Khors

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Khors
Member of Vladimir's pantheon
Xors by Andrey Shishkin.jpg
Khors by Andrey Shishkin, 2015
Texts
  • Primary Chronicle
  • The Tale of Igor's Campaign
  • The Virgin Mary’s Journey through the Torments
  • Sermon by Saint Gregory, Found in the Comments...
  • Sermon by the Holy Father Saint John Chrysostom...
  • Sermon by One Who Loves Christ...
  • Sermon and Revelation by the Holy Apostles

Khors[a] is a Slavic god of uncertain functions mentioned since the 12th century. Generally interpreted as a sun god, sometimes as a moon god. The meaning of the theonym is also unknown: most often his name has been combined with the Iranian word for sun, such as the Persian xoršid, or the Ossetian xor, but modern linguists strongly criticize such an etymology, and other native etymologies are proposed instead.

Sources[]

Khors is the most frequently mentioned Slavic god, after Perun.[1] He first appears in the Primary Chronicle letopis along with other gods to whom Vladimir the Great erected statues:

And Vladimir began to reign alone in Kiev. And he placed idols on the hill outside the palace: a Perun in wood with a silver head and a gold moustache, and Khors, Dazhdbog and Stribog and Simargl and Mokosh. And they offered sacrifices and called them gods, and they took their sons and daughters to them and sacrificed them to the devils. And they profaned the earth with their sacrifices, and Rus’ and that hill were profaned by blood. But God the merciful, who does not wish the death of sinners, on that hill stands today the church of Saint Vasilij, as we will relate later.[2]

Old East Slavic original text
И нача къняжити Володимиръ въ Кыевѣ единъ, и постави кумиры на хълму, вънѣ двора теремьнаго: Перуна древяна, а главу его сьребряну, а усъ златъ, и Хърса, Дажьбога и Стрибога и Сѣмарьгла и Мокошь. И жьряху имъ, наричюще я богы, и привожаху сыны своя и дъщери, и жьряху бѣсомъ. И осквьрняху землю требами своими; и осквьрни ся кръвьми земля Русьская и хълмъ тъ. Нъ преблагыи Богъ не хотя съмьрти грѣшьникомъ, на томь хълмѣ нынѣ цьркы есть святаго Василия, якоже послѣди съкажемъ.
— Primary Chronicle

The second source mentioning the god is The Tale of Igor's Campaign: "Prince Vseslav was a judge for his subjects, he distributed cities among princes, but by night he ran like a wolf, from Kyiv he ran to Tmutorokan, before the cock crowed, as a wolf he ran along the road of the great Khors."[3]

God is also mentioned in the apocryphal work Sermon and Apocalypse of the Holy Apostles, which mentions Perun and Khors as old men, and Khors is credited with real life in Cyprus.[4] Khors also appears in the apocryphal text Conversation of the Three Saints, in which St. Basil, St. Gregory the Theologian, and St. John Chrysostom converse. St. John asks: "What was thunder made from?", St. Basil replies: "There are two angels of thunder. For this, the ancient Greek Perun, Khors is Jewish. And there are two angels of lightning".[5] This text combines Slavic, Christian, and Bogomil traditions.[6][4] He also occurs in other letopis-dependent sources.[4]

In proper nouns[]

Mikhail Vasil'yev cited a number of hydronyms from the Novgorod-Severian region (e.g., Khorsovo swamp, Khorsov reservoir) from the 16th-18th centuries, toponyms in Volhynia from the 10th-12th centuries, or Khrŭsovo in Bulgaria, to the right of the Danube.[7] Andrey Beskov notes that in Borova region (Ukraine), not far from the village of  [uk], there was the village of Horsivka, which is now under the Oskol reservoir. Significantly, among the inhabitants of this village were bearers of the surname Khors.[8]

God was also to be preserved in the Old Serbian name Хьрсь, Old Bulgarian Хръсъ,[9] Serbian Хрс, Hrs, Хрсовик, Hrsovik,[10] Old East Slavic Хорсъ[9] in analogy to the Polish name , from the god Dazhbog.[11] It is also possible that he was preserved in the Old Czech name Chorúš.[10] It has been proposed that the Serbian names should be regarded as alterations of the Greek name Χρυσης, Khrisis, or Χρυσος, Khrisos, but according to Aleksander Brückner this is unwarranted: these names are not Christian names, so there was no reason for the Serbs to adopt them, and Χρυσ- is spelled simply as khris-.[12]

Etymology[]

Christian, propaganda image of Khors, Georg A. Schleusing, La Religion ancienne et moderne des Moscovites, 1698.

