Antonio Iturmendi Bañales

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Antonio Iturmendi Bañales
Born
Antonio Iturmendi Bañales

1903
Baracaldo, Spain
Died1976
Madrid, Spain
NationalitySpanish
Occupationlawyer
Known forpolitician
Political partyTraditionalist Communion, Falange Española Tradicionalista

Antonio Iturmendi Bañales (1903–1976) was a Spanish Carlist and Francoist politician. He is best known as the Minister of Justice, serving in 1951–1965, as the Cortes speaker, serving in 1965–1969; he held the parliamentarian ticket between 1949 and 1976. He is also noted as briefly a civil governor and Tarragona and Zaragoza provinces in 1939. Though not counted among key decision-makers of the Francoist regime, he is considered instrumental in thwarting the Falangist attempt to re-define the system in the mid-1950s, and in the process of implementing the Alfonsist restoration in the 1960s.

Family and youth[]

Baracaldo, early 20. c.

The Iturmendi family originated from the Navarrese town of Morentín was first noted in the mid-16th century.[1] It got very branched, though none of its representatives got particularly distinguished. The best-known family member was Emeterio Celedonio Iturmendi Barbarín (1812-1883), a military who became an icon of Carlist insurgency;[2] he took part in all three Carlist wars (1833-8, 1849, 1873-6) and grew to general.[3] He was also the brother of Antonio's great-grandfather.[4] Either the grandfather or the father of Antonio moved to Baracaldo on the Biscay coast; the latter, (1873-1955), was educated in jurisprudence and worked as a lawyer for almost half a century.[5] In the mid-1920s he was president of Consejo Judicial of Banco Vasco and as such was involved in negotiations over Concierto Económico, periodical financial arrangements between the provincial Biscay self-government and Madrid.[6] In the mid-1930s he became the dean of Colegio de Abogados of the Biscay province, the position held until death.[7] Iturmendi López married Julia Bañales Menchaca (1881-1962);[8] the couple had 11 children, 7 sons[9] and 4 daughters.[10]

Like his siblings, Antonio was raised in a profoundly Catholic ambience; he started education at the Doctrina Cristiana and Sagrados Corazones schools, where he obtained the baccalaureate.[11] At unspecified time though probably around the year of 1920 he entered facultad de derecho at Universidad de Deusto, the prestigious Bilbao-based high school founded by the Jesuit Order. It is at Deusto that he graduated in law;[12] exact date is not clear and probably fell on the mid-1920s.[13] In 1924 Iturmendi settled his affairs with the army[14] and in 1926 he was nominated abogado de estado, the state juridical service.[15] The same year he successfully passed entry exams to Instituto Reus[16] and commenced law practice in Delegación de Hacienda[17] in Castellón,[18] though already in 1927 he was transferred to Logroño.[19] At unspecified time in the late 1920s Iturmendi returned to his native Biscay when posted to Bilbao.[20]

Deusto University, current view

In 1927 Iturmendi married Rita Gómez Nales (1900-1983), a Mexico-born girl from an indiano family;[21] none of the sources consulted provides any information on her family except that they resided in Madrid.[22] The couple settled in Bilbao. Antonio and Rita had 5 children: María Teresa, María del Pilár,[23] María de los Angeles, Antonio and Javier Iturmendi Gómez Nales. None of them became a public figure, though Maria Teresa married Alfonso Osorio García, a Francoist and later a Christian-Democrat politician, deputy prime minister in the Suarez government.[24] Some of Antonio's grandchildren, especially from the Osorio Iturmendi[25] and the Iturmendi Mac-Lellan families, are high corporative executives.[26] One Iturmendi's brother was a locally recognized lawyer[27] and another was a military.[28] Antonio's nephew, José Iturmendi Morales, became a scholar in jurisprudence and for 20 years until 2008 served as dean of the Law Department at Universidad Complutense in Madrid, considered one of key Spanish iusnaturalists.[29] Antonio's niece, Juana Iturmendi Maguregui,[30] is a Partido Popular politician and served in the Senate during the 2009–2011 term.[31]

Bilbao: from abogado to deputy mayor[]

Carlist standard

Close to nothing is known about Iturmendi's public engagements of the late 1920s and early 1930s, except that he continued exercising as abogado del estado in Bilbao. At unspecified time he became asesor juridico for the provincial Biscay self-government[32] and it is likely that in this role he met Esteban Bilbao, the friend of his father and during primoderiverista period the president of the Biscay diputación; Bilbao was to become Iturmendi's lifetime political patron and Iturmendi turned his protégé and successor. In the early 1930s Iturmendi continued as a lawyer; during Dictablanda he worked with his father in the same office,[33] but in the Republican period he set up an office of his own.[34] None of the sources consulted clearly notes him as involved in any political activity. Later works and press notes referred to Iturmendi as a Carlist and Traditionalist,[35] though it is not confirmed that like Esteban Bilbao he joined Traditionalist Communion or otherwise engaged in Carlist initiatives. An apparently well-known Iturmendi was recorded as involved in Acción Popular in the Biscay countryside, though it is not clear whether the person is question was Antonio, his father or any other family member.[36]

There is no data available related to Iturmendi's stand prior and shortly after the July 1936 coup. It is not known whether he was involved in the Carlist conspiracy, where he resided during the outbreak of the Civil War and what his fate was in the next few months. In August 1936 José Iturmendi showed up in Burgos and publicly declared adhesion to the military Junta, yet a corresponding press note did not mention Antonio as accompanying his father.[37] He reportedly accepted the Unification Decree of April 1937 and was among these Carlists who readily joined the new Francoist state party, Falange Española Tradicionalista,[38] though the first confirmed information on his whereabouts comes from December 1937. Recommended by Esteban Bilbao, Iturmendi was nominated into a 3-member Comisión Liquidadora;[39] once the Nationalists scrapped all separate provincial Biscay arrangements, especially Concierto Económico, the body was entrusted with engineering their legal handover to the central administration and it completed the task within few months.[40]

Bilbao
Bilbao

Also the next Iturmendi's assignment kept him busy in Bilbao. In August 1938 the Nationalist Ministry of Interior appointed the 3rd municipal administration, headed by José Lequerica; in a trademark Francoist move of balancing various political groupings, as a tractable Carlist Iturmendi was nominated primero teniente de alcalde, de facto the deputy mayor of the city.[41] He became president of the Economic and Budgetary Commission[42] and entered executive boards of commercial companies controlled by the city, e.g. he joined Junta de Gobierno of Caja de Ahorros de Bilbao.[43] None of the sources consulted provides any detailed information on his activity in the town hall; it is neither clear when exactly he ceased. Most sources note that in January 1939 he was posted to a new job in Catalonia; however, some works list Iturmendi as member of the Bilbao administration until March 1939.[44]

