Year |
Conference Champions |
Champion |
John Gagliardi Trophy Winner
|
1973
|
- College Athletic Conference – Southwestern at Memphis
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Carthage
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Champion Unknown
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Buena Vista
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Juniata (North), Franklin & Marshall (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Minnesota–Duluth and St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Nichols
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- Northwest Conference – Pacific Lutheran
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference – Slippery Rock
- Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (Division III) – Fisk
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Wittenburg
|
—
|
1974
|
- College Athletic Conference – Rose–Hulman
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan and Millikin
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Olivet
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Wilkes (North), Franklin & Marshall (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead and Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Boston State and Nichols
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Glassboro State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference – Slippery Rock
- Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (Division III) – Clark Atlanta
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse, Wisconsin–Platteville, and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Central College (IA)
|
—
|
1975
|
- College Athletic Conference – Rose–Hulman and Sewanee
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wiliam Penn
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Albright (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Lawrence
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Nichols
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Glassboro State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield, Pacific Lutheran, and Whitworth
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference – East Stroudsburg
- Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (Division III) – Fisk
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – La Verne and Redlands
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse, Wisconsin–River Falls, and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Wittenburg
|
—
|
1976
|
- College Athletic Conference – Sewanee
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Carroll (WI)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Alfred
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wiliam Penn
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Albright (North), Franklin & Marshall (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Cornell College, Knox, and Monmouth
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Nichols
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Glassboro State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Randolph-Macon
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference – East Stroudsburg
- Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (Division III) – Fort Valley State
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Trinity (TX)
- Twin Rivers Conference – Concordia–St. Paul, Loras, Maranatha Baptist, Northwestern–St. Paul, and Northwestern (WI)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Oshkosh, Wisconsin–Platteville, and Wisconsin–River Falls
|
St. John's (MN)
|
—
|
1977
|
- College Athletic Conference – Southwestern at Memphis
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan and Millikin
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Champion Unknown
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Albright (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Ripon
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Massachusetts Maritime
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Glassboro State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference – Clarion
- Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (Division III) – Clark Atlanta and Miles
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Tarleton State
- Twin Rivers Conference – Concordia–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Stevens Point
|
Widener
|
1978
|
- College Athletic Conference – Southwestern at Memphis and Sewanee
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Elmhurst and Millikin
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Buena Vista, Central (IA), Dubuque, and Luther
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Cornell College and Ripon
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead and St. Olaf
- New England Football Conference – Boston State and Nichols
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Randolph-Macon
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference – East Stroudsburg
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Tarleton State
- Twin Rivers Conference – Northwestern (WI)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Baldwin Wallace
|
—
|
1979
|
- College Athletic Conference – Southwestern at Memphis, Rose–Hulman, and Sewanee
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Millikin
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Dubuque
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Lawrence
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead, Saint John's (MN), St. Olaf, and St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – New Haven
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- Northwest Conference – Pacific Lutheran
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Denison (Red Division), Wittenberg (Blue Division)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Randolph-Macon
- Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference‡ – Lock Haven
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Carnegie Mellon
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Claremont–Mudd–Scripps
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Austin
- Twin Rivers Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–River Falls
|
Ithaca
|
—
|
1980
|
- College Athletic Conference – Centre
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Elmhurst and Illinois Wesleyan
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Dubuque
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Cornell College and Lawrence
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead
- New England Football Conference – Maine Maritime
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Trenton State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace (Red Division), Wittenberg (Blue Division)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Bridgewater
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Bethany (WV)
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – McMurry
- Twin Rivers Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse, Wisconsin–Platteville, Wisconsin–River Falls, and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Dayton
|
—
|
1981
|
- College Athletic Conference – Rose–Hulman
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Alfred