In Old Russian sources, this theonym is noted as Xърсъ, Xŭrsŭ, Хорсъ, Xorsŭ, Хъросъ, Xŭrosŭ, and in modern Russian literature it is written as Khors (Russian: Хорс), similarly spelled by Maciej Stryjkowski - Khorsum (Polish: Chorsum, modern Chors). In English, depending on the transliteration system, the name is written as Khors, Hors, or Xors.[1][4]

Iranian etymology[]

Currently, the most popular view regarding the etymology of the theonym Khors is Iranian, and this etymology has been proposed since the 19th century. The Russian historian Pёtr Butkov, who called Khors "the Slavic Apollo", was one of the first to connect his name with the Persian خورشید, xuršit and the Ossetian xur, xor "sun," and with the Ossetian xorošŭ, хоrsŭ, xorsu meaning "good".[13] Iranian xvar "halo", Indian hāra, hāras "fire"[14] or Persian xoršid "sun", Xuršid "sun-god" are also proposed.[13][15] The Iranian word was also supposed to be the root word for Krones, the sky god in the Voguls and Ostyaks, and for the word kvar "sky", "air" in the Votyak language.[14]

Vladimir Toporov believed that the name Khors was brought to Kyiv, along with the solar cult, by soldiers from Khwarazm, who were supposedly stationed there during the reign of Vladimir the Great, but this theory has been heavily criticized. Mikhail Vasil'yev stated that the name could not have been borrowed from Middle Persian, but from Sarmatian-Alan peoples in the first millennium BC[16] (so-called Iranian inversion).

Besides the Iranian etymology, there were other theories. For example, an early loan from Ossetian xorz "good" was proposed, which would also explain the Russian word хороший, khoroshiy "good," which was originally supposed to mean "of Khors, belonging to Khors", but this possibility was rejected by Vasmer. Toporov, who also rejected borrowing from Ossetian, wrote:

The only Russian word which has really been connected by researchers with the name of Khors is – khoroshiy. This link now appears unquestionable [...]. Unquestionable is also the direction of the word formation: Khorskhoroshiy. It is only the concrete Iranian source of the name Hors that raises doubts.[17]

Criticism[]

Borrowing from Iranian languages has been accepted by religious scholars without much complaint, but linguists, such as Max Vasmer, point out phonetic problems. Iranian hva- does not explain the Slavic short vowel ъ (ŭ), and š could not in Slavic languages remain as s, but according to the ruki rule should remain either as х (h) or as š (sh) in case the word was borrowed after the rule completion.[18]

Iranian etymology also has historical problems. Khors could not have been borrowed during the reign of Vladimir the Great because by that time Persia had already converted to Islam, and the word Xoršid in Persian meant only "sun" and had no religious connotations. The name cannot be derived from the Avestan Hvar (because of the final -s), or hvarə хšаētəm: the expression was shortened to xwaršēδ/xoršid in Middle Persian during the Sassanid dynasty, at which time sun worship was transferred to the god Mitra. Additionally, at an early stage, iconoclasm prevailed in Persia and idols of Iranian gods were replaced with sacred fires. It is unclear, then, how the Eastern Slavs would have borrowed the word xwaršēδ/xoršid from Persia in such a short time, made a radical phonetic change, and placed Khors so high in the pantheon.[18] Vasil'yev tried to solve this problem by suggesting the existence of a hypothetical Sarmatian-Alan word *xors/*xūrs "King-Sun" obtained through a complex chain of assumptions, but here too the phonetic problems mentioned earlier arise.[18]

A comprehensive critique of Iranian theory was also made by Andrey Beskov.[19]

Slavic etymologies[]

From Proto-Indo-European *g̑hers-[]

