Matt Medved of Billboard labeled it a "softer-edged song" and said it was a "welcomed shift."[2] Writer of US magazine, Vents, RJ Frometa said "Showing no signs of slowing down, The Chainsmokers continue their unprecedented release schedule delivering fans a new song every month. Their latest offering, 'Inside Out' ft. Charlee, starts off toned-down, allowing the [Swedish] singer's captivating vocals to take the lead, before building to the song's high point and showcasing the duo's signature sound and style."[3]