American Horror Stories

Scarlett forms a relationship with Ruby (Kaia Gerber), a young girl who snuck into the Murder House to commit suicide, while Troy begins to cheat on Michael with a contractor named Adam (Aaron Tveit). After discovering the bodies of Maya and her friends behind a brick wall, Adam blackmails Michael and Troy but is then slain by the Rubber Man. Michael and Troy try to flee the house but find they cannot leave. They find out that they were murdered earlier in an effort on Ruby's behalf to persuade Scarlett to stay with her in the Murder House forever. On Halloween, Scarlett and Ruby venture out of the house. Maya and her friends pursue them to get revenge on Scarlett, but they are unsuccessful. At dawn, Scarlett resolves to move out of the Murder House but promises Ruby that she will visit her every Halloween.

After several failed attempts to get pregnant, Liv Whitley (Billie Lourd) receives a totem from Bernadette (Virginia Gardner), the receptionist at a fertility clinic, and places it under her bed just before she and her husband Matt (Ronen Rubinstein) have sex. The totem works and Liv has a son, Aaron. Sixteen months later, Liv is suffering from postpartum depression and begins seeing visions of Ba'al, a demon haunting her child. Liv seeks out Bernadette, who shares a banishment ritual with her. Liv accidentally stabs Matt while performing the ritual and is committed to an asylum. It is revealed that Matt and his college friends had orchestrated every supernatural event to gaslight Liv, as well as having an affair with Bernadette. As Matt celebrates his success, the real Ba'al (Dane DiLiegro) appears and slaughters Bernadette and Matt's friends. It is revealed that Liv sent Ba’al to exact revenge. The banishment ritual Bernadette gave her was actually a summoning spell. Matt is sent to prison and Liv welcomes Ba’al into her bed, ready to have another baby.

A boy named Jacob () disappears on a camping trip. Ten years later, his father Jay (Aaron Tveit) is approached by a hunter named Bob (Blake Shields), who presents evidence that Jacob is still alive after being kidnapped by a drug cartel. He offers to take Jay, and Jacob's skeptical mom, Addy (Tiffany Dupont) into the woods to seek information about Jacob's whereabouts. After being hunted by wild humanoid creatures, Bob reveals it was all a hoax in order to rob them. After wounding Jay, Bob is attacked and devoured by the creatures. Jay and Addy seek refuge at a park ranger's station manned by Stan (Cody Fern), who divulges that the National Park Service was created by the government to protect the public from clusters of feral human beings. The group is attacked by the creatures and Stan is killed. Jay and Addy are taken to the leader of the creatures, Jacob, who appears to recognize them, however one of the creatures asks Jacob who they are and he responds, "Dinner".

Michelle (Mercedes Mason) creates a video game, Escape from Murder House, based on past seasons of American Horror Story, but her son Rory (Nicolas Bechtel) isn't impressed because the game doesn't make sense. While conducting research, Michelle enters the Murder House on Halloween Night. Ruby (Kaia Gerber) and Scarlett (Sierra McCormick) reconnect, while Michelle meets Dr. Ben Harmon (Dylan McDermott), whom she questions unaware that he's one of the ghosts, then she's confronted and stabbed to death by Ruby and Scarlett. One year later on Halloween, Michelle finds Rory and claims there is no escaping the Murder House. Rory offers to burn it down, but Michelle refuses. Ignoring his mother, Rory shows up with gasoline canisters, and while Ruby tries to stop him, she in turn is stopped by the other ghosts who are tired of their suffering. As Scarlett arrives to help Ruby, the house is set ablaze. Three years later, condos have been built where the Murder House once stood, and Scarlett purchases the last unit to reunite with Ruby. This is revealed to be the end of the game that Michelle, who is alive and well, has developed with Rory's approval.