Nikolaj Gorjaev (1896) was the first to link khoroshiy with Vedic हृषु, hṛṣu "glad, happy", but his proposal was not taken seriously because formerly words beginning with kh were considered loans from Iranian languages. This interpretation was renewed by Constantine Borissoff (2014). According to him, it would be expected that in South Slavic languages one would expect the Sanskrit syllable to correspond to -ŭr- and in East Slavic languages to correspond to -oro-, so that h-ṛ-ṣu and kh-oro-sh(iy) exactly agree phonetically. Semantically, in Russian khoroshiy means "good" in a broad sense: "nice", "beautiful", "pleasant," "worthy", etc., and Vedic hṛṣu has several meanings: (1) "bristling, erection (esp. of the hair in a thrill of rapture or delight)", (2) "joy, pleasure, happiness", "to be restless or impatient [for some reason] (also personified as a son of Dharma)", (3) "erection of the sexual organ, sexual excitement, lustfulness", (4) "ardent desire". The verb from hṛṣu, harṣati (हर्षति), means "becomes sexually excited"; "becomes erect or stiff or rigid, bristles". Thus, the word means deep, bodily joy. Significantly, the noun hṛṣu was also sometimes used as a theonym for the Vedic god (1) Agni or fire, (2) sun and (3) moon.[20]

Vedic hṛṣu is derived from the Proto-Indo-European root *g̑hers-/*ghers- or *g'ʰers-(eh1)-. It is thought that *g̑h/*g'ʰ gave rise to χ in Greek and Proto-Italic: Greek χαίρω, chaírō "to be satisfied", Proto-Italic *xors-ē- "to be glad", from which Latin hirsutus "prickly" and horrere "to bristle, shudder, look frightful" are derived. Toporov, who considered Khors to be an Iranian loanword, while researching the etymology of the word khoroshiy found that it is a related word for хорохориться, khorokhorit'sya "to swagger, to boast (lit. ‘to stick up’ – said of a cock’s comb)", хорзать, khorzat' "to get a swelled head, to boast", and харзиться kharzit'sya "to become exited or angry’". He noted that all of these words contain the semantic element "to grow, to increase," and he connected this with the rising sun, whose disk enlarges as it rises. According to Leo Borissoff, such etymology is questionable, and he proposes that these words should be combined with the secondary meaning of the Vedic hṛṣu - "telling lies". In this context, the Russian khorosh- may derive from an ancient fertility cult (in the broad sense of the term), according to the evolution of the meaning: "worthy, good’" ← "fertile" ← "sexually potent" ← "erect’" ← "to bristle’". Such an etymology would also explain the dialectical words хорош, khorosh "lover", хорошуль, khoroshul' "‘type of round ritual bread", and the theonym Khors itself.[21]

Other etymologies of khoroshiy[]

However, there are other proposals as to the etymology of the word khoroshiy and other related words. Linguist Zhanna Varbot (1981), in addition to the adjective khoroshiy "beautiful", also points to Russian verbs from this adjective: хорошеть khoroshet' "to become more beautiful", dialectal хорошиться, khoroshit'sya "to make self look good". She finds the comparison between khoroshyi and khorokhorit'sya valid, but points out that the main meaning of the word in literary language and most dialects is "to be brave", and is related to dialectal хорохоря, khorokhorya "feisty, impudent". In different dialects, the group of these words is used in a different sense: khorokhorit'sya "to praise, swagger", хорхора khorkhora "disheveled hen"; the words хорохора, хорхора occur in idioms with the meaning "rags": хорохорки, khorokhorki "rags", хорхоры, khorkhory "dirty rags" and Belarusian dial. хыряхоня, khyryakhonya "a person who dresses up to attract attention". According to Varbot, khorokhora originally meant "protruding feathers, wool, rags", and the verb khorokhorit'sya meant "to fluff, fluster (about birds and animals)", and this etymology is supported by the fact that ruffled feathers or fur is an element of aggressive behavior, mating rivalry, and majesty. This etymology explains the meaning of "to be conceited", "to dress up, to be pretty", and from the latter the meaning of "good", as vocabulary develops from a concrete vocabulary, to an abstract vocabulary. All of these words contain the root khor-. According to Varbot, feathers, wool, or rags can be connected in meaning with "skin", while pointing to the Russian dial. word хоравина khoravina "animal skin", which is derived from the Proto-Slavic stem *(s)kor- from PIE. root *(s)ker- "to cut, tear". Other Slavic words meaning "rough surface" derive from this root: *kora, *skora, *skorupa, *korsta. The kh occurring in the group of words related to khoroshiy, however, is the result of a common metathesis: Proto-Indo-European *skProto-Balto-Slavic *ks → Proto-Slavic *x (kh).[22]

