Vincent Bevan

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
For the Canadian policeman, see Vince Bevan.

Vincent David Bevan
Vincent Bevan 1953.jpg
Vincent Bevan in 1953
Birth nameVincent David Bevan
Date of birth(1921-12-24)24 December 1921
Place of birthOtaki, New Zealand
Date of death26 May 1996(1996-05-26) (aged 74)
Place of deathWellington, New Zealand
Height1.65 m (5 ft 5 in)
Weight72 kg (159 lb)
SchoolOtaki Convent School
Notable relative(s) (half-brother)
Keith Davis (cousin)
Tamati Ellison (grandson)
Jacob Ellison (grandson)
Occupation(s)Café owner, carpenter, milk vendor[1] and taxi proprietor[2]
Rugby union career
Position(s) Halfback
All Black No. 479
Provincial / State sides
Years Team Apps (Points)
1943–54 Wellington 75[5] (32[3][4])
National team(s)
Years Team Apps (Points)
1947–54 New Zealand 25[7] (3[6])

Vincent David Bevan (24 December 1921 – 26 May 1996) was a New Zealand rugby union player.

Early life[]

Bevan was born in the Horowhenua at Otaki, about halfway between Wellington and Palmerston North, and was the son of Winifred Bevan and Lewis Homes.

Playing career[]

Bevan served in the North African and Italian campaigns during World War II and played for the 22nd New Zealand Battalion team (winners of the Freyberg Cup in 1944), the 9th Brigade and 8th Army XVs and the 7th Brigade Group (1942).[8][9]

The final of the 1944 Freyberg Cup was contested in early December in the ruins of the Fascist Stadium in Forlì in Italy.[10] A tense game was played between the 22nd Battalion team and the 2nd New Zealand Division Ammunition Company.[11] The match was vigorous, the ground conditions atrocious and the day bitingly cold.[12] It was a tough contest with little opportunity for the backs to shine.[13] Bevan displayed good form and threw a pass to his captain, Lin Thomas, who kicked the dropped goal from the only dry spot on the ground and won the game for the 22nd Battalion, 4–0.[14]

Bevan played for Wellington College Old Boys before being selected by the former All Black Alex McDonald to represent the Wellington Rugby Football Union at a provincial level.[15] He wasn't always the first choice halfback for Wellington, being bumped from the top spot in 1946 by Dr Manahi Nitama Paewai.[16] In 1947, Bevan made the first of his four appearances for the North Island in the annual interisland match.[17]

He was a member of the New Zealand national side, the All Blacks, from 1947 to 1954. But for injury, (Bevan had either fallen from a truck[18] or had been hit by a truck near the front line at the end of the War[19]), he may well have played for the famous New Zealand team which in 1945–46 toured Britain and France.[20] The trials for the team were held in Austria and Bevan had shown such good form that his selection had been a certainty.[21]

Bevan's official All Blacks profile says that "he is best remembered for games he didn't play and the tour he was not allowed to go on. Bevan's career, indeed, is one of the starkest examples of some of the gross stupidities, even injustices, New Zealand rugby created for itself by trying for too long to fit in with the colour bar, later formalised as apartheid, being enforced in South Africa. Bevan should have been the All Blacks' number one halfback on the tour of South Africa in 1949, but an inadvertent reference to his trace of Māori ancestry a year or two beforehand meant he was ruled ineligible to be selected".[22]

His first two test caps came instead in the 1949 series against Australia that was played in New Zealand. This tour coincided with the stronger though Māori-free All Blacks team touring South Africa. Bevan played all four tests the following year against the touring British Lions. Injuries prevented him from touring with the 1951 All Blacks to Australia.[23] Bevan was a member of the 1953–54 New Zealand rugby union tour of the United Kingdom, Ireland, France and North America and played capably enough during his 16 appearances.[24] But with age he was losing a little of his speed and his cousin, Keith Davis, his junior by nearly 10 years, was preferred for all five internationals.[25]

In total, Bevan played 25 matches for the All Blacks including six tests.[26] His only points for the All Blacks came in a match at Manchester on 17 February 1954 when he scored a try in a 17–3 win against North-Western Counties.[27]

During his first-class career, Bevan played for Wellington College Old Boys (1943), Athletic (1946–49), Tawa (1950–51), Athletic (1953–54), North Island (1947–49, 53), NZ Trials (1947, 50, 53) and the New Zealand XV (1949).[28] He built a good club partnership with Bill Freeman who would later become a highly successful coach for Wellington.[29] Freeman, at first five-eighths, was the grateful recipient of Bevan's renowned dive-pass.[30]