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley and Juniata (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Lawrence
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- Northwest Conference – Pacific Lutheran
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace (Red Division), Wittenberg (Blue Division)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Washington & Lee
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Carnegie Mellon
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Whittier
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Austin and Sul Ross State
- Twin Rivers Conference – Concordia–St. Paul and Northwestern–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Eau Claire
|
Widener
|
—
|
1982
|
- College Athletic Conference – Sewanee
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – St. Lawrence
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley and Lycoming (North), Widener (South)
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Ripon
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace (Red Division), Ohio Northern (Blue Division)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Hiram
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – La Verne
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Sul Ross State
- Twin Rivers Conference – Concordia–St. Paul, Mount Senario, and Northwestern–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
West Georgia
|
—
|
1983
|
- Centennial Conference – Gettysburg, Muhlenberg, and Swarthmore
- College Athletic Conference – Centre and Rose–Hulman
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – St. Lawrence
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA) and Wartburg
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Susquehanna
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Lake Forest
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Massachusetts Maritime and Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Glassboro State, Montclair State, and Trenton State
- Northwest Conference – Pacific Lutheran
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace (Red Division), Wittenberg (Blue Division)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Carnegie Mellon
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – McMurry and Sul Ross State
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario and Northwestern (WI)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Eau Claire
|
Augustana (IL)
|
—
|
1984
|
- Centennial Conference – Gettysburg and Swarthmore
- College Athletic Conference – Centre
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central College (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Cornell College
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Hamline
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Case Western Reserve
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Randolph-Macon
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Austin
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–River Falls and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Augustana (IL)
|
—
|
1985
|
- Centennial Conference – Gettysburg
- College Athletic Conference – Centre and Rhodes
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State and Western Connecticut State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Denison
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry, Randolph-Macon, and Washington & Lee
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Carnegie Mellon
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Austin and Sul Ross State
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–River Falls
|
Augustana (IL)
|
—
|
1986
|
- Centennial Conference – Franklin & Marshall and Muhlenberg
- College Athletic Conference – Rose–Hulman
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Susquehanna
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Lawrence
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Denison
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Claremont–Mudd–Scripps
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Tarleton State
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse, Wisconsin–River Falls, and Wisconsin–Stevens Point
|
Augustana (IL)
|
—
|
1987
|
- Centennial Conference – Franklin & Marshall
- College Athletic Conference – Rhodes
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Independent College Athletic Conference‡ – Ithaca
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Susquehanna and Widener
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Gustavus Adolphus
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Kean
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Capital
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Claremont–Mudd–Scripps and Occidental
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Tarleton State
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–River Falls and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Wagner
|
—
|
1988
|
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson and Franklin & Marshall
- College Athletic Conference – Rose–Hulman
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL) and Carroll (WI)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Simpson
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian and Alma
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Moravian and Widener
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead and Hamline
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Trenton State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace and Wittenberg
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Austin
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Concordia–Saint Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Ithaca
|
—
|
1989
|
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson
- College Athletic Conference – Centre
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Millikin
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian and Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming and Susquehanna
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Bridgewater State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Kenyon and Ohio Wesleyan
- Ohio Athletic Conference – John Carroll
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Randolph-Macon
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Carnegie Mellon and Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Howard Payne and Tarleton State
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Dayton
|
—
|
1990
|
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson
- College Athletic Conference – Centre and Sewanee
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin –Augustana (IL) and Millikin
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – DePauw
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead and St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Plymouth State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Trenton State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Tarleton State
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Maranatha Baptist and Northwestern–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Allegheny
|
—
|
1991
|
- Association of Mideast Colleges – Thomas More
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Simpson