Rise and demise[]

Falangist standard

In January 1939 Iturmendi was nominated the first Francoist gobernador civil in Tarragona.[45] He is noted as involved in anti-Republican purges; officials deemed “anti-patriotic” were to be removed or suspended.[46] Iturmendi was also recorded for his role during a conflict related to cardenal Vidal Barraquer. Furious about the archbishop's neutralist stance, Franco was determined to prevent his return to Tarragona;[47] Iturmendi helped to outmaneuver the provisional papal nominee, Francesc Vives, and greatly contributed to final defeat of the Vatican's diplomacy in their struggle to reinstate Vidal.[48] In March 1939[49] Iturmendi was transferred to civil governor position in Zaragoza, which he held for 5 months. Again, he is noted as the one whose hand “did not tremble” when dealing with officials suspected of lack of enthusiasm for the new regime.[50]

In August 1939 Iturmendi ceased as the Zaragoza governor and was nominated head of Dirección General de Administración Local within the Ministry of Interior;[51] the job presented him with enormous powers as he became responsible for these local nominations which were not reserved for the Minister or civil governors.[52] Indeed, he cautiously endorsed Carlists in ranks of the local officials, noted for promoting his fellow Traditionalists in Vic,[53] Valencia[54] or Bilbao.[55] He also organized from scratch Cuerpo de Funcionarios of the local administration and founded a dedicated school named Instituto de Estudios de Administración Local, serving at the same time as its vice-president.[56]

Basilica de Begoña

In September 1939 Iturmendi was appointed to the second Consejo Nacional of Falange;[57] according to some scholars he represented the Carlist “colaboracionistas”, who replaced Carlist “duros”.[58] Others count him among the hardline Falangist “blandos” and note that Iturmendi in public appeared in the black party uniform.[59] As before taking seat in Consejo he did not seek authorization from the Carlist regent-claimant Don Javier, the latter expelled him from Comunión Tradicionalista.[60] Undeterred, Iturmendi continued in Francoist structures. In May 1941 he ceased at Administración Local[61] and was appointed sub-secretary in Ministry of Interior.[62] Political background of the change remains disputed; according to one scholar Iturmendi was promoted by the new minister Valentín Galarza as part of his offensive against Serrano Suñer;[63] another account has it that Serrano was Iturmendi's “mentor”.[64]

Iturmendi's position versus Carlism remained ambiguous. On the one hand, as high official of the Interior he monitored the intransigent party activists and denounced some as "aliadofilos".[65] On the other, in late 1941 he visited the Falangist secretario general and demanded that Traditionalists are no longer isolated and marginalized.[66] He maintained relations with collaborative Carlists; in August 1942 he was present during a sermon to honor the Carlist dead, which later became known as the Begoña incident.[67] Iturmendi emerged unhurt[68] yet he was furious about the hardline Falangism. In protest he resigned his seat in Consejo Nacional;[69] shortly afterwards he ceased as sub-secretary in the Interior.[70] It is not clear whether the dismissal was related to his resignation; some scholars claim that on the contrary, he was fired as part of the anti-Serranista purges in the ministry.[71]

From sidelines back to power[]

Esteban Bilbao

In late 1942 Iturmendi was not re-appointed to the new Consejo Nacional[72] and he found himself on the sidelines of official politics; according to some scholars he commenced the period of “largo ostracismo”, which was to last until the end of the decade.[73] Politically he seemed bewildered, vacillating between Javierista Carlism, Juanista Carlism, Carloctavismo and Francoism. In 1943 together with orthodox Carlist leaders he signed a letter to Franco; the signatories demanded that totalitarian features of the regime are removed and traditional institutions are brought back.[74] Some authors claim that in 1944 Iturmendi returned to Comunión Tradicionalista, allegedly because he sensed that after the Allied takeover of Western Europe the end of Francoism was near.[75] However, almost at the same time Iturmendi was reportedly engaged in drafting a political manifesto of the Alfonsist claimant Don Juan; it materialized in 1946 as Bases Institucionales de la Monarquía Española. Some scholars claim that the 1946 Ley de Sucesión partially acknowledged the Juanista proposal.[76] Others suggest rather that it might have been written with the Carloctavista claimant in mind;[77] together with Esteban Bilbao, Iturmendi emerged as one of the best known supporters of Karl Pius Habsburgo-Lorena.[78] As at the time it appeared that Carloctavistas enjoyed some cautious backing of the regime[79] it might have seemed that Iturmendi took part in a Francoist plot to install a puppet king. Indeed, he started to re-gain position in officialdom;[80] in 1947 he was appointed to the new Consejo Nacional of Falange[81] and as its member he automatically gained seat in the third Francoist Cortes, assembled in 1949.[82]

former FEFASA

Though not holding important political positions throughout most of the 1940s, Iturmendi did not entirely fall out of grace. At unspecified time in the mid-1940s[83] he was appointed president of the executive board of Fabricación Española de Fibras Textiles Artificiales, the company created within the Instituto Nacional de Industria framework in Miranda de Ebro. As part of the Francoist plan of reaching full economic independence, FEFASA was tasked with launching production of synthetic fiber; though based on German technology, the bid was not successful before Iturmendi ceased as president.[84] Other commercial enterprises he engaged in were Pola and Nervión, two Bilbao-based insurance companies where he worked as consejero.[85] Iturmendi resumed also the law practice, though not in Bilbao but in Madrid; he served as abogado del estado before various Tribunales in the capital.[86] He engaged also in more ambitious juridical activities. In a move hardly compatible with his earlier work in Liquidadora, he took part in works developing legal infrastructure for semi-autonomous governance which would incorporate some fuerista establishments into the civil code. They climaxed in Congreso Nacional de Derecho Civil in Zaragoza in 1946; its resolutions paved the way for a 1947 decree, which in turned enabled further works.[87] They were to continue grudgingly throughout decades and ultimately turned out to be a failure, yet even 20 years later Iturmendi considered them vital for Spanish legal system.[88]

Minister of Justice[]