According to , khoroshiy contains the root *xorsъ meaning "to clean" and points to dial. хорошить khoroshit' "to clean (e.g. corn, beans, etc.)". It would thus originally mean "clean" and later "pretty".[23] Max Vasmer considered this word to be a shortened form from хоро́брый khoróbryy "brave" (see PS *xorbrъ) with the suffix -sh and objected to combining it with the theonym Khors due to the lack of a confirmed form *Хоросъ.[24]

From Proto-Indo-European *kr̥ḱós[]

Aleksander Brückner (1918) also proposed a Slavic origin of the theonym. According to him, Chъrsъ in Polish would sound like chars and he finds this word in Polish dated phrases przecharsła koza or wycharsł mężczyzna meaning "emaciated, haggard, pinched, drawn" creature, or in Czech words krsati, krsnouti "to emaciate, haggard", krsek "dwarf", zakrsly, krs "dwarf shrub" with typical interchange of ch and k – the Polish word with preserved original k is karślak "knotty tree", or toponymes Karsy.[12] The Proto-Slavic form of these words is reconstructed as the adjective *kъrsъ "declined, skinny, dwarf", the verb *kъrsati "to decrease, decline", *krsnąti "to lose weight" from PIE. *kr̥ḱós "skinny" (PIE → PS s).[25][9] This interpretation was supported by Michał Łuczyński (2020). According to him, the Proto-Slavic form of theonym, *Xъrsъ, from the earlier *Kъrsъ, is formally identical with the surnames: Old Serbian Хьрсь and Old Bulgarian Xrъсъ, as well as the toponyms: Old Polish *Kars and *Chars, Serbian Hrs and Old Russian Хорсъ and others, and is derived from the adjective *kъrsъ "skinny". This reconstruction is etymologically correct, and semantically consistent with the lunar interpretation – moon as "skinny", which may have been related to lunar cycles.[9]

From Proto-Indo-European *kʷr̥s-[]

According to the Slovak linguist Martin Pukanec (2013), the theonym Khors does not have a Proto-Slavic genesis. He points here to a Slavic TarT/TorT (T = any consonant) switch that occurred around 800. Proto-Slavic TorT in East Slavic languages passed into ToroT, so Proto-Slavic *Xor should pass into East Slavic *Xoro, and such a notation is not confirmed by the sources. According to him, there is also no reliable attestation of this theonym in West and South Slavic languages. In that case, according to Pukanec, the theonym was borrowed from Persian xuršēt "shining sun", but he does not address the criticism of such etymology by other linguists presented earlier.[26]

He also points to another possibility. Proto-Slavic TorT passed into Church Slavonic as TъrT and TrъT, which would explain both notations *Xorsъ and *Xъrsъ and recognizes the *Xъrsъ notation as primary. As the PS *x may derive from PIE *k or *g, when searching for the PIE etymology of the word, attention must be paid primarily to the rounded phones *kʷ, *gʷ, and *gʷʰ; the Proto-Indo-European stem can thus be reconstructed as *kʷr̥s- or *gʷr̥s- or *gʷʰr̥s-. Of the aforementioned stems, only one, *kʷr̥s-, is found in Julius Pokorny's Indogermanisches etymologisches Wörterbuch, who reconstructed this stem using Greek πρῖνος, prînos "oak (holly)", Gaulish prenne "large tree", Old High German horst, hurst "bush, thicket" or Slovene hrást "oak", which, like the theonym in question, contain a vowel between -r- and -s-. Such a reconstruction would indicate functions similar to those of Perun, the god of storms and oaks.[26]

Interpretations[]

Khors-Dazhbog – Sun god[]

Scholars who assume an Iranian etymology most often attribute the solar features to Khors. The main argument is the root of the theonim meaning "sun" in the first place, regardless of which exact word that root was. Moreover, according to The Tale of Igor's Campaign, Prince Vseslav, who "came to Tmutarakani before the cocks" and "ran along the road of the great Khors", traveled from west to east and thus reached the castle before the cocks crowed, and in this way "overtook" the Sun.[27]