In 75 matches for Wellington, Bevan scored seven tries, two conversions and two dropped goals.[31] His first try for Wellington came in the 1943 season against Canterbury.[32] Two of Bevan's tries came in Ranfurly Shield matches for Wellington during the 1953 season against Otago and Taranaki respectively. Against Taranaki at Athletic Park, Wellington on 29 August 1953, the Wellington forwards "asserted their mastery...[and] the speedy backline had a feast of ball and treated the crowd to spectacular rugby".[33] During the game, Bevan was "a livewire link between the forwards and backs".[34] Up 18–0 at halftime, Wellington won the match 26–3.

Bevan rounded out his long career with several appearances in festival-type matches for the Centurions (1952, 55–56),[35] bringing his first class match tally to 121 [36] with a total of 11 tries, two conversions and two dropped goals.[37]

Test matches and playing style[]

Vincent Bevan in 1949

Alex McDonald had originally been impressed by Bevan's strength, quickness, length of pass and hard-nosed application and was part of the selection panel that sent him to Australia as an All Black in 1947.[38] Although Bevan played well, he failed to make the test lineup in the two-match series, with Auckland's Percy Tetzlaff preferred.[39]

Against Australia, in the second test in the 1949 series that was played at Eden Park in Auckland on 24 September 1949, Bevan gave away several penalties but played a rugged game and his passing was generally good,[40] although Australia scored after nineteen minutes when Bevan threw a wild pass to Jack McLean on the blindside near his own line.[41] The All Blacks lost the test 16–9.

The first test against the Lions in the 1950 series was played at Carisbrook in Dunedin on 27 May 1950. As the All Black forwards started to show improvement, Bevan received a ball quickly from a scrum, which he gathered and started a run wide across the field on the open side.[42] In an attempt to beat the Lions defence, he gave the ball a tap with his foot but it bounced head high and Jack Kyle had it for the Lions.[43] In a flash he was through the All Blacks, and racing for the line 25 yards away.[44] A shoulder-high tackle by Nau Cherrington stopped him for only an instant before he was over the line.[45] Later in the game, George Beatty received a pass from Bevan about the twenty-five.[46] With the pace on Beatty passed to Roy Roper, who beat four men and scored a few yards from the corner.[47] With seven minutes left, Bob Scott came up into a rush and kicked high toward the Lions' goal before a scrum was then ordered not more than 10 yards from the post.[48] Ron Elvidge called for a pass from Bevan down the blindside which he received and away went the All Black captain on an irresistible dash for the corner past at least three defenders.[49] Elvidge crashed over for the try and the match ended with the scores tied at 9–9.

In the third test against the Lions at Athletic Park in Wellington on 1 July 1950, Bevan played behind an All Black pack of six, which was shredded by injury and the no-replacement law of the day.[50] The match provided the stirring spectacle of the six All Black forwards battling against eight, and a team of 13 physically effective players gaining the mastery of 15.[51] Bevan scolded, spurred and cajoled the pack and showed a perception of pressure points, breadth and alacrity of clearance and physical toughness that were telling factors in transforming a mission impossible into a day of glory for New Zealand rugby.[52] The second half of the match was only a few minutes old when a touch finder from Bevan brought the All Blacks into the Lion's twenty-five on the right flank.[53] He then sensed a half-chance out to his left and the ball was spun through the backs which led to the winning try by the injured All Black captain, Elvidge.[54] The All Blacks won the test 6–3.

The fourth and final test was played at Eden Park in Auckland on 29 July 1950. Early on, Bevan shot through a gap and Graham Mexted carried on almost to the Lion's goal-line.[55] Later in the match Richard White led a good movement and the Lion's line was close at hand when Bevan ran from a scrum, only to be swamped.[56] Bevan then sparkled with two dashing breaks and Bill Meates almost scored from the second.[57] The final score was 11–8 to the All Blacks.

