ""Israel asks whether autonomy of the ultra-Orthodox contributed to the deadly stampede"". 2 May 2021. Retrieved 3 May 2021.
  46. ^ Altman, Yair (3 May 2021). "State comptroller to review events leading to Lag B'Omer stampede". Israel Hayom. Retrieved 3 May 2021.
  47. ^ Breiner, Josh (10 May 2021). "Mount Meron disaster: Israel arrests safety engineer who okayed celebration where 45 died". Haaretz.
  48. ^ Spiro, Amy (6 June 2021). "What's in the coalition agreements Yesh Atid signed with 'change bloc' partners". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 27 June 2021.
  49. ^ a b "Former chief justice Naor to head Meron disaster probe, with sweeping mandate". The Times of Israel. 27 June 2021. Retrieved 27 June 2021.
  50. ^ a b Krauss, Joseph (29 April 2021). "Stampede at Israeli religious festival kills nearly 40". Associated Press. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  51. ^ "As Meron deaths rise to 45, PM declares Sunday day of mourning, vows full probe". The Times of Israel. 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  52. ^ "בעקבות האסון במירון: ביטולי הופעות בעולם התרבות". ynet (in Hebrew). 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 30 April 2021.
  53. ^ "Palestinian leader Abbas, Jordan's king, Gulf allies send condolences over Meron". Times of Israel. 30 April 2021. Archived from the original on 2 May 2021. Retrieved 1 May 2021.
  54. ^ Proctor, Charlie. "The Queen sends a message of condolence to the President of Israel after dozens are killed in stampede". Royal Central. Retrieved 7 May 2021.
  55. ^ Official PIBA Facebook page (PibaIsrael), 1 May 2021
  56. ^ @GLZRadio (30 April 2021). "רשות האוכלוסין וההגירה: "לאור האסון שאירע במירון וכמחווה למשפחות הנפגעים השוהות מחוץ לישראל - פתחנו מסלול ייעודי עבור בני משפחה מדרגה ראשונה מחו״ל, המבקשים להגיע לבקר את הפצועים הנמצאים בישראל"" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
  57. ^ "Arab towns offer food, drink to Meron survivors; hundreds give blood in Tel Aviv". Times of Israel. Retrieved 8 January 2022.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  58. ^ "Hezbollah supporters, pro-Palestinian social media celebrate Meron deaths". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 8 January 2022.
  59. ^ a b "פרסום ראשון | הנחיה חדשה למרכז המקומות הקדושים אחרי האסון במירון". ערוץ 7.
  60. ^ Sarare (23 September 2021). "MERON EFFECT: Toldos Aharon Simchas Beis HaShoeva Closed To The Public". The Yeshiva World. Retrieved 23 December 2021.

External links[]

Retrieved from ""