It has also been pointed out in the text of the Primary Chronicle where, when listing the statues of the gods, only between Khors and Dazhbog, the sun god, no conjunction "and" is used (unlike the rest of the gods), and this, according to many scholars, would suggest that Khors is another name of Dadzbog, his hypostasis, or that they are related in some other way.[14][28] Such a view was supported e.g. by Henryk Łowmiański, according to whom Dazhbog was an explanation of Khors. He pointed out, however, that he was not sure if conjunction wasn't there.[29] Brückner argued against this view, claiming that the lack of conjunctions was irrelevant, and he considered the association of Dazhbog with Khors to be unjustified.[30] An analysis of the spelling of Old East Slavic sources confirms Brückner's view: the lack of a conjunction often occurs in the enumeration of choronyms, ethnonyms, hydronyms, anthroponyms, and theonyms, e.g.: copy of Novgorod First Chronicle: "... и стриба сенмарекла мокошь", Sermon and Revelation by the Holy Apostles: "пероуна и хорса и ", Sermon by Saint Gregory, found in the comments: "молятся (...) нероуноу. хорсу мокоши".[31]

Moon god[]

Some scholars, who also assume an Iranian etymology, believe that Chors was a lunar god, and that the meaning of his name refers not to the rays of the sun, but to the rays of the moon.[27]

It is pointed out here that Vseslav was called a "wolf" and werewolfism is associated with the moon, while the prince's journey itself takes place at night when the sun is absent from the sky, thus he could not cut the path of the sun but the moon.[32][33] Additionally, it is also pointed out that Tmutarakan is not located from Kyiv to the east, but to the southeast.[27] A probable misunderstanding of the phrase "to the hens" is also pointed out. In Old East Slavic this phrase meant "until late; at night", "until dawn, before dawn", and Russian dial. phrase до вторых кочетов meant "until late; after midnight' (literally: "to the other roosters"). As phrases beginning with "до" meant night and morning phrases starting with "со" (cf. со вторыми кочетами), it can be concluded that Vseslav arrived in the city at night, not in the morning.[34] Łuczynski also points out that the epithet "great" (OES великому, velikomu) used in relation to Khors in The Tale, which is usually[34] taken as an argument for the solar interpretation, can be understood differently: in Slavic folklore the epithet "great" is often used in relation to the moon, e.g. the Polish wielki księżyc, Croatian and Slovenian velik mesec, and he further compares the Old Russian phrase to the Old Norse kenning mána vegr "sky", literally "the way of the moon".[34]

The interpretation of the name Khors as "emaciated" was supported by linguist Wanda Budziszewska. She reports that the waning moon was called "puny, frail" among the Slavs: Polish dial. (Podhale and the Cracow area) wietek, wiotek, Old Czech vetech, Belarusian v́òtak and Russian vétoch. In Old Polish, the word wiotchy meant "frail because of wear, use, old age"[35] (PS *vetъxъ).

God of fertility and vegetation[]

According to the linguist Constantine Borrisoff, who assumes a Slavic etymology of Khors, tying Khors to the sun or sun disk adds little to the discussion of the god's function, since in world mythologies major deities are very often tied to the sun. Instead, tying his etymology to the PIE. root *g̑hers-, he compares Khors to the Greek Dionysus, as dying-and-rising deity.[1]

According to scholars such as Oleg Trubachov and Evel Gasparini, Slavic deities should not be directly compared with classical ones because of the difference in development. The language and religion of the Slavs were archaic (for this reason should not be ignored in the reconstruction of Proto-Indo-European mythology), making it more accurate to compare the religion of the Slavs to, for example, the Minoan religion. At the center of the Minoan religion was the Great Goddess, and her mortal but eternally reborn beloved, resembling Attis and Dionysus, whom Lewis Richard Farnell called "Zeus-Dionysus of Crete".[36]