Ministry of Justice, current view

Since the late 1940s reinstated in official structures, Iturmendi rose to governmental strata when in 1951 he was nominated Minister of Justice.[89] None of the sources consulted provides any details on mechanism of his appointment except that it was part of the Franco's balancing game[90] and that Iturmendi followed in the footsteps of Esteban Bilbao.[91] His term turned out to be one of the longest ministerial tenures in the Francoist Spain and lasted 14 years until 1965;[92] until today Iturmendi remains also the longest serving Spanish minister of justice in the entire history.[93] Moreover, during his tenure he was also many times and for short few-day periods double-hatting as a caretaker minister for Public Works,[94] Economy,[95] Education,[96] Labor[97] and Information.[98]

By the time Iturmendi took office the regime had already mitigated its terror; also the basic Francoist legislation had already been in place. Iturmendi focused on regulations which stabilized the system further on. He soon announced his determination to do away with administrative defects of the juridical system,[99] and then contributed to fine-tuning of the Civil Code, Ley de Jurisdicción Contencioso-Administrativa, Ley de Sociedales de Responsabilidad Limitada, Ley de Expropriación Forzosa,[100] Ley de Venta de Bienes and Ley de Adopción.[101] He was also chief engineer behind the concept of dual citizenship, shared by Spain and Latin American states and gradually implemented throughout the 1950s.[102] Some scholars claim that Iturmendi's Traditionalist leaning contributed to further restrictions on public morality, like the 1956 regulations which officially delegalized prostitution or the 1958 law aimed against homosexuals.[103] One of his final ministerial initiatives was setting up Juzgado y Tribunal de Orden Publico; in 1963 the body replaced the obsolete Tribunal Especial para la Represión de la Masonería y el Comunismo and was designed to handle high-profile political cases.[104] In 1963 he admitted to 610 political prisoners in Spain.[105]

Arrese
Arrese

When discussing his governmental career many scholars do not focus on Iturmendi's ministerial work but single out his stand during the 1956 crisis, when Falange hardliners led by Arrese produced the last serious attempt to convert the regime into a totalitarian system. Since 1947 continuously member of the Falangist Consejo Nacional, in 1955 Iturmendi was appointed to a party committee entrusted with drafting the law. First he tried to water it down during internal works of the committee[106] but failed.[107] Then as minister of justice he wrote to Franco arguing against the proposal once it had already landed on dictator's desk;[108] Iturmendi claimed that if accepted, it would build a Soviet-style regime like these of the USSR, Poland, Yugoslavia or China.[109] He declared that only the monarchy might prevent “tyranny of inorganic democracy”[110] and presented his own set of legislative proposals, aimed to build “Estado do Derecho”;[111] according to some scholars they were drafted by López Rodo.[112] Forming a common front with the monarchists and the military Iturmendi emerged successful; the climax led to the cabinet reshuffle, sidetracking of Arrese and adoption of a vague Ley de Principios del Movimiento Nacional.[113]

Monarchist[]

Don Javier

Iturmendi vacillated between a few political monarchist groupings active in the Francoist Spain. According to some scholars the 1953 death of Karl Pius[114] and the apparent collapse of Carloctavismo left him disoriented.[115] In the mid-1950s he reportedly intended “to act as intermediary” between the Carlist claimant Don Javier and Franco[116] and a few Javierista politicians indeed considered him an acceptable partner;[117] some historians claim that Carlist adoption of a new, collaborative strategy towards the regime might have been influenced by Iturmendi.[118] However, others note that Iturmendi remained entirely loyal to the dictator and was even prepared to lead a new Carlist organisation sponsored by the regime and with the sole purpose to distract and fragment the Traditionalists.[119] In the 1950s Iturmendi as the minister of justice a few times met Don Javier and always demanded that the latter tunes down his statements;[120] in 1955 he twice met the claimant[121] and in 1956 he threatened him and the entire Carlist executive[122] with execution or incarceration in case they do not retract what looked like monarchical declarations.[123] Despite these threats Don Javier and the new Carlist political leader Valiente still deemed Iturmendi tractable and their best liaison with Franco;[124] they preferred to comply.[125] As late as in 1957 Valiente thought of Iturmendi when sketching a planned Carlist collaborationist strategy[126] with the intention to promote the Borbón-Parmas.[127]

Don Juan
Don Juan

Many scholars suggest that in the late 1950s Iturmendi was already firmly in the Juanista camp and that his talks with the Javieristas were merely intended to make them accept Don Juan as the Carlist heir.[128] Though he did not sign a so-called Acto de Estoril, a 1957 document in which some 50 Traditionalists declared Count of Barcelona as their dynastical leader, Iturmendi is considered a key person in behind-the-stage maneuvers and one of key Juanistas in the government;[129] some authors claim that at the time Iturmendi already started rather to steer towards the son of Don Juan.[130] Historians speculate that at unspecified time in the late 1950s Iturmendi joined “Operación Salmón”, a long-term informal monarchist campaign to impress upon Franco the idea of crowning Don Juan Carlos.[131] The campaign lasted for some 10 years and during the crucial period of 1962-1964 it was co-ordinated by sort of a general staff, composed of 3 ministerial heavyweights: Manuel Fraga (Information), Camilo Alonso Vega (Interior) and Iturmendi (Justice).[132] At that time much effort was dedicated to thwarting royal ambitions of Don Javier and especially his son Don Carlos Hugo, who gained some genuine popularity. As minister of justice Iturmendi was crucial in countering efforts to obtain Spanish citizenship either for the prince[133] or for his father;[134] he also worked to restrict the Hugocarlista campaign in the media.[135] In return he gained virulent hostility of the Carlos Hugo supporters,[136] who denounced him as traitor to the Carlist cause.[137] They also tried to insult him in public; one such incident during the 1964 Corpus Christi celebrations in Toledo[138] triggered repression against the assailants.[139]

Hierarch[]

Juan Carlos, Prince of Spain

Since 1949 Iturmendi was continuously member in the Cortes by virtue of his seat in the Falangist Consejo Nacional.[140] His parliamentary ticket was renewed in 1952, 1955, 1958, 1961 and 1964; since 1952 he held double eligibility because of his ministerial job.[141] In 1965 he ceased as minister of justice[142] to enable his taking seat of the Cortes speaker. The role was held by Esteban Bilbao until he resigned due to his age;[143] as the most senior collaborative Traditionalist and the disciple of Bilbao[144] Iturmendi inherited the job.[145] The speaker role automatically made him president of Consejo del Reino and Consejo de Regencia,[146] peculiar diarchic structures giving credibility to quasi-monarchic nature of the Francoist Spain.[147] In this triple role Iturmendi enjoyed the most prestigious and distinguished positions available to civilians within the regime, even though there was very little if any political power formally attached to any of them.