Bevan based his passing game on his swiftness to retrieve ball hooked at high velocity and on a swivelling dive-pass that foiled marauders and spoilers.[58] He was quick to respond to physical affront, real or imagined, and employed a devastating hip-throw that felled and humiliated many unsuspecting locks and props steamrolling with belligerent intent through the lineout.[59]

Bevan had an innate rugby sense and once saved a Ranfurly Shield match for Wellington by potting a goal from the base of the scrum about twenty five metres out.[60] He was a quick and neat passer and ran well from the scrum or ruck and was a good all-round player.[61]

Controversial non-selections[]

Bevan lost some of the best years of his career when international rugby was mothballed during and after World War II.[62] The All Blacks played just four tests between 1939 and the 1949 tour to South Africa.[63]

The nuggety Bevan was widely considered New Zealand's best halfback of the immediate post-war period.[64] He wasn't selected for the All Blacks tour of South Africa in 1949, however, as the Māori Advisory Council had informed the New Zealand Rugby Football Union that he had Māori ancestry.[65] Bevan's mother was half Māori and once that became known New Zealand's best halfback was ruled ineligible for the tour, where race rules in South Africa at the time meant rugby was strictly for Europeans.[66] New Zealand was beaten in all four tests for various reasons, not the least the lack of a top halfback.[67]

Māori players who may have made the All Blacks tour of South Africa also included Nau Cherrington, Ron Bryers, Ben Couch and Johnny Smith.[68] The captain, Fred Allen (rugby union), later mourned the loss of Smith and in particular Bevan from the tour.[69]

Prior to the tour, the Member of Parliament for Northern Māori, Tapihana Paraire (T. P.) Paikea, used the Budget debate in Parliament to comment on the exclusion of the Māori players.[70] He drew attention to the plight of Bevan, who was not eligible for the Māori team which visited Fiji in 1949 because he had too little Māori blood, but was now prevented from going to South Africa because he had too much Māori blood.[71]

It was said that Bevan was not considered by Māori of the time to have enough Māori blood to be a Māori All Black.[72][73] He never once appeared for a New Zealand Māori selection or in any Māori match such as a Prince of Wales Cup trial.[74]

Involvement in opposition to the 1960 All Black tour to South Africa[]

Bevan, along with other sports people, academics, well-known church and Māori leaders, and trade unionists, sponsored the petition organized by the Citizens' All Black Tour Association that called for the abandonment of the 1960 All Black tour to South Africa and for the government to intervene.[75] This was because the New Zealand Rugby Football Union had decided, as it had done in the past, that it would be in the best interests of Māori players that they should not be selected for the tour.[76] The petition gained 153,000 signatures[77] but was largely ignored by the Union and the government.[78]

Together with George Nēpia and Manahi Nitama Paewai,[79] Bevan was a member of a fifty person deputation that met with Prime Minister Walter Nash and the leader of the Opposition, Jack Marshall,[80] calling for the cancellation of the tour.[81] This protest, which took place on 26 February 1960, had been led by the Association's chairman, Dr Rolland O'Regan,[82] but it did not succeed; the 1960 tour went ahead as planned.[83]

References[]

  1. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  2. ^ Registrar of Electors 1981, p. 7.
  3. ^ Swan & Jackson 1952.
  4. ^ Wellington Rugby History. 1951–1979. (Part II – The Completion of 100 Years) 1979.
  5. ^ Wellington Rugby History. 1951–1979. (Part II – The Completion of 100 Years) 1979, p. 150.
  6. ^ Knight 2014.
  7. ^ Knight 2014.
  8. ^ Chester, McMillan & Palenski 2005, p. 25.
  9. ^ Palenski 2014, p. 43.
  10. ^ Whatman 2005, p. 27.
  11. ^ Whatman 2005, p. 27.
  12. ^ Whatman 2005, p. 27.
  13. ^ Whatman 2005, p. 27.
  14. ^ Whatman 2005, p. 27.
  15. ^ Versey 1996, p. A9.
  16. ^ Mulholland 2009, p. 90.
  17. ^ Knight 2014.
  18. ^ Whatman 2005, p. 28.
  19. ^ Mulholland 2009, p. 90.
  20. ^ Knight 2014.
  21. ^ McCarthy 1968, p. 179.
  22. ^ Knight 2014.
  23. ^ Knight 2014.
  24. ^ Knight 2014.
  25. ^ Knight 2014.
  26. ^ Knight 2014.
  27. ^ Knight 2014.
  28. ^ Chester, McMillan & Palenski 2005, p. 25.
  29. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  30. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  31. ^ Wellington Rugby History. 1951–1979. (Part II – The Completion of 100 Years) 1979.
  32. ^ Swan & Jackson 1952, p. 112.
  33. ^ White 2014.
  34. ^ White 2014.
  35. ^ Palenski 2014, p. 43.
  36. ^ Knight 2014.
  37. ^ Akers 2016.
  38. ^ Versey 1996, p. A9.
  39. ^ Knight 2014.
  40. ^ Chester & McMillan 1978, p. 156.
  41. ^ Chester & McMillan 1978, p. 156.
  42. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 39.
  43. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 39.
  44. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 39.
  45. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 39.
  46. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 39.
  47. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 39.
  48. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 40.
  49. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 40.
  50. ^ Versey 1996, p. A9.
  51. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 55.
  52. ^ Versey 1996, p. A9.
  53. ^ Alderson 2017.
  54. ^ Palenski 2005, p. 65.
  55. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 54.
  56. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 55.
  57. ^ Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks 2005, p. 56.
  58. ^ Versey 1996, p. A9.
  59. ^ Versey 1996, p. A9.
  60. ^ Zavos 1979, p. 126.
  61. ^ Zavos 1979, p. 219.
  62. ^ Smith 2010.
  63. ^ Smith 2010.
  64. ^ Smith 2010.
  65. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  66. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  67. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  68. ^ Mulholland 2009, p. 102.
  69. ^ Mulholland 2009, p. 102.
  70. ^ Richards 1999, p. 17.
  71. ^ Richards 1999, p. 17.
  72. ^ Ogilvie 1996, p. 9.
  73. ^ Ryan 1949, p. 8.
  74. ^ Knight 2014.
  75. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.
  76. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.
  77. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.
  78. ^ Richards 1999, p. 23.
  79. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.
  80. ^ Richards 1999, p. 22.
  81. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.
  82. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.
  83. ^ McEldowney 2006, p. 306.

