Year
|
Category
|
Nominated work
|
Result
|
Ref.
|
1999
|
Boston Society of Film Critics Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
The Insider
|
Won
|
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
New York Film Critics Circle Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
San Diego Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
2000
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Las Vegas Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
National Society of Film Critics Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Online Film & Television Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Online Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
2002
|
National Board of Review Award, Best Acting by an Ensemble
|
Nicholas Nickelby
|
Won
|
|
2005
|
Online Film & Television Association Award, Best Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture or Miniseries
|
Our Fathers
|
Nominated
|
|
2007
|
Method Fest Award, Best Ensemble Cast
|
Man in the Chair
|
Won
|
|
Palm Beach International Film Festival Award, Best Lead Actor
|
Won
|
|
2010
|
AARP Movies for Grownups Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
The Last Station
|
Nominated
|
|
AARP Movies for Grownups Award, Best Grownup Love Story (shared with Helen Mirren)
|
Nominated
|
|
2011
|
Awards Circuit Community Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Beginners
|
Won
|
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Golden Schmoes Award, Best Supporting Actor of the Year
|
Nominated
|
|
Gotham Award, Best Ensemble Performance
|
Won
|
|
Hollywood Film Festival Award, Best Supporting Actor of the Year
|
Won
|
|
Houston Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Indiana Film Journalists Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Indiewire Critic's Poll Award, Best Supporting Performance
|
Won
|
|
Kansas City Film Critics Circle Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
National Board of Review Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
New York Film Critics Circle Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Phoenix Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
San Diego Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Satellite Award, Best Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture
|
Nominated
|
|
Southeastern Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Toronto Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Utah Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Village Voice Film Poll Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Washington DC Area Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
2012
|
AARP Movies for Grownups Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
ACTRA Award, Outstanding Performance - Male
|
Won
|
|
Santa Barbara International Film Festival Award, Special Jury Prize for Artistic Merit
|
Won
|
|
Alliance of Women Film Journalists Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Central Ohio Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Chlotrudis Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Critics Choice Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Denver Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Gay and Lesbian Entertainment Critics Association Award, Film Performance of the Year
|
Nominated
|
|
Gold Derby Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
International Cinephile Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
International Online Cinema Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
International Online Film Critic's Poll Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
Iowa Film Critics Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
London Critics Circle Film award, Best Supporting Actor of the Year
|
Nominated
|
|
National Society of Film Critics Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
North Texas Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Online Film & Television Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Online Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Won
|
|
2014
|
Women Film Critics Circle Award, Best Screen Couple (shared with Shirley MacLaine)
|
Elsa & Fred
|
Nominated
|
|
2015
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Award, Best Actor in a Canadian Film
|
Remember
|
Nominated
|
|
2016
|
ACTRA Award, Outstanding Performance - Male
|
Won
|
|
Hanoi International Film Festival, Best Main Actor
|
Won
|
|
Women Film Critics Circle Award, Best Lead Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
2018
|
AARP Movies for Grownups Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
All the Money in the World
|
Nominated
|
|
Hawaii Film Critics Society Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|
North Carolina Film Critics Association Award, Best Supporting Actor
|
Nominated
|
|