It is not entirely clear what was Iturmendi's position in terms of practical politics, except that he remained utterly loyal to Franco. Some scholars counted him among key Juanista or Juancarlista supporters already since the late 1950s.[148] Others note that faced with two overlapping sets of rivalries within the government - technocratic monarchists versus regentialists and immovilistas versus reformists - Iturmendi preferred not to take a firm stand and fluctuated.[149] It is clear that he kept opposing the syndicalist hardliners; during 1967 works on Ley de Representacion Familiar he blocked the Falangists from entering the draft committee and ultimately ensured liberalization of the electoral law.[150] He also remained on ice-cold terms with Hugocarlista supporters; when two of their MPs faced legal action related to so-called Cortes Transhumantes activity Iturmendi refused any assistance.[151] His monarchist efforts were finally crowned in 1969, when Don Juan Carlos was nominated the future king of Spain; Iturmendi played a personal role in the ceremony since it was in front of him as president of the Cortes that the royal hopeful swore fidelity to the Francoist leyes fundamentales.[152]

Franco

In late 1969 Iturmendi resigned as president of the Cortes, Consejo del Reino and Consejo de Regencia; he quoted his age and declared withdrawal from active politics.[153] This did not prevent his 8th consecutive appointment to the Cortes in 1971, since not having resigned his seat in the National Council of the Movimiento he still automatically qualified as procurador.[154] His last term lasted unexpectedly long as the parliament was not dissolved until his death;[155] similarly he also retained membership in Consejo Nacional. Already a septuagenarian, he usually remained politically passive. However, in the early 1970s he was noted for joining forces with Traditionalist Carlists in an attempt to build Hermandad de Maestrazgo, an organization supposed to counter the progressive Hugocarlista bid to control Carlism.[156] Following the death of Franco Iturmendi was counted among “40 de Ayete”, direct Franco appointees to the Council and to the Cortes still serving; others name him “pata negra franquista”.[157]

Reception and legacy[]

Academia de Jurisprudencia site

During the Francoist era Iturmendi was hailed in the media as a great statesman. He was decorated with a number of honors, above all Cross of Isabel la Católica, Order of Carlos III, Order of San Raimundo de Peñafort and Mérito Civil.[158] In 1955 he was declared hijo predilecto by Baracaldo.[159] Among many prestigious bodies he formed part of the first to be mentioned is Real Academia de Jurisprudencia y Legislación, which he joined in 1973.[160] His numerous works were published between 1940 and 1973; they are either juridical studies[161] or dissertations on history of Traditionalist thought.[162] His death was acknowledged in nationwide media; most presented him as great jurist and politician.[163] In 1977 Juan Carlos de Borbón conferred upon Iturmendi's widow the title of condesa de Iturmendi. The move was to honor the deceased as “constante defensor de la Institución Monárquica”[164] and turned out to be one of only 6 condados created during his rule;[165] the title is currently held by Iturmendi's grandson, Antonio Iturmendi Mac-Lellan. At least in one street has been named after him.[166]

Over time perception of Iturmendi and his role in history changed dramatically. Though already in the 1950s he was dubbed “a scoundrel” by some orthodox Carlists[167] and declared “a traitor” by Hugocarlista politicians and Hugocalista historiography in the 1970s,[168] only in the late 20th century in the Spanish public discourse his dominant image became this of a villain, member of the dictatorial authoritarian elite associated with repression.[169] The anti-Francoist backlash of the 21st century changed street names;[170] left-wing deputies demand that his portrait gets removed from the gallery of Cortes speakers[171] and his official biography on the Cortes website was long in the status of “being reworked”.[172] Family relation with Iturmendi was used in campaign against his nephew, José Iturmendi Morales, when he ran for the Universidad Complutense rectorship in 2011.[173] In some partisan works he is dubbed “canalla”.[174] There are authors who deny him the name of a Traditionalist[175] or a Carlist.[176]

In scientific historiographic discourse Iturmendi has not earned a monograph so far, be it a full-blown biography or a minor article. In general works dealing with Francoism he is usually acknowledged as a noticeable, but second-rate figure, a man who held two important jobs but who did not qualify among key policy-makers of the regime.[177] Some scholars suggest that the likes of Rodezno, Bilbao and Iturmendi were instrumental in shaping Francoism as they infused Traditionalist spirit into the corporative organicist concepts of the early regime,[178] some rather underline his role in relation to the Alfonsist restoration and the ultimate crowning of Don Juan Carlos,[179] and some tend to present him as an opportunist who did not let “Carlism get in the way” of his career.[180] Some mention him on the list of Basques on prominent positions within Francoism.[181] At times he is noted as the one who delegalized prostitution in Spain,[182] though some scholars present it as a reactionary rather than a progressive move.[183]

See also[]

Footnotes[]