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Massachusetts–Lowell
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Glassboro State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Guilford
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Millsaps
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Midwestern State
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Concordia–St. Paul
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Ithaca
|
—
|
1992
|
- Association of Mideast Colleges – Thomas More
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan
- Freedom Football Conference – WPI
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Cornell College
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Carleton
- New England Football Conference – Bridgewater State
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Sewanee
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Howard Payne
- University Athletic Association – Rochester
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
—
|
1993
|
- Association of Mideast Colleges – Thomas More
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson and Franklin & Marshall
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Freedom Football Conference – WPI
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Anderson
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Wilkes
- Midwest Collegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Maine Maritime
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Randolph-Macon
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – La Verne
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hardin–Simmons
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Mount Union
|
Jim Ballard, Mount Union (QB)
|
1994
|
- Association of Mideast Colleges – Bluffton and Thomas More
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL) and Illinois Wesleyan
- Freedom Football Conference – Merchant Marine and Plymouth State
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover and Wabash
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Conference – Coe
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Maine Maritime and Massachusetts–Dartmouth
- New Jersey State Athletic Conference – Kean and Trenton State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Baldwin Wallace, John Carroll, and Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – La Verne
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association– Hardin–Simmons, Howard Payne, and Midwestern State
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon and Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Albion
|
Carey Bender, Coe (RB)
|
1995
|
- Association of Mideast Colleges‡ – Thomas More
- Centennial Conference – Franklin & Marshall
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Wheaton (IL)
- Freedom Football Conference – Plymouth State
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Conference – Cornell College
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead and Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Worcester State
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – La Verne
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Centre, Rhodes, and Trinity (TX)
- Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hardin–Simmons and Howard Payne
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon and Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – Union (NY)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
, St. John's (MN) (WR)
|
1996
|
- American Southwest Conference – Hardin–Simmons and Sul Ross State
- Centennial Conference – Ursinus
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan
- Freedom Football Conference – Coast Guard
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Lakeland
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – DePauw
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Simpson
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Conference – Ripon
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Worcester State
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – TCNJ
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Northwest Conference – Willamette
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Millsaps and Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon, Case Western Reserve, and Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Maranatha Baptist and Martin Luther
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – Union (NY)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Mount Union
|
, Illinois Wesleyan (QB)
|
1997
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mississippi College
- Centennial Conference – McDaniel
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Freedom Football Conference – Coast Guard and Springfield
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Lakeland
- Indiana Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Simpson
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Albright and Lycoming
- Midwest Conference – Carroll (WI)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Augsburg
- New England Football Conference – Bridgewater State and Worcester State
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny, Wittenberg, and Wooster
- Northwest Conference – Willamette
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry, Guilford, and Randolph-Macon
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Grove City
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – California Lutheran, Redlands, and Whittier
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Not available
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – RPI
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Mount Union
|
, Mount Union (QB)
|
1998
|
- American Southwest Conference – Hardin–Simmons
- Centennial Conference – McDaniel
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Millikin
- Freedom Football Conference – Springfield
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Aurora
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Conference – Grinnell
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Salve Regina (Blue Division), Bridgewater State (Red Division)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – TCNJ
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Northwest Conference – Pacific Lutheran
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Grove City, Washington & Jefferson, and Waynesburg
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Whittier
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Chicago
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Maranatha Baptist, Martin Luther, and Mount Senario
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – RPI
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Eau Claire, Wisconsin–River Falls, Wisconsin–Stevens Point, and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Mount Union
|
, Augsburg (WR, P)
|
1999
|
- American Southwest Conference – Hardin–Simmons
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Frostburg State
- Centennial Conference – McDaniel
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Freedom Football Conference – Western Connecticut State
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Aurora
