- 1957: Michigan (, , , Hanley)
1957: Michigan State (, , , )
- 1958: Yale (, Jecko, , )
- 1959: Michigan (, , Gillanders, Hanley)
- 1960: Indiana (McKinney, , Troy, )
- 1961: Ohio State (, , , )
- 1962: Ohio State (, , , )
- 1963: Minnesota (, Luken, Richardson, )
- 1964: USC (Bennett, Craig, , Saari)
- 1965: Indiana (, Trethewey, Schmidt, )
- 1966: Michigan (, , , )
- 1967: UCLA (, , , Zorn)
- 1968: UT Arlington (Russell, , , )
- 1969: Indiana (Hickox, Counsilman, , )
- 1970: Stanford (, Job, Ferris, )
- 1971: Stanford (, Job, Ferris, )
- 1972: USC (, , Heckl, )
- 1973: Tennessee (, , , )
- 1974: Tennessee (, , , )
- 1975: USC (Naber, Chatfield, Bottom, )
- 1976: USC (Naber, , Bottom, Bottom)
- 1977: Indiana (Arantes, , , Montgomery)
- 1978: California (Rocca, Smith, Arvidsson, )
- 1979: California (Rocca, Smith, Arvidsson, )
- 1980: Texas (, Spann, Paulus, Kirchner)
- 1981: Texas (, Spann, Paulus, Kirchner)
- 1982: Texas (, Nevid, Paulus, )
- 1983: SMU (, Lundquist, , )
- 1984: Texas (Carey, , , )
- 1985: Stanford (, Moffet, Morales, )
- 1986: Stanford (Murphy, Moffet, Morales, )
- 1987: Stanford (Mortenson, , Morales, )
- 1988: Texas (, Stackle, , Jacobs)
- 1989: Texas (, Dersch, , Gjertsen)
- 1990: Texas (, Stackle, Jordan, Gjertsen)
- 1991: Florida (Zubero, , Nesty, )
- 1992: Stanford (Rouse, , , Retterer)
- 1993: Stanford (, , , Retterer)
- 1994: Stanford (Rouse, , Carey, Hudepohl)
- 1995: Stanford (Retterer, Grote, Muhammad, Hudepohl)
- 1996: Tennessee (, Linn, , Busquets)
- 1997: Auburn (, , Hargis, )
- 1998: Stanford (, Wilkens, Muhammad, )
- 1999: Auburn (, , , Hawke)
- 2001: Texas (Dusing, Hansen, Hannan, Crocker)
- 2002: Stanford (Marshall, , , Bal)
- 2003: Texas (Peirsol, Hansen, Crocker, )
- 2005: Stanford (Cramer, , , Wildman-Tobriner)
- 2006: Arizona (Thoman, , Subirats, )
- 2007: Northwestern (Grevers, Alexandrov, , )
- 2008: Arizona (Subirats, , Townsend, Joel Greenshields)
- 2009: Auburn (Wollach, Klein, McGill, Targett)
- 2010: California (Barnea, Dugonjič, Shields, )
- 2011: California (Barnea, Dugonjič, Shields, Adrian)
- 2012: California (Gydesen, , Shields, )
- 2013: Arizona (, Cordes, Smith, Shapira Bar-Or)
- 2014: California (Murphy, , Tarczyński, Stubblefield)
- 2015: Texas (, Licon, Schooling, Conger)
- 2016: Texas (Shebat, Licon, Schooling, Conger)
- 2017: Texas (Shebat, Licon, Schooling, Conger)
- 2018: Indiana (, Finnerty, Lanza, Pieroni)
- 2019: Indiana (, Finnerty, Lanza, Apple)
2020
- 2021: Texas (, Corbeau, , Krueger)
|