Dionysus, in addition to being the god of wine, was the god of trees and vegetation in general. The cult of Dionysus is believed to be of Thraco-Phrygian, or exclusively Thracian, origin. Even if this cult originated in another culture, the fact that this cult was particularly strong near the area where Trubachov placed the homeland of the Proto-Slavic tribes is of great importance in this context. In the Balkans, where the Thracians lived, there are many names like Greek Crestonia and Cherso, Bulgarian  [bg], and Romanian Hârșova, as well as words like Greek χάρις, cháris "beauty, delight," and Bulgarian харесам, kharesam "[I] like, love" – all of which are phonetically and semantically compatible with Vedic hṛṣu/harṣa. In studying the cult of Dionysus, Toporov noted that the characteristics of the dying-and-rising deity are also manifested in Slavic folklore and rituals related to marriage, New Year traditions, and seasonal festivals. Additionally, Dionysus' animal incarnations were the bull and goat, which are symbols of fertility, and in this context the Latin name for the he-goat hircus can not be coincidental.[37]

According to Herodotus, the Thracians worshiped a trinity: Dionysus, Ares, and Artemis. Artemis may have been the counterpart of the local goddess Semele, the mother of Dionysus. Semele is one of the related words for the Indo-European word meaning "earth" and appears in other mythologies as Phrygian ζεμέλω, Zemélō "Mother-Earth," Lithuanian Žemė Pati "Earth Spouse," Žemyna – goddess of earth, and the Slavic archetype and personification Mati Syra Zemlya. Semele thus may be a link between Slavic and Thracian cults.[38]

In Slavic mythology, there are figures and gods who have historically been associated with the theme of the dying-and-rising deity: in the Balkans it is Zeleni Juraj, in the Eastern Slavs it is Jarilo, and in the Western Slavs it is Jarovit. All these figures, and Saint George, their Christian continuator, are depicted as heroes on a white horse, and such an image would suggest a connection with the Thracian Rider, also called Heros. Toporov suggested a common etymology for Greek ἥρως, hḗrōs "hero, protector," ὧρος, hō̂ros "time, season," Avestan yar- "year," German Jahre "year," Slavic jare "spring", "vehement, fervent", and Jarovit and Jarilo. Khors cannot be etymologically connected directly with ἥρως hḗrōs because the -s in the Greek word is morphological. However, according to some scholars, heros on Thracian inscriptions does not always correspond to the Greek heros, but more to Eros. According to Borrisoff, the new interpretation of Khors does not create a contradiction between Eros and Dionysus or Agni, who combines the characteristics of Helios, Eros, Ares and Dionysus.[20]

According to Borrisoff, this interpretation also supports the Khors-Dazhbog dualistic interpretation: he argues that in the Eastern Slavs Dazhbog has solar qualities and in the Southern Slavs chthonic qualities and compares them to the deity Rudra-Shiva, who combines procreative and destructive qualities.[39] He also links Khors with Slovenian sun god Kresnik.[40]

Baltic parallels[]

According to Borrisoff, the proto-form of the theonym Khors should be *h(V)rs-, which according to the ruki rule evolved into the Slavic languages as *h(V)rx, and into the Baltic languages should evolve as *h(V)rš, and finding a Baltic continuator of this proto-form should finally refute the Iranian etymology. He finds this continuator in the Prussian god (mentioned from the 13th century onwards), whose exact functions are subject to debate, but the consensus is to regard his worship as primarily connected with the sphere of fertility. His symbol, as with Dionysus, was the bull, and some scholars have considered him to be an echo of the worship of the Great Goddess and the son or husband of Žemyna.[41]

The image of the Curcho was destroyed after the harvest and re-done annually, he was the protector of all field fruits, food and drink was in his care, he was a cheerful table God.

However, Curche cannot be a direct continuation of the preform *h(V)rs, since there is no kh sound in Baltic languages, and the correct Baltic form should be *kurk. For this reason, Curche is considered to have been borrowed from Slavic, and as early as the 19th century a loan from the neighboring Masurians was suggested, and the Slavic origin of Curcho may be indicated by the Sorbian deity . However, the Baltic continuation of this word may be the Lithuanian Kuršis – the spirit of grain.[41]

Alleged idol[]

Stone baba found near Pskov. According to Vunderer's description it represents , and according to Kirpichnikov's interpretation Khors or Dazhbog.

The German traveler Johann David Wunderer, who traveled in Russia from 1589 to 1590 and described Pskov in his memoir, mentioned the statues of Khors and that were supposed to be located near Pskov:

In front of the town we saw two idols, set up in olden times by the priests who worshipped them, namely, Usad, whose stone statue holds a cross in his hand, (and) Khors, who stands on a serpent, with a sword in one hand and a thunderbolt (literally, a ray of fire - A.K.) in the other.