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion, Alma, and Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Salve Regina (Blue Division), Bridgewater State (Red Division)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Northwest Conference – Willamette
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Catholic
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – RPI
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse and Wisconsin–Stevens Point
|
Pacific Lutheran
|
Danny Ragsdale, (QB)
|
2000
|
- American Southwest Conference – Hardin–Simmons
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – McDaniel
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan, Millikin, and Wheaton (IL)
- Dixie Intercollegiate Football Conference – No Champion Named
- Freedom Football Conference – Springfield
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Bluffton and Hanover
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Aurora
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Bethel (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Nichols and Salve Regina (Blue Division), Bridgewater State (Red Division)
- Championship Game: Bridgewater State 27, Salve Regina 24
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst, Colby, and Middlebury
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Emory & Henry
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – DePauw, Sewanee, and Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Chicago
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Mount Senario
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hobart, Rochester, and Union (NY)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Stout
|
Mount Union
|
, Pacific Lutheran (QB)
|
2001
|
- American Southwest Conference – Hardin–Simmons
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – McDaniel and Muhlenberg
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL) and Illinois Wesleyan
- Dixie Intercollegiate Football Conference – Christopher Newport and Ferrum
- Freedom Football Conference – Plymouth State and Western Connecticut State
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Anderson and Defiance
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – MacMurray
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Conference – Ripon and St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Bethel (MN) and Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Westfield State (Bogan Division), Nichols (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Westfield State 12, Nichols 0
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Williams
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Northwest Conference – Linfield, Pacific Lutheran, and Whitworth
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Bridgewater
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – RPI
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Eau Claire and Wisconsin–Stevens Point
|
Mount Union
|
, Mount Union (RB)
|
2002
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Frostburg State
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins, McDaniel, and Muhlenberg
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Wheaton (IL)
- Dixie Intercollegiate Football Conference – Christopher Newport and Ferrum
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca
- Freedom Football Conference – Springfield
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – MacMurray
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA), Coe, and Wartburg
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Alma
- Middle Atlantic Conference – King's College and Widener
- Midwest Conference – Lake Forest and St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Westfield State (Bogan Division), UMass Dartmouth (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: UMass Dartmouth 16, Westfield State 0
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Trinity (CT) and Williams
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Bridgewater
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hobart
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Mount Union
|
, Mount Union (RB)
|
2003
|
- American Southwest Conference – East Texas Baptist, Hardin–Simmons, and Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Frostburg State
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins and Muhlenberg
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Wheaton (IL)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca
- Freedom Football Conference‡ – Springfield
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hanover
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Concordia (WI)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Westfield State (Bogan Division), Curry (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Curry 36, Westfield State 0
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Trinity (CT)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Allegheny
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Bridgewater
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Waynesburg<
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Centre and Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Westminster (MO)
- Upstate Collegiate Athletic Conference – Hobart and RPI
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport and Shenandoah
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
St. John's (MN)
|
Blake Elliott, St. John's (MN) (WR, P, KR)
|
2004
|
- American Southwest Conference – Hardin–Simmons
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Salisbury
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson, Franklin & Marshall, Johns Hopkins, McDaniel, and Muhlenberg
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Carthage and Wheaton (IL)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca and St. John Fisher
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Mount St. Joseph
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Aurora, Concordia (WI), and Lakeland
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Coe and Wartburg
- Liberty League – Hobart
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Alma
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Concordia–Moorhead
- New England Football Conference – Fitchburg State (Bogan Division), Curry and Endicott (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Curry 17, Fitchburg State 7
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Trinity (CT)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wooster
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Bridgewater
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – DePauw and Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Westminster (MO)
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport and Shenandoah
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–La Crosse
|
Linfield
|
, Wesley (DE) (S)
|
2005
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – SUNY Brockport, Salisbury, and Wesley
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Mount St. Joseph
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Lakeland
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA) and Coe
- Liberty League – Union (NY)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley
- Midwest Conference – Monmouth (IL)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Fitchburg State (Bogan Division), Curry (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Curry 17, Fitchburg State 14 (2OT)
