2020–2022 Ethiopian–Sudanese clashes

2020–2022 Ethiopian–Sudanese clashes
Part of spillover of the Tigray War
Date 15 December 2020 – present Location Al-Fashaga near the Ethiopia–Sudan border Result Ongoing Sudan claims to have recaptured all of the border territory with Ethiopia[4][5] Both Sudan and Ethiopia have sent military reinforcements to the border.[6][7]
Belligerents
Sudan	Amhara militias  Ethiopia ENDF (alleged) Amhara Region (alleged)  Eritrea (alleged)[1]	Tigray[2] Tigrayan militias/refugees[3]
Commanders and leaders
Abdel Fattah al-Burhan Walid Ahmad al-Sajjan Bahaa El-Din Youssef  (POW)	Sahle-Work Zewde Abiy Ahmed Isaias Afwerki	Debretsion Gebremichael Fetlework Gebregziabher Tadesse Werede Tesfay
Units involved
SAF RSF	ENDF EDF	TDF
Strength
6,000[8]	Unknown Unknown Unknown	Unknown
Casualties and losses
90 servicemen killed[9] 1 officer captured[10]	45 Amhara militiamen captured[2]	At least 10 civilians killed (Sudanese claim)[11][12][13]

The 2020–2022 Ethiopian–Sudanese clashes are clashes between Sudan and Ethiopia together with Amhara militants and Eritrea in the disputed border region of al-Fashaga (an area of Sudan east of the Atbara River and South of the Tekeze River).^[14] Since 2008 Ethiopia has dropped all claims to the al-Fashaga as long as Sudan allowed Ethiopian farmers and militants to stay in the area undisturbed. With the outbreak of the Tigray War, Sudanese forces were able to move into the region due to an agreement with Ethiopia just three days before. When the Amhara militants left to assist the federal government in the war, Sudanese forces started to drive out the Ethiopian farmers, including the Amhara, effectively breaking the 2008 compromise. Ethiopia has also accused Sudan of killing Amhara farmers.^[15][16]

The clashes first began in the area along the Ethiopia–Sudan border on 15 December 2020 when Amhara militants allegedly backed by the Ethiopian government ambushed several Sudanese military officers, killing 4 of them.^[17][18] Since then, Sudan has recaptured most of the disputed border. Despite it still being legally Sudanese territory the Amhara region has called Sudanese deployment an invasion and has said that al-Fashaga belonged to Ethiopia's Amhara region. Abiy Ahmed has made statements supporting that claim. Because of Sudan kicking out the Amhara militants, Sudanese farmers have begun to cultivate their land for the first time in 25 years.^[14] The Amhara militants have also been killing Sudanese farmers.^[16]

Background[]

In 1902, British-ruled Sudan and the Ethiopian Empire signed a treaty to properly demarcate the border, but it failed as some areas along the border were left unresolved.^[19] In both the 1902 and a later 1907 treaty the international boundary runs to the east which means the land of al-Fashaga is Sudanese but Ethiopians had already settled the area and had already been cultivating there along with paying taxes to the Ethiopian government.^[15]

After the Eritrean–Ethiopian War Ethiopia and Sudan began long-dormant talks to settle the exact location of their 744 km-long (462 miles) border. With the most difficult area to agree on being the al-Fashaga region.^[15]

In 2008, they reached a compromise. Ethiopia agreed to the al-Fashaga region being a part of Sudan but Amhara farmers would still be allowed to continue living there undisturbed. Tigrayans farmers in the northern regions of al-Fashaga were also allowed to stay there.^[15][16]

Once the Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF) was removed from power in 2018, Amhara Region leaders whose sub-national territory Fashaga is located in condemned the deal as a secret bargain and said they were not properly consulted when the deal was made.^[15]

Prelude[]

At the start of the Tigray War, the head of Sudan's ruling Sovereign Council, Lt. General Abdel Fattah, dispatched over 6,000 soldiers to the Ethiopian border as part of an agreement reached with Ethiopia on 1 November 2020 to prevent Tigrayan rebels from using Sudan as a supply route (who would attack Ethiopian bases just two later.)^[8][20] With Sudanese troops finally being deployed to the border, the 2008 compromise was practically dissolved. And once the Amhara militants were re-deployed to Tigray to help the federal government, the Sudanese soldiers started began removing potentially thousands of Amhara and Tigrayan farmers from the region.^[16][20] The Sudanese troops would make rapid progress in consolidating their hold on the disputed territory. On 2 December, the Sudanese Armed Forces occupied the area, controlled by Ethiopia for 25 years, expelling Ethiopian militants without a fight. Three days later, Sudan would deploy the Sixth Infantry Division to al-Fashaga to take control of , Gallabat locality. Sudan would continue to penetrate deeper into al-Fashaga by the second week of December.^[20]

Clashes[]

2020[]

On 15 December, Ethiopian militants, allegedly backed by the Ethiopian government, ambushed several Sudanese troops killing an officer and three soldiers. Later that day, the Sudanese Prime Minister Abdalla Hamdok said that the armed forces of Sudan were prepared to "repel" the military aggression. Already dealing with a war in the north, the Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed tried to calm the situation by tweeting, "Such incidents will not break the bond b/n our two countries as we always use dialogue to resolve issues."^[19][20]

Tensions increased when Sudan started mobilising soldiers to the contested border and by New Year's day, it claimed to have recaptured all villages in the region. In response, Ethiopian military chief General Birhanu Jula Gelalcha said, "Our military is engaged elsewhere, they took advantage of that. This should have been solved amicably. Sudan needs to choose dialogue, as there are third party actors who want to see our countries divided."^[19]