  1. ^ Iturmendi entry, [in:] Heraldry Institute service, available here
  2. ^ Iturmendi Barbarín has earned a monograph, Marcelo Nuñez de Cepeda, El general Iturmendi, Pamplona 1960
  3. ^ Iturmendi Barbarin, Emeterio Celedonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  4. ^ Ayuntamiento de Morentin, [in:] Morentin service, available here
  5. ^ ABC 12.04.55, available here
  6. ^ ABC 27.01.26, available here
  7. ^ ABC 12.04.55, available here
  8. ^ Hoje Oficial de Lunes 23.04.62, available here
  9. ^ named José, Antonio, Pedro, Emilio, Marcelo, Jesus and Ramón, ABC 12.04.55, available here
  10. ^ named María Victoria, María Purificación, María de los Angeles and Ana María, ABC 12.04.55, available here
  11. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here. Iturmendi remained profoundly religious throughout all his life; at one point he advised to Conde Rodezno “Procura hacer en esta vida todo lo que te sirva para la otra”, Jesús Pavón, Semblanza del Conde de Rodezno, [in:] Principe de Viana 15/54-55 (1954), p. 190
  12. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  13. ^ Eduardo Montagut Contreras, Antonio Iturmendi Bañales, [in:] El País 28.10.08, available here
  14. ^ La Noche 24.10.24, available here
  15. ^ Heraldo de Castellón 22.06.22, available here
  16. ^ ABC 31.10.26, available here
  17. ^ Heraldo de Castellón 20.01.27, available here
  18. ^ Heraldo de Castellón 27.10.26, available here
  19. ^ Heraldo de Casetllón 20.01.27, available here
  20. ^ La Vanguardia Española 05.03.76, available here
  21. ^ Antonio Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] Geneanet service, available here, Enrique Herreros, La Codorniz de Enrique Herreros, Madrid 2005, ISBN 9788441417403, p. 53
  22. ^ the marriage ceremony took place in the Madrid church of Nuestra Señora de los Angeles at calle Bravo Murillo, Herreros 2005, p. 53
  23. ^ compare her front-page photo as “a Spanish beauty” in Semana 29.06.54, available here
  24. ^ La Vanguardia Española 05.03.76, available here
  25. ^ see Lucas Osorio Iturmendi entry, [in:] Bloomberg service, available here, Alfonso Osorio Iturmendi profile, [in:] LinkedIn service, available here, María Angeles Osorio Iturmendi profile, [in:] LinkedIn service, available here
  26. ^ Antonio Iturmendi MacLellan, [in:] CrestCom España service, available here
  27. ^ Antonio Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] Congreso service, available here
  28. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado 03.02.37, available here
  29. ^ he is considered the disciple of Francisco Elías de Tejada, Miguel Ayuso Torres, Francisco Elías de Tejada en la ciencia jurídico-política, [in:] Anales de la Fundación Francisco Elías de Tejada 3 (1997), p. 16
  30. ^ she is daughter to Antonio’s brother José Iturmendi Bañales and Juana Maguregui y Díaz de Mendívil, José Miguel de Mayoralgo y Lodo, Movimiento Nobiliario. Año 1937, p. 137
  31. ^ Iturmendi Maguregui, Juana entry, [in:] Senado service, available here
  32. ^ ABC 03.10.65, available here
  33. ^ Anuario del País Vasco 1930, p. 388, available here
  34. ^ Anuario Regional 1932, p. 661, available here
  35. ^ see e.g. “[Iturmendi] fue originariamente tradicionalista, peró entró en FET-JONS”, Martí Marín Cobrera, Los gobernadores civiles del franquismo, [in:] Historia y Política 29 (2013), p. 276
  36. ^ El Nervión 20.01.36, available here
  37. ^ Diario de Burgos 07.08.36, available here
  38. ^ Ramón María Rodón Guinjoan, Invierno, primavera y otoño del carlismo (1939-1976) [PhD thesis Universitat Abat Oliba CEU], Barcelona 2015, p. 30
  39. ^ Eduardo J. Alonso Olea, El crédito de la Unión Minera, [in:] Historia Contemporánea 24 (2002), p. 346
  40. ^ El Pensamiento Alaves 13.12.37, available here a
  41. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  42. ^ Joseba Agirreazkuenaga, Mikel Urquijo (eds.), Bilbao desde sus alcaldes: Diccionario biográfico de los alcaldes de Bilbao y gestión municipal en la Dictadura vol. 3, Bilbao 2008, ISBN 9788488714145,p. 178
  43. ^ Agirreazkuenaga, Urquijo 2008, p. 180
  44. ^ Agirreazkuenaga, Urquijo 2008, p. 178. One source claims that Iturmendi was appointed a concejal in the Bilbao ayuntamiento in 1950, see the Real Academia de Historia service; this information is not confirmed elsewhere and might result from confusion; it was Antonio's brother Pedro Iturmendi Banales who served as concejal in the Bilbao ayuntamiento during few strings in course of early Francoism
  45. ^ technically the first Francoist civil governor of Tarragona was Carmelo Monzón Mosso, nominated in April 1938 (also for the province of Castellón). At that time the Nationalist made first incursions into the province, yet until January 1939 they never controlled more than 25% of its territory. Official provincial site does not count Monzón as the civil governor, Govern civil de Tarragona, [in:] Tarragona service, available here
  46. ^ Josep Recasens Llort, La repressió franquista a la Ribera d'Ebre (1938-1945), Valls 2003, ISBN 9788496035690, p. 293
  47. ^ Gonzalo Redondo, Historia de la Iglesia en España, 1931-1939: La Guerra Civil, 1936-1939, Madrid 1993, ISBN 9788432130168, pp. 566-567
  48. ^ Hilari Raguer, Gunpowder and Incense: The Catholic Church and the Spanish Civil War, London 2007, ISBN 9781134365937, pp. 299-301
  49. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado 13.03.39, available here
  50. ^ Antoni Segura, La dictadura franquista, Barcelona 2012, ISBN 9788447535538, p. 166
  51. ^ Imperio 17.08.39, available here
  52. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  53. ^ Martí Marín i Corbera, El personal polític de l’ajuntament de Vic durant el franquisme: algunes consideracions (1939-1975), [in:] Recerques: história, economia, cultura 31 (1995), p. 392
  54. ^ Andreu Ginés i Sànchez, La instauració del franquisme al País Valencià [PhD thesis Barcelona Universitat Pompeu Fabra], Barcelona 2008, p. 702
  55. ^ Alfonso Ballestero, José Ma de Oriol y Urquijo, Madrid 2014, ISBN 9788483569160, p. 76
  56. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here, La Vanguardia Española 05.03.76, available here
  57. ^ ABC 13.09.39, available here
  58. ^ like Manuel Fal Conde or María Rosa Urraca Pastor, Josep Miralles Climent, La rebeldía carlista. Memoria de una represión silenciada: Enfrentamientos, marginación y persecución durante la primera mitad del régimen franquista (1936-1955), Madrid 2018, ISBN 9788416558711, p. 40