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Trinity (CT)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan and SUNY Cortland
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Bridgewater
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thiel
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Chicago
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- USA South Athletic Conference – Ferrum and Methodist
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Mount Union
|
Brett Elliott, Linfield (QB)
|
2006
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – Dickinson
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Augustana (IL), North Central (IL), and Wheaton (IL)
- Empire 8 Conference – St. John Fisher and Springfield
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Mount St. Joseph
- Illini-Badger Football Conference – Concordia (WI)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Liberty League – Hobart and Union (NY)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Wilkes
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Bethel (MN) and Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Coast Guard (Bogan Division), Curry (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Curry 34, Coast Guard 28
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Williams
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan and SUNY Cortland
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wabash and Wittenberg
- Northwest Conference – Whitworth
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Washington & Lee
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Millsaps
- University Athletic Association – Carnegie Mellon
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Minnesota–Morris
- USA South Athletic Conference – Averett and Christopher Newport
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Mount Union
|
, Alma (QB)
|
2007
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – Muhlenberg
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan and North Central (IL)
- Empire 8 Conference – Hartwick and St. John Fisher
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin
- Illini-Badger Football Conference‡ – Concordia (WI) and Lakeland
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Liberty League – Hobart and RPI
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Hope and Olivet
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Bethel (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Coast Guard (Bogan Division), Curry (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Curry 10, Coast Guard 7
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Middlebury
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – SUNY Cortland and TCNJ
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Northwest Conference – Whitworth
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – California Lutheran and Redlands
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Millsaps and Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Case Western Reserve
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- USA South Athletic Conference – North Carolina Wesleyan
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Justin Beaver, Wisconsin–Whitewater (RB)
|
2008
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – Muhlenberg
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – North Central (IL)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg
- Liberty League – Hobart
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Trine
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Albright, Delaware Valley, and Lycoming
- Midwest Conference – Monmouth (IL)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Bridgewater State and Maine Maritime (Bogan Division), Plymouth State (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Plymouth State 46, Maine Maritime 16
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Trinity (CT)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – SUNY Cortland
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Aurora
- Northwest Conference – Willamette
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Catholic, Emory & Henry, Hampden–Sydney, and Randolph-Macon
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thomas More
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Occidental
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Millsaps
- University Athletic Association – Case Western Reserve
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Northwestern–St. Paul
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Stevens Point and Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Mount Union
|
, Mount Union (QB)
|
2009
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor and Mississippi College
- Atlantic Central Football Conference – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Illinois Wesleyan and North Central (IL)
- Eastern Collegiate Football Conference – Norwich
- Empire 8 Conference – Alfred and St. John Fisher and
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Mount St. Joseph
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Central (IA)
- Liberty League – Susquehanna and Union (NY)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Trine
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley
- Midwest Conference – Monmouth (IL)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Maine Maritime (Bogan Division), Curry (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Maine Maritime 48, Curry 42
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Montclair State
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Lakeland
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thomas More
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – California Lutheran
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – DePauw and Millsaps
- University Athletic Association – Case Western Reserve
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Martin Luther and Greenville
- USA South Athletic Conference – North Carolina Wesleyan
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
, Augustana (IL) (OT)
|
2010
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Atlantic Central Football Conference‡ – Wesley
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins, Muhlenberg, and Ursinus
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – North Central (IL)
- Eastern Collegiate Football Conference – SUNY Maritime
- Empire 8 Conference – Alfred
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg
- Liberty League – St. Lawrence
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Trine
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Framingham State and Maine Maritime (Bogan Division), Western New England (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Endicott 38, Maine Maritime 35
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Williams
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Montclair State, Rowan, and SUNY Cortland
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Benedictine (IL)
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Washington & Lee
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thomas More