On 28 December, Sudan claimed to have captured the villages of , , Pasha, Lamlam, , Males, Ashkar, Arqa, Umm Pasha Teddy. In total it captured 11 settlements that Ethiopian militias were controlling. Sudan also claimed to have captured the town of Lilli from Amhara forces and militias. Lilli is home to Amhara militia commanders, major traders and farmers. In total, over a thousand Ethiopian farmers live there.^[21]

2021[]

On 3 January, Sudan captured 45 Amhara militiamen who had crossed into Sudan. Sudanese deputy army asserted to restore al-Fashaga, that had been occupied by Ethiopians of the Amhara ethnic group.^[2]

Ethiopian militiamen kidnapped three Sudanese merchants from the Basanda area of El-Gadarif state on 30 January after penetrating seven kilometres inside Sudanese territory, and set their motorcycle on fire. The Sudanese military deployed additional reinforcements after the kidnapping.^[22] Armed relatives of the abductees tried to enter the Ethiopian town of Metemma, but were persuaded to withdraw. The merchants were later released after payment of a ransom.^[23]

On 14 February, Sudan said Ethiopian soldiers crossed into its territory. The Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that Sudan had been plundering and displacing Ethiopian citizens since 6 November 2020 and that the Sudanese army should evacuate the area that it has forcefully occupied. Ethiopia has also accused Sudan of crossing into its territory.^[24]

On 20 February, the Sudanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs claimed that Eritrean forces had entered into the al-Fashaga region with Ethiopian forces. Four days later on 24 February, Eritrea denied the involvement of its forces in the tensions on the Sudanese-Ethiopian borders. Stating that it wished for a peaceful solution to the conflict and that his government understands Sudan's position regarding its right to extend its sovereignty over its land.^[25]

On 23 February, Ethiopia asked Sudan to withdraw its troops from the disputed border area before peace talks could begin. The Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesperson, , said that Ethiopia does not want to enter into conflict with Sudan again. He also said that Ethiopia wished to return to the 2008 compromise which would allow Ethiopian troops and civilians enter region undisturbed. Finally Mufti said there was a third party who pushed Sudan to enter into conflict with Ethiopia.^[26] The same day Sudan stated that it would not withdraw its troops from the border region and said the deployment of the Sudanese army on the border strip with Ethiopia is a final and irreversible decision.^[27]

On 2 March, Sudanese army continued to push in the last Ethiopian stronghold of Bereket in the disputed border region of al-Fashaga against Ethiopian-backed forces. In the meantime, Sudan claimed Eritrean forces were helping the Ethiopians.^[28]

Sudan closed the Gallabat-Metemma border crossing with Ethiopia on 3 April, two days after Ethiopian militiamen attacked Sudanese customs officials in presence of the Ethiopian military.^[29] Walid Ahmad al-Sajjan, commander of the Fifth Brigade of the Sudanese Armed Forces in Umm Barakit, stated on 8 April that the Sudanese military had retaken 95% of the disputed al-Fashaga region from Ethiopia.^[30]

On 13 April, Sudan released 61 Ethiopian soldiers it had captured and handed them to the Ethiopian government through the Gallabat border crossing.^[31]

Three children of the Fellata tribe were kidnapped by Ethiopian militias from an area near Gallabat and Metemma on 23 July.^[32] Sudanese captain Bahaa El-Din Youssef, commander of the Gallabat Military Region, was captured and later tortured while pursuing the militia behind the kidnapping. Meanwhile, the military build-up continued on the border and Sudan closed the Gallabat border crossing with Ethiopia on 24 July.^[10]

Sudan's military stated on 26 September that Ethiopian forces had tried to capture the Umm Barakit area a day earlier, but were forced to withdraw after being confronted by it.^[33]

On Saturday 27 November 2021, six Sudanese soldiers were killed in an attack by Ethiopian forces on a Sudanese army post near the border between the countries, Sudanese military sources told Reuters. Sudan's army said in an earlier statement on Facebook that “groups of the Ethiopian army and militias attacked its forces in Al-Fashaga Al-sughra, which resulted in deaths … our forces valiantly repelled the attack and inflicted heavy losses in lives and equipment on the attackers.”^[34]

On December 15, 2021, the Sudanese Forces announced full control over the disputed region.^[35]

Reactions and peace process[]

International[]

• Saudi Arabia offered to help reconcile the feuding parties.^[19]
• British Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab met with officials from both sides and urged them to end their fighting and seek common ground.^[19]
• President Salva Kiir met separately with Sudanese Foreign Minister Mariam Sadiq and will meet with Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed in Juba. Depending on the outcome of these two talks, a three-way summit could be held later in Juba.^[36]

Intergovernmental organizations[]

• Special European Envoy and Finnish Foreign Minister Pekka Haavisto met with Sudanese officials in Khartoum to help reduce tensions between Sudan and Ethiopia. He also met with Ethiopian officials after he was done in Sudan.^[37]

Other[]

• Rashid Abdi, a researcher and Horn of Africa analyst said "Ethiopia is reticent about the al-Fashaga crisis because it touches on Prime Minister Abiy's grip on power and the interests of the Amhara one of his ethnic support base. Whereas in Sudan, a new conflict could complicate the political transition and sow divisions. The army can use war as excuse to reconsolidate power and edge out the civilians."^[19]

References[]