  59. ^ Manuel Martorell Pérez, La continuidad ideológica del carlismo tras la Guerra Civil [PhD thesis in Historia Contemporanea, Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia], Valencia 2009, p. 188
  60. ^ Jacek Bartyzel, Nic bez Boga, nic wbrew tradycji, Radzymin 2015, ISBN 9788360748732, p. 69
  61. ^ Marín i Corbera 1995, p. 392
  62. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  63. ^ Paul Preston, Doves of War: Four Women of Spain, Boston 2003, ISBN 9781555535605, p. 285; another author claims it was Franco who intended to clip the wings of Serrano, Stanley G. Payne, The Franco Regime, Madison 2011, ISBN 9780299110741, p. 287
  64. ^ Marin Cobrera 2013, p. 276
  65. ^ Miralles Climent 2018, p. 162, Manuel Martorell Pérez, Antonio Arrue, Euskaltzaindiaren suspertzean lagundu zuen karlista, [in:] Euskera 56 (2011), p. 856
  66. ^ Mercedes Peñalba Sotorrío, Entre la boina roja y la camisa azul, Estella 2013, ISBN 9788423533657, p. 88. Another author claims that Iturmendi made the same representation already in 1940, denouncing “agravios inferidos a los tradicionalistas”, Miralles Climent 2018, p. 148. However, the author claims this representation was made to Arrese, who at the time was not the FET secretary general
  67. ^ Rodón Guinjoan 2015, p. 90
  68. ^ Aurora Villanueva Martínez, Organizacion, actividad y bases del carlismo navarro durante el primer franquismo, [in:] Geronimo de Uztariz 19 (2003), p. 115, Miralles Climent 2018, p. 217
  69. ^ Martorell Pérez 2008, p. 188
  70. ^ Marín i Cobrera 2001, p. 392
  71. ^ Marin Cobrera 2013, p. 276
  72. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado 329 (1942), available here
  73. ^ Marin Cobrera 2013, p. 276
  74. ^ Ballestero 2014, p. 80, Robert Vallverdú i Martí, La metamorfosi del carlisme català: del "Déu, Pàtria i Rei" a l'Assamblea de Catalunya (1936-1975), Barcelona 2014, ISBN 9788498837261, p. 96, César Alcalá, D. Mauricio de Sivatte. Una biografía política (1901-1980), Barcelona 2001, ISBN 8493109797, p. 53
  75. ^ Manuel Martorell Pérez, Carlos Hugo frente a Juan Carlos. La solución federal para España que Franco rechazó, Madrid 2014, ISBN 9788477682653, p. 68
  76. ^ published 1946 under auspices of Don Juan and prepared jointly by Iturmendi, Rodezno, Gil-Robles and Saínz-Rodriguez, Alvaro Rodríguez Núñez, Franquismo y tradicionalismo. La legitimación teórica del franquismo en la teoría política tradicionalista [PhD thesis Universidade de Santiago de Compostela], Santiago de Compostela 2014, p. 240, Santiago Martínez Sanchez, El cardenal Pedro Segura y Saenz [PhD thesis Universidad Navarra], Pamplona 2002, p. 448
  77. ^ "Franco acted as if he was prepared to turn his back on the direct line of the Bourbon dynasty and seek an eventual successor elsewhere", Payne 2011, p. 328; “he would produce a law which turned Spain into a kingdom but that would not necessarily mean bringing back the Bourbons”, Paul Preston, The monarchy of Juan Carlos, [in:] Sebastian Balfour (ed.), The Politics of Contemporary Spain, New York 2008, ISBN 9781134249800, p. 31
  78. ^ Mercedes Vázquez de Prada, El papel del carlismo navarro en el inicio de la fragmentación definitiva de la comunión tradicionalista (1957-1960), [in:] Príncipe de Viana 72 (2011), p. 400, Jordi Canal, El carlismo, Madrid 2000, ISBN 8420639478, p. 353, Iker Cantabrana Morras, Lo viejo y lo nuevo, [in:] Sancho el Sabio 21 (2004), p. 158
  79. ^ Josep Carles Clemente Muñoz, Breve historia de las guerras carlistas, Madrid 2011, ISBN 9788499671710, p. 231
  80. ^ according to one scholar Iturmendi left Falange altogether but returned in 1946, Martorell Pérez 2014, p. 68
  81. ^ Montagut Contreras 2008
  82. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Cortes service, available here.
  83. ^ El Pensamiento Alaves 05.04.45, available here
  84. ^ it is not clear when Iturmendi ceased as FEFASA president. The last time he was noted in the press in such role was 1950. In a large 1957 article related he was not mentioned at all, compare Diario de Burgos 30.07.57, available here. For further details on FEFASA and its role in the INI economic plan see Daniel Lanero, Dulce Freire (eds.), Agricultura y inovación tecnológica en la península ibérica, Madrid 2011, ISBN 9788449111792, p. 175
  85. ^ Mundo Obrero 15.08.51, here
  86. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here, ABC 03.10.65, available here
  87. ^ Encarna Roca Trías, La postcodificación civil: la unidad de Códigos, una política muerta, [in:] Anuario de historia del derecho español 82 (2012), pp. 178-179
  88. ^ Miguel L. Lacruz Mantegón, El Derecho de sucesiones aragonés: las huellas del maestro Lacruz, [in:] María del Carmen Bayod, José Antonio Serrano (eds.), Cincuenta años de Derecho civil aragonés, Zaragoza 2018, ISBN 9788499114866, pp. 219-220
  89. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  90. ^ Payne 2011, pp. 416-417
  91. ^ Clemente 2011, p. 231
  92. ^ José Girón de Velasco served 16 years as minister of labor (1941-1957), Blas Pérez González served 15 years as minister of Interior (1942-1957)
  93. ^ the second longest-serving minister of justice, Francisco Tadeo Calomarde, served almost 9 years between 1824 and 1832; the third longest-serving minister, Antonio Oriol Urquijo, remained in office for almost 8 years between 1965 and 1973
  94. ^ in 1953, 1954 and 1955, Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] official Cortes service, available here
  95. ^ in 1956, 1958, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963 and 1964, Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] official Cortes service, available here
  96. ^ in 1958 and 1960, Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] official Cortes service, available here
  97. ^ in 1958 and 1959, Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] official Cortes service, available here
  98. ^ in 1964, Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] official Cortes service, available here
  99. ^ Paul Preston, Michael Partridge, Piers Ludlow (eds.), Great Britain. Foreign Office, British documents on foreign affairs: reports and papers from the Foreign Office confidential print. From 1951 through 1956. Europe, 1951, vol. 5, London 2008, ISBN 9780886927240, p. 52
  100. ^ ABC 06.03.76, available here