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – California Lutheran
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – DePauw
- University Athletic Association – Chicago
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Greenville
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport and North Carolina Wesleyan
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
, Trine (QB)
|
2011
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – North Central (IL)
- Eastern Collegiate Football Conference – Norwich
- Empire 8 Conference – Salisbury
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Dubuque
- Liberty League – Hobart and Union (NY)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Delaware Valley
- Midwest Conference – Monmouth (IL)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Framingham State (Bogan Division), Western New England (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Western New England 20, Framingham State 13 (OT)
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Kean
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wabash
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Benedictine (IL) and Concordia Chicago
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney and Washington & Lee
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thomas More
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – California Lutheran
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Case Western Reserve
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – St. Scholastica
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
, Dubuque (WR)
|
2012
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Elmhurst, North Central (IL), and Wheaton (IL)
- Eastern Collegiate Football Conference – Castleton State and Mount Ida
- Empire 8 Conference – Salisbury
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Coe
- Liberty League – Hobart
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener
- Midwest Conference – Lake Forest and St. Norbert
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – St. Thomas (MN)
- New England Football Conference – Framingham State (Bogan Division), Endicott and Salve Regina (Boyd Division)
- Championship Game: Framingham State 28, Salve Regina 16
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Trinity (CT)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – SUNY Cortland
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Ohio Wesleyan and Wittenberg
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Concordia Chicago
- Northwest Conference – Linfield
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Washington & Lee
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson and Waynesburg
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – California Lutheran
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Trinity (TX)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – Greenville, Northwestern–St. Paul, and St. Scholastica
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport, Ferrum, and Maryville (TN)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Oshkosh
|
Mount Union
|
, Elmhurst (IL) (RB)
|
2013
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor (13–1, 6–0)
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins (10–1, 9–0)
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – North Central (IL) (13–1, 7–0)
- Eastern Collegiate Football Conference – Gallaudet (9–2, 6–1)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca (9–3, 6–1)
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin (8–4, 7–1) and Rose–Hulman (7–3, 7–1)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg (9–3, 6–1)
- Liberty League – Hobart (10–1, 7–0)
- Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference – Framingham State (9–2, 8–0)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Albion (8–3, 6–0)
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Lycoming (7–3, 7–2) and Lebanon Valley (8–3, 7–2)
- Midwest Conference – St. Norbert (8–3, 8–1)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Bethel (MN) (12–1, 8–0)
- New England Football Conference – Endicott (8–3, 7–0)
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst (7–1, 7–1), Middlebury (7–1, 7–1), and Wesleyan (CT) (7–1, 7–1)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Rowan (9–3, 6–1) and Brockport State (8–3, 6–1)
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg (10–2, 9–0)
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Concordia (WI) (8–3, 6–0)
- Northwest Conference – Linfield (11–1, 6–0)
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union (14–1, 9–0)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney (9–3, 6–1)
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Thomas More (9–1, 7–1) and Washington & Jefferson (8–3, 7–1)
- Southern Athletic Association – Millsaps (9–1, 5–1) and Rhodes (8–2, 5–1)
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Redlands (7–3, 7–0)
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Texas Lutheran (8–1, 3–0)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis (8–3, 3–0)
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – St. Scholastica (9–2, 9–0)
- USA South Athletic Conference – Methodist (8–2, 6–1) and Maryville (TN) (8–3, 6–1)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater (15–0, 7–0)
|
Wisconsin–Whitewater
|
Kevin Burke, Mount Union (QB)
|
2014
|
- American Southwest Conference – Mary Hardin–Baylor (9–0, 4–0)
- Centennial Conference – Johns Hopkins (9–0, 8–0)
- College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin – Wheaton (IL) (9–0, 6–0)
- Eastern Collegiate Football Conference – Husson (8–2, 7–0)
- Empire 8 Conference – Ithaca (7–2, 6–2)
- Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference – Franklin (7–0, 7–2)
- Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wartburg (9–0, 6–0)
- Liberty League – Hobart (9–0, 6–0)
- Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference – Framingham State (10–1, 8–0)
- Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association – Adrian (8–3, 5–1)
- Middle Atlantic Conference – Widener (12–0, 9–0)
- Midwest Conference ��� Macalester (9–2, 5–0)
- Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Saint John's (MN) (10–2, 7–1)
- New England Football Conference – MIT (8–3, 7–0)
- New England Small College Athletic Conference – Amherst (8–0, 8–0)
- New Jersey Athletic Conference – Morrisville State (9–2, 6–1), Montclair State (8–2, 6–1), and Rowan (7–4, 6–1)
- North Coast Athletic Conference – Wittenberg (8–1, 8–0)
- Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference – Wisconsin Lutheran (7–3, 5–1)
- Northwest Conference – Linfield (10–1, 6–1)
- Ohio Athletic Conference – Mount Union (12–0, 9–0)
- Old Dominion Athletic Conference – Hampden–Sydney (7–4, 5–2)
- Presidents' Athletic Conference – Washington & Jefferson (9–0, 7–0)
- Southern Athletic Association – Centre (10–1, 6–0)
- Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Chapman (7–1, 6–0)
- Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference – Texas Lutheran (8–1, 2–0)
- University Athletic Association – Washington–Saint Louis (8–3, 3–0)
- Upper Midwest Athletic Conference – St. Scholastica (10–0, 9–0)
- USA South Athletic Conference – Christopher Newport (8–2, 6–1)
- Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference – Wisconsin–Whitewater (9–0, 6–0)
|
—
|
—
|