In his diary, Wunderer described Pskov freshly, although when he was editing the manuscript, he added elements that are borrowed from other sources, and they add more detailed information that, however, are easily identifiable. Wunderer could not have known the names of the gods depicted on the stone primarily because the Uslad he mentions is in fact a pseudodeity, his name came about as a result of a distortion of a passage in Primary Chronicle in which a golden statue of Perun is described, Sigismund von Herberstein recognized the word golden (us zlat) as an independent name Uslad, and he never existed in the Russian pantheon. Many historians considered the mentioned passage unreliable.[42]

Wunderer realized that a field camp of Stephen Báthory, who besieged Pskov in 1581-1582, had once been located near the statues, and this information led to the location of the statues he described. The camp was located south of Pskov and lay on both sides of the Promiezhitsa stream, which separated the flat terrain around the city from the wooded hills and mountains that stretched all the way to the Cheremcha river, and the statues must have been located near it. The existence of the idol was unexpectedly confirmed when, during excavations in 1897, the so-called stone baba (a conventional name for stone statues depicting people in Eastern Europe) was found between Promiezhitsa and the factory. The statue was probably not found in its original place, but that place must have been nearby anyway. During World War II, the statue, which was in the Pskov Museum, was lost, but photographs from 1928-1929 have survived. The idol was about 100 cm. long, and had a cross on its chest, which was made at the same time as the rest of the sculpture, but the idol was deliberately damaged, and only the head is preserved in good condition.[42]

According to Russian archaeologist  [ru] the figure is related to the Slavic paganism. The location of the statue and the sign of the cross coincide exactly with Wunderer's description. The cross, which is an ancient symbol of the sun, is supposed to testify to the relationship of the god in the statue with the sun, and the statue itself is supposed to represent Khors or Dazhbog.[42] Some researchers have suggested that the statue belongs to Christian culture. The statue is dated to the 8th to 10th century.[43]

References[]

Notes
  1. ^ Old East Slavic: Хърсъ, Хорсъ
    Russian: Хорс IPA: [xˈors]
References
  1. ^ a b c Borissoff 2014, p. 9.
  2. ^ Alvarez-Pedroza 2021, p. 277–278.
  3. ^ Alvarez-Pedroza 2021, p. 305.
  4. ^ a b c d Gieysztor 2006, p. 180-181.
  5. ^ Alvarez-Pedroza 2021, p. 358.
  6. ^ Santos Marinas 2013.
  7. ^ Vasil'yev 1999, p. 17.
  8. ^ Beskov 2010, p. 82-83.
  9. ^ a b c d Łuczyński 2020, p. 117.
  10. ^ a b Váňa 1990, p. 79.
  11. ^ Brückner 1985, p. 156.
  12. ^ a b Brückner 1985, p. 157.
  13. ^ a b Borissoff 2014, p. 9-10.
  14. ^ a b c Gieysztor 2006, p. 181.
  15. ^ Szyjewski 2003, p. 108.
  16. ^ Borissoff 2014.
  17. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 15–16.
  18. ^ a b c Borissoff 2014, p. 11-12.
  19. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 15.
  20. ^ a b Borissoff 2014, p. 18.
  21. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 16-17.
  22. ^ Varbot 1981.
  23. ^ Shanskiy & Bobrova 2004, p. 213.
  24. ^ Vasmer 1986, p. 267.
  25. ^ Trubachyov 1987, p. 240.
  26. ^ a b Pukanec 2013, p. 49-52.
  27. ^ a b c Szyjewski 2003, p. 108-109.
  28. ^ Szyjewski 2003, p. 108–109.
  29. ^ Łowmiański 1979, p. 125-126.
  30. ^ Brückner 1985, p. 140, 157.
  31. ^ Łuczyński 2020, p. 38-39.
  32. ^ Gieysztor 2006, p. 181-182..
  33. ^ Brückner 1985, p. 18, 156..
  34. ^ a b c Łuczyński 2020, p. 40-41.
  35. ^ Budziszewska 1999.
  36. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 19-20.
  37. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 20-21.
  38. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 21-22.
  39. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 26-27.
  40. ^ Borissoff 2014, p. 25.
  41. ^ a b Borissoff 2014, p. 22-23.
  42. ^ a b c Kirpichnikov 1988, p. 34-37.
  43. ^ "Культурные ценности – Жертвы войны - Идол". www.lostart.ru. Retrieved 2021-02-13.