  101. ^ detailed discussion in Antonio Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] Real Academia de Historia service, available here. For some comments on Iturmendi-sponsored law which banned prostitution see Aurora G. Morcillo, The Seduction of Modern Spain: The Female Body and the Francoist Body Politic, Lewisburg 2010, ISBN 9780838757536, p. 122
  102. ^ Iturmendi claimed that “the Hispanic, a solid and enduring bloc, will provide, in the hour uncertainty in which we live, a guarantee for more peace; this peace anxiously desired by so many”; in the 1950s some 10 dual-citizenship agreements were concluded, Daniel Gunnar Kressel, The Hispanic Community of Nations: the Spanish-Argentine nexus and the imagining of a Hispanic Cold War bloc, [in:] Cahiers des Ameriques Latines 79 (2015), pp. 115-133
  103. ^ see Pascual Marzal, Criminal Law under the Francoist Regime: the Influence of Militarism and National-Catholicism, [in:] Stephen Skinner, Fascism and Criminal Law: History, Theory, Continuity, New York 2015, ISBN 9781782255475
  104. ^ some scholars claim that as the case of Julián Grimau exposed inconsistencies in the Francoist penal infrastructure, Iturmendi prepared corrective legislation. According to some authors the draft was ready before Grimau’s execution, Julián Casanova, Carlos Gil Andrés, Twentieth-Century Spain: A History, Cambridge 2014, ISBN 9781107016965, p. 267
  105. ^ Manuel L. Abellán, Medio siglo de cultura (1939-1989), Amsterdam 1990, ISBN 9789051832242, p. 251
  106. ^ Ituemrndi tried to argue that the law would turn FET into bureaucratic, state-dependent institution without life, J. Sarmiento, Franco y el poder, [in:] Historia de España blog 03.09.11, available here
  107. ^ Sarmiento 2011, Alvaro de Diego González, Algunas de las claves de la transición en el punto de inflexión del franquismo: la etapa constituyente de Arrese (1956-1957), [in:] La transición a la democracia en España: actas de las VI Jornadas de Castilla-La Mancha sobre Investigación en Archivos, Guadalajara 2004, ISBN 8493165891, p. 10
  108. ^ Iturmendi claimed that "the state should represent all Spaniards, even those not affiliated to the Movement", Sarmiento 2011
  109. ^ Diego González 2004, p. 13
  110. ^ Diego González 2004, p. 11
  111. ^ Payne 2011, p. 448
  112. ^ Kim Helsvig, Modernization and Administrative Reform during the later Franquist Régime (1957-1973), Oslo 1998, p. 102
  113. ^ Iturmendi denounced the draft proposal as running against “leyes fundamentales” and having nothing to do “con la tradición política española y con el espíritu del alzamiento”, Mercedes Vázquez de Prada, El nuevo rumbo político del carlismo hacia la colaboración con el régimen (1955-56), [in:] Hispania 69 (2009), p. 206
  114. ^ Iturmendi presided over the funeral ceremonies, which assumed an unexpedtly high profile, Francisco de las Heras y Borrero, Un pretendiente desconocido. Carlos de Habsburgo. El otro candidato de Franco, Madrid 2004, ISBN 8497725565, pp. 126, 129
  115. ^ Antonio Riviera, Dictadura y desarrollismo. El franquismo en Alava, [in:] Academia service 2009, p. 162
  116. ^ Jeremy MacClancy, The Decline of Carlism, Reno 2000, ISBN 9780874173444, p. 86
  117. ^ Josep Carles Clemente, Historia del Carlismo contemporaneo 1935–1972, Barcelona 1977, ISBN, 9788425307591, p. 299
  118. ^ Mercedes Vázquez de Prada, El final de una ilusión. Auge y declive del tradicionalismo carlista (1957-1967), Madrid 2016, ISBN 9788416558407, p. 39
  119. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2011, p. 398
  120. ^ the first meeting between Iturmendi and Don Javier is dated for 1952, when after the Barcelona Eucharistic Congress the minister visited the claimant and challenged his monarchic statements, claiming that there is only one jefe del estado and everyone claiming such role might be considered subversive, Francisco Manuel Heras y Borrero, Carlos Hugo el Rey que no pudo ser: la lucha por el trono de España de Carlos Hugo de Borbón Parma, la última esperanza del carlismo, Madrid 2010, ISBN 9788495009999, p. 51, Martorell Pérez 2008, p. 396
  121. ^ Ana Marín Fidaldo, Manuel M. Burgueño, In memoriam. Manuel J. Fal Conde (1894-1975), Sevilla 1980, p. 52
  122. ^ Miralles Climent 2018, p. 367
  123. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2011, p. 188, Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 38, Javier Lavardín, Historia del ultimo pretendiente a la corona de España, Paris 1976, pp. 27-28
  124. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2011, p. 192
  125. ^ Alcalá 2001, p. 148
  126. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2011, p. 400
  127. ^ Rodón Guinjoan 2015, p. 221
  128. ^ Miralles Climent 2018, p. 364, Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 34, Marín Fidaldo, Burgueño 1980, p. 52 364, Vázquez de Prada 2009, p. 192
  129. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 61 Rodón Guinjoan 2015, p. 177
  130. ^ Alcalá 2001, p. 127
  131. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 92, Martorell Pérez 2014, p. 20
  132. ^ Daniel Jesús García Riol, La resistencia tradicionalista a la renovación ideológica del carlismo (1965-1973) [PhD thesis UNED], Madrid 2015, p. 217
  133. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2016, pp. 222, 232
  134. ^ Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 247
  135. ^ Martorell Pérez 2008, p. 484
  136. ^ the key antagonist of Iturmendi within the Hugocarlista camp was Ramón Massó, Vázquez de Prada 2016, pp. 55, 130
  137. ^ Lavardín 1976, p. 213
  138. ^ when Ituemrndi led the Corpus Christi parade the young Hugocarlistas assaulted him with cries of “traidor” and “Rey Javier!”, Martorell Pérez 2014, p. 163
  139. ^ Francisco Javier Caspistegui Gorasurreta, El naufragio de las ortodoxias. El carlismo, 1962–1977, Pamplona 1997; ISBN 9788431315641, p. 125
  140. ^ over time Iturmendi grew to Comisión Permanente of the Council and was noted in such role in 1966, Joaquín Monserrat Cavaller, Joaquín Bau Nolla y la restauración de la Monarquía, Madrid 2001, ISBN 8487863949, p. 243
  141. ^ see the official Iturmendi note on the Congress website, available here When stepping down, Iturmendi made room for another Carlist, Antonio Oriol. Payne 2011, p. 511
  142. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  143. ^ Payne 2011, p. 511
  144. ^ Clemente 2011, p. 231
  145. ^ Antonio Iturmendi Bañales, [in:] official Cortes service, available here
  146. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  147. ^ Monserrat 2001, p. 309
