2000
|
Boston Society of Film Critics
|
Best Actor(3rd place)
|
You Can Count On Me
|
Won
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
|
New Generation Award
|
Won
|
Montreal World Film Festival
|
Best Actor[citation needed]
|
Won
|
National Society of Film Critics
|
Best Actor (2nd place)
|
Won
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor (2nd place)
|
Won
|
Toronto Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor (2nd place)
|
Won
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Independent Spirit Awards
|
Best Male Lead
|
Nominated
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2004
|
Teen Choice Awards
|
Choice Movie Actor – Comedy
|
13 Going on 30
|
Nominated
|
Teen Choice Award for Choice Movie Chemistry (with Jennifer Garner)
|
Nominated
|
Choice Movie Liplock (with Jennifer Garner)
|
Nominated
|
2006
|
Tony Awards
|
Best Featured Actor in a Play
|
Awake and Sing
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor in a Canadian Film
|
Blindness
|
Nominated
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Actor – Motion Picture
|
What Doesn't Kill You
|
Nominated
|
2009
|
Sundance Film Festival
|
Special Jury Prize[citation needed]
|
Sympathy for Delicious
|
Won
|
2010
|
Boston Society of Film Critics
|
Best Cast (2nd place)
|
The Kids Are All Right
|
Won
|
New York Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
Academy Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
BAFTA Awards
|
Best Actor in a Supporting Role
|
Nominated
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Best Cast
|
Nominated
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Gotham Awards
|
Best Ensemble Performance
|
Nominated
|
Independent Spirit Awards
|
Best Supporting Male
|
Nominated
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Screen Actors Guild
|
Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture
|
Nominated
|
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role
|
Nominated
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
|
Best Ensemble
|
Nominated
|
Saturn Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Shutter Island
|
Nominated
|
Scream Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
MTV Movie Awards
|
Best Fight
|
The Avengers
|
Won
|
Best Hero
|
Nominated
|
Best On-Screen Duo (with Robert Downey, Jr.)[1]
|
Nominated
|
Choice Hissy Fit
|
Nominated
|
2014
|
Primetime Emmy Awards
|
Outstanding Television Movie (co-executive producer)[2]
|
The Normal Heart
|
Won
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Actor – Miniseries or Television Film
|
Won
|
Screen Actors Guild
|
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Miniseries or Television Movie
|
Won
|
Critics' Choice Television Awards
|
Best Actor in a Movie/Miniseries
|
Nominated
|
Golden Globe Awards
|
Best Actor – Miniseries or Television Film
|
Nominated
|
Primetime Emmy Awards
|
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie
|
Nominated
|
Hollywood Film Awards
|
Hollywood Film Ensemble Award
|
Foxcatcher
|
Won
|
Gotham Independent Film Awards
|
Special Jury Award for Ensemble Performance
|
Won
|
AACTA International Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Academy Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
BAFTA Awards
|
Best Actor in a Supporting Role
|
Nominated
|
Golden Globe Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture
|
Nominated
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
San Francisco Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture
|
Nominated
|
Screen Actors Guilds
|
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role
|
Nominated
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2015
|
Golden Globe Awards
|
Best Actor – Motion Picture Musical or Comedy
|
Infinitely Polar Bear
|
Nominated
|
Critics' Choice Movie Awards
|
Critics' Choice Movie Award for Best Acting Ensemble
|
Spotlight
|
Won
|
Gotham Independent Film Awards
|
Special Jury Award for Ensemble Performance
|
Won
|
Independent Spirit Awards
|
Robert Altman Award for Best Ensemble
|
Won
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Cast in a Motion Picture
|
Won
|
Screen Actors Guilds
|
Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture
|
Won
|
Academy Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor[3]
|
Nominated
|
BAFTA Awards
|
Best Actor in a Supporting Role
|
Nominated
|
Critics' Choice Movie Awards
|
Best Actor in a Supporting Role
|
Nominated
|
Florida Film Critics Circle
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Houston Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture
|
Nominated
|
St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Association
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
2018
|
Grammy Awards
|
Best Spoken Word Album[4]
|
Our Revolution: A Future to Believe In
|
Nominated
|
MTV Movie & TV Awards
|
Best Fight (with Chris Hemsworth)
|
Thor: Ragnarok
|
Nominated
|
Teen Choice Awards
|
Choice Sci-Fi Movie Actor
|
Nominated
|
2019
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Actor, Drama
|
Dark Waters
|
Nominated
|
2020
|
Primetime Emmy Awards
|
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited Series or Movie[5]
|
I Know This Much Is True
|
Won
|
TCA Awards
|
Individual Achievement in Drama
|
Nominated
|
2021
|
Critics' Choice Television Awards
|
Best Actor in a Movie/Miniseries
|
Nominated
|
Golden Globe Awards
|
Best Actor – Miniseries or Television Film[6]
|
Won
|
Satellite Awards
|
Best Actor in a Miniseries or TV Film
|
Nominated
|
Screen Actors Guild Awards
|
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Miniseries or Television Movie
|
Won
|