Bibliography[]

  • Alvarez-Pedroza, Juan Antonio (2021). Sources of Slavic Pre-Christian Religion. Leiden: Koninklijke Brill. ISBN 978-90-04-44138-5.
  • Beskov, Andrey Anatolyevich (2010). Восточнославянское язычество: Религиоведческий анализ (in Russian). Saarbrücken: LAMBERT Academic Publishing. ISBN 978-3843300230.
  • Borissoff, Constantine Leo (2014). "Non-Iranian origin of the Eastern-Slavonic god Xŭrsŭ/Xors". Studia Mythologica Slavica. 17: 9–36. doi:10.3986/sms.v17i0.1491. ISSN 1581-128X.
  • Brückner, Aleksander (1985). Mitologia słowiańska i polska (in Polish). Warsaw: Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. ISBN 83-01-06245-2.
  • Budziszewska, Wanda (1999). "Dwie kultowe nazwy księżyca u Słowian". In Bartmiński, Jerzy (ed.). Językowy obraz świata (in Polish). 12. Lublin: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Marii Curie-Skłodowskiej.
  • Gieysztor, Aleksander (2006). Mitologia Słowian (in Polish). Warsaw: Wydawnictwa Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego. ISBN 978-83-235-0234-0.
  • Kirpichnikov, Anatol Nikolayevich (1988). "Древнерусское святилище у Пскова". Древности славян и Руси (in Russian). Moscow: Nauka. ISBN 5-02-009419-6.
  • Łowmiański, Henryk (1979). Religia Słowian i jej upadek, w. VI-XII (in Polish). Warsaw: Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. ISBN 83-01-00033-3.
  • Łuczyński, Michał (2020). Bogowie dawnych Słowian. Studium onomastyczne (in Polish). Kielce: Kieleckie Towarzystwo Naukowe. ISBN 978-83-60777-83-1.
  • Pukanec, Martin (2013). Martin Pukanec: Etymologický nákres slovanského sveta bohov a démonov (náboženstva a morálky Slovanov) (in Slovak). Nitra: Constantine the Philosopher University. ISBN 978-80-558-0280-0.
  • Santos Marinas, Enrique (2013). "Reassessment, Unification, and Enlargement of the Sources of Slavic Pre-Christian Religion". Russian History. 40 (1): 27–40. doi:10.1163/18763316-04001003. ISSN 0094-288X.
  • Shanskiy, Nikolay; Bobrova, Tatyana (2004). Школьный этимологический словарь русского языка. Происхождение слов (in Russian). Moscow: Дрофа. p. 231. ISBN 5-7107-8679-9.
  • Szyjewski, Andrzej (2003). Religia Słowian (in Polish). Kraków: Wydawnictwo WAM. ISBN 83-7318-205-5.
  • Trubachyov, Oleg (1987). "*kъrsъ". Этимологический словарь русского языка (in Russian). 13. Moscow: Nauka.
  • Varbot, Zhanna Zhanovna (1981). "Славянские этимологии (*opoka; *nadovьsь и *nadovьsьnь; *žęžel'ь; *kobica, *zakobenь и др.; *xorošьjь и *xorxoriti sę)" (PDF). Этимология. 1979 (in Russian). Moscow: Nauka. pp. 37–42.
  • Váňa, Zdeněk (1990). Svět slovanských bohů a démonů (in Czech). Praga: Panorama. ISBN 80-7038-187-6.
  • Vasil'yev, Mikhail Alexandrovich (1999). Язычество восточных славян накануне крещения Руси: Религиозно-мифологическое взаимодействие с иранским миром. Языческая реформа князя Владимира (in Russian). Moscow: Индрик. ISBN 978-5-85759-087-4.
  • Vasmer, Max (1986). "хороший". Этимологический словарь русского языка (in Russian). 2. Translated by Trubachyov, Oleg (2 ed.). Moscow: Progress.

Further reading[]

Retrieved from ""