  148. ^ Miralles Climent 2018, p. 364, Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 34, Marín Fidaldo, Burgueño 1980, p. 52 Vázquez de Prada 2009, p. 192
  149. ^ Payne 2011, p. 505
  150. ^ Pedro Cobo Pulido, Representación familair en la época de Franco (1945-1974) [PhD thesis Universidad de Malaga], Málaga 200, p. 220
  151. ^ the Carlist MPs José Angel Zubiaur and Auxilio Goñi were charged with attending so-called Cortes Transhumantes, rump sessions of willing Cortes deputies staged across the country, Caspistegui 1997, p. 334
  152. ^ Montagut Contreras 2008
  153. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  154. ^ Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio, [in:] Cortes service, available here
  155. ^ see Iturmendi’s Cortes’ tickets at the official website of the house, available here
  156. ^ Caspistegui 1997, p. 237; on the other hand, a small monograph dedicated to Hermandad does not mention Iturmendi at all, see Ramón Rodón Guinjoan, Una aproximación al estudio de la Hermandad Nacional Monárquica del Maestrazgo y del Partido Social Regionalista, [in:] Aportes 88 (2015), pp. 169-201
  157. ^ Gregorio Morán, Adolfo Suárez: Ambición y destino, Madrid 2011, ISBN 9788499920283, p. 75
  158. ^ also , Mérito Agricola and Mérito Naval, Iturmendi Bañales, Antonio entry, [in:] Auñamendi Eusko Entziklopedia service, available here
  159. ^ ABC 28.06.55, available here
  160. ^ Antonio Iturmendi Bañales, [in:] Real Academia de Historia service, available here
  161. ^ El régimen municipal en los pueblos adoptados (1940), De la justicia y de los jueces (1952), I Congreso Penal y Penitenciario Hispano Luso Americano y Filipino (1952, with Federico Castejón y Martínez de Arizala), Curso de conferencias sobre derecho inmobiliario registral (1952), Sociedades de responsabilidad limitada (1953), En defensa de proyectos de ley ante las Cortes españolas y sobre temas jurídicos y materias de la competencia del departamento (1961), Perfeccionamiento de la organización y procedimiento de la justicia (1964), Las compilaciones forales en el proceso de la codificación española (1973)
  162. ^ Vázquez Mella (editor, 1953, with Rafael Gambra), En torno a la doctrina de la soberanía social en Vázquez de Mella (1962), Balmes sacerdote: su magisterio politico visto por un por un seglar (1970)
  163. ^ ABC 06.03.76, available here
  164. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado 06.01.77, available here
  165. ^ Alfonso R. Aldeyturriaga, El Corte del Rey de España, [in:] La Rioja 19.06.14, available here
  166. ^ one such street has been identified in Quart de Poblet; it is not clear when it was named after Iturmendi
  167. ^ e.g. by an orthodox Carlist historian Melchor Ferrer, referred after Vallverdu 2014, p. 151
  168. ^ Iturmendi is pictured in “Gallery of traitors” by a Hugocarlista historian, Clemente 2011, pp. 231-232
  169. ^ see Marzal 2015, Segura 2012, Recasens Llort 2003
  170. ^ the Quart de Poblet street was purged in 2016, see Las 13 Rosas y otras mujeres renombran calles franquistas de Quart de Poblet, [in:] La Vanguardia 21.07.16, available here
  171. ^ see Communicado de Izquierda Republicana, [in:] Izquierda Repubulicana service available here
  172. ^ “biografía en proceso de remodelación”; the effect of this re-work is Antonio Iturmendi Bañales entry, [in:] Congreso service, available here
  173. ^ Diego Barcala, Iturmendi, el requeté que aspira a ser rector, [in:] Público service 12.04.11, available here
  174. ^ Antonio Arizmendi, Patricio de Blas Zabaleta, Conspiración contra el obispo de Calahorra: Denuncia y crónica de una canallada, Madrid 2008, ISBN 9788441420830, pp. 12, 58, 95-96. The book deals with the Francoist smear campaign, subsequent marginalisation and media blackout on Fidel García Martínez, the former bishop of Calahorra; Iturmendi is presented as the one who forced the church into silence over the regime’s campaign of insults and mockery
  175. ^ Iturmendi is dubbed “pseudo-tradicionalista” in Miralles Climent 2018, p. 332
  176. ^ Iturmendi is classified as representative of „post-carlism”, Bartyzel 2015, p. 69
  177. ^ see e.g. key English-language works on the regime, written by authors who usually present a strikingly different perspective of the Spanish recent history, Stanley G. Payne, The Franco Regime, Madison 2011, ISBN 9780299110741, and Paul Preston, Franco. A Biography, London 1995, ISBN 9780006862109
  178. ^ Caspistegui 1997, p. 11
  179. ^ for scholarly discouse see e.g. García Riol 2015, p. 217, Martorell Pérez 2018, p. 20, Vázquez de Prada 2016, p. 92. For popular media discourse, see e.g. Manuel Martorell, La ‘Operación Salmón’ de los tecnócratas abrió a Juan Carlos las puertas del Trono, [in:] Cuartopoder service, 08.01.17, available here
  180. ^ MacClancy 2000, p. 93
  181. ^ see e.g. Jesús Laínz Fernández, Adiós, España: Verdad y mentira de los nacionalismos, Madrid 2010, ISBN 9788499205021, Yolanda Couceiro, El euskera se prohibió con Franco? Falso, [in:] InfoHispania 27.12.18, available here. In some cases Antonio is confused with his brother Pedro, see Jacobo de Andrés, Ascensión Corcuera, Los vascos que crearon el franquismo, [in:] La Tribuna del Pais Vasco 21.05.14, available here
  182. ^ Morcillo 2010, p. 122
  183. ^ "can be explained by the political mood of members of Franco’s government during those years, and in partiuclar the stance of the then Minister of Justice, Antonio Iturmendi, well-known for his Carlist ideology" and passim, Marzal 2015

Further reading[]

  • Álvaro de Diego González, Algunas de las claves de la transición en el punto de inflexión del franquismo la etapa constituyente de Arrese (1956-1957), [in:] La transición a la democracia en España: actas de las VI Jornadas de Castilla-La Mancha sobre Investigación en Archivos, Guadalajara 2004, Vol. 2, ISBN 8493165891
  • Javier Lavardín, Historia del ultimo pretendiente a la corona de España, Paris 1976
  • Stanley G. Payne, The Franco Regime, London 1987, ISBN 0299110702, 9780299110741
  • Manuel Martorell Pérez, La continuidad ideológica del carlismo tras la Guerra Civil, [PhD thesis], Valencia 2009
  • Mercedes Vázquez de Prada, El final de una ilusión. Auge y declive del tradicionalismo carlista (1957-1967), Madrid 2016, ISBN 9788416558407
  • Aurora Villanueva Martínez, Organización, actividad y bases del carlismo navarro durante el primer franquismo, [in:] Gerónimo de Uztariz 19 (2003), pp. 97–117

External links[]

Retrieved from ""