Sources[]

  • Akers, C., New Zealand Rugby Register 1870-2015: The Players, Referees and Administrators in First Class Rugby. New Zealand Rugby Museum, Palmerston North, 2016.
  • Alderson, Andrew (15 April 2017). "Ron Elvidge: Career ended with series-clinching try". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 4 June 2018.
  • Chester, R. and McMillan, N.A.C., Men in Black. Moa Beckett Publishers Limited, Auckland, 1978.
  • Chester, R., McMillan, N. and Palenski, R., The Encyclopedia of New Zealand Rugby. Hachette Livre NZ Limited, Auckland, 2005.
  • Knight, Lindsay. "Vince Bevan". New Zealand Rugby Museum. Retrieved 29 May 2014.
  • McCarthy, W., Haka! The All Blacks Story. Pelham Books Ltd, London, 1968.
  • McEldowney, W.J., Geoffrey Alley, Librarian. His Life and Work. Victoria University Press, Wellington, 2006.
  • Mulholland, M., Beneath the Maori Moon: An Illustrated History of Maori Rugby. Huia Publishers, Wellington, 2009.
  • Ogilvie, D., Ancestry cost him All Black tour. The Evening Post (New Zealand), Thursday, 30 May 1996, p. 9.
  • Palenski, R., All Blacks v Lions. Hodder Moa Beckett Publishers Ltd, Auckland, 2005.
  • Palenski, R., All Blackography: the indispensable guide to every All Black. Upstart Press, Auckland, 2014.
  • Registrar of Electors, Porirua electoral district composite roll. Porirua, 1981, p. 7.
  • Richards, T., Dancing on our bones: New Zealand, South Africa, rugby and racism. Bridget Williams Books, Wellington, 1999.
  • Rivals. 75 Years of the Lions v All Blacks. [From the archives of the] New Zealand Herald, Random House New Zealand, 2005.
  • Ryan, L., N.Z. battling to build up test team. Sunday Herald (Sydney), Sunday, 14 August 1949, p. 8.
  • Smith, T., More for NZRU to do after apology. The Press, Saturday, 22 May 2010.
  • Swan, A.C. and Jackson, G.F.W., Wellington Rugby History 1870–1950. A. H. & A. W. Reed, Wellington, 1952.
  • Versey, A., Gritty All Black never did things by halves. The Sunday Star-Times, Sunday, 2 June 1996, p. A9.
  • Wellington Rugby History. 1951–1979. (Part II – The Completion of 100 Years). Wellington Rugby Football Union, Wellington, 1979.
  • Whatman, M., Khaki All Blacks. A Tribute to the 'Kiwis' – The 2nd NZEF Army Rugby Team. Hodder Moa Beckett Publishers Ltd, Auckland, 2005.
  • White, Steven (2 October 2014). "Wellington v Taranaki 1953: the high point of a golden year". College Rugby. Retrieved 4 June 2018.
  • Zavos, S., After the Final Whistle. Mourie's 'Grand-Slam' All Blacks...and the Controversies, Personalities and Tactics of Post-War New Zealand Rugby. Fourth Estate Books Limited, Wellington, 1979.
Retrieved from ""