2010 New York's 29th congressional district elections

2010 New York's 29th congressional district election

← 2008 November 2, 2010 (2010-11-02) 2012 →

Nominee Tom Reed Matthew Zeller Party Republican Democratic Popular vote 94,209 (special) 101,209 (general) 73,513 (special) 78,578 (general) Percentage 56% 44%

Representative before election Eric Massa Democratic Elected Representative Tom Reed Republican

Elections in New York State
show Federal government Presidential elections 1792 1796 1800 1804 1808 1812 1816 1820 1824 1828 1832 1836 1840 1844 1848 1852 1856 1860 1864 1868 1872 1876 1880 1884 1888 1892 1896 1900 1904 1908 1912 1916 1920 1924 1928 1932 1936 1940 1944 1948 1952 1956 1960 1964 1968 1972 1976 1980 1984 1988 1992 1996 2000 2004 Dem 2008 Dem GOP 2012 2016 Dem GOP 2020 Dem U.S. Senate 1789 1791 1795 1796 sp 1797 Jan 1798 sp Aug 1798 sp Apr 1800 sp Nov 1800 sp 1801 1802 sp 1803 Feb 1804 sp Nov 1804 sp 1807 1809 1813 1815 1819–20 1821 1825–26 1827 1829 sp 1831 1833 1833 sp 1837 1839–40 1843 1845 sp 1849 1851 1855 1857 1861 1863 1867 1869 1873 1875 1879 1881 1881 sp 1885 1887 1891 1893 1897 1899 1903 1905 1909 1911 1914 1916 1920 1922 1926 1928 1932 1934 1938 1938 sp 1940 1944 1946 1949 sp 1950 1952 1956 1958 1962 1964 1968 1970 1974 1976 1980 1982 1986 1988 1992 1994 1998 2000 2004 2006 2010 2010 sp 2012 2016 2018 2022 2024 U.S. House 1789 1790 1791 1st sp 1793 1794 1796 1798 1799 1st sp 1800 1801 5th sp 1801 6th sp 1802 1803 6th sp 1803 7th sp 1804 1st sp 2nd and 3rd sp 1805 2nd and 3rd sp 1806 1808 12th sp 1810 2nd sp 1812 6th sp 1813 15th sp 1813 2nd sp 1814 1815 6th sp 1815 12th sp 1816 20th sp 21st sp 1817 4th sp 1818 1821 6th sp 1821 9th sp 1822 1823 28th sp 1824 1826 1827 29th sp 1828 5th sp 1830 6th sp 20th sp 1832 1834 1836 17th sp 30th sp 1838 1840 1841 26th May sp 26th Nov sp 1842 1844 1846 12th sp 1848 1850 1852 1854 12th sp 1856 1858 1859 4th sp 1860 31st sp 1862 1863 14th sp 1864 1866 1868 1870 1872 1874 1876 1878 1879 12th sp 1880 32nd sp 1881 9th sp 11th sp 22nd sp 1881 27th sp 1882 1884 1885 8th sp 1886 15th sp 1888 1889 6th sp 9th sp 27th sp 1890 1891 2nd sp 10th sp 1891 12th sp 22nd sp 1892 1894 14th sp 15th sp 1895 10th sp 1896 1897 3rd sp 1898 1899 34th sp 1900 1902 26th sp 1904 12th sp 1906 8th sp 1908 3rd sp 1910 1912 26th sp 1913 13th sp 20th sp 1914 1915 31st sp 1916 1917 15th sp 1918 7th sp 8th sp 21st sp 22nd sp 1920 14th sp 26th sp 1922 1923 11th sp 16th sp 19th sp 24th sp 32nd sp 1924 1926 1927 35th sp 1928 32nd sp 1929 21st sp 1930 18th sp 1931 7th sp 9th sp 1932 1933 34th sp 1934 1935 2nd sp 22nd sp 1936 1937 27th sp 17th sp 25th sp 1938 1939 34th sp 1940 14th sp 22nd sp 31st sp 1941 14th sp 17th sp 1942 1944 4th sp 11th sp 21st sp 1946 19th sp 1947 14th sp 1948 24th sp 1949 7th sp 10th sp 20th sp 1950 1952 5th sp 32nd sp 1954 1956 22nd sp 1958 1959 43rd sp 1960 23rd sp 1962 6th sp 1964 1966 17th sp 1968 13th sp 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 18th sp 21st sp 1980 1982 1983 7th sp 1984 1986 6th sp 1988 1990 14th sp 18th sp 1992 17th sp 1994 1996 1997 13th sp 1998 6th sp 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2009 20th sp 23rd sp 2010 29th sp 2011 9th sp 26th sp 2012 2014 2015 11th sp 2016 2018 14th 25th sp 2020 27th sp
show State government New York gubernatorial elections 1777 1780 1783 1786 1789 1792 1795 1798 1801 1804 1807 1810 1813 1816 1817 1820 1822 1824 1826 1828 1830 1832 1834 1836 1838 1840 1842 1844 1846 1848 1850 1852 1854 1856 1858 1860 1862 1864 1866 1868 1870 1872 1874 1876 1879 1882 1885 1888 1891 1894 1896 1898 1900 1902 1904 1906 1908 1910 1912 1914 1916 1918 1920 1922 1924 1926 1928 1930 1932 1934 1936 1938 1942 1946 1950 1954 1958 1962 1966 1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010 2014 2018 2022 Attorney General elections 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010 2014 2018 2022 State Comptroller elections 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010 2014 2018 State Senate elections 2018 2020 2022 State Assembly elections 99th district, 2006 2016 2018 2020 2022 State elections by year 1811-LtGSE 1844 1846 1847-JSE 1847 1848 1849 1850 1851 1852 1853 1854 1855 1856 1857 1858 1859 1860 1861 1862 1863 1864 1865 1866 1867 1868 1869 1870 1870–JSE 1871 1872 1873 1874 1875 1876 1877 1878 1879 1880 1881 1882 1883 1884 1885 1886 1887 1888 1889 1890 1891 1892 1893 1894 1895 1896 1897 1898 1900 1902 1903 1904 1906 1907 1908 1910 1912 1913 1914 1916 1917 1918 1920 1921 1922 1923 1924 1926 1927 1928 1930 1932 1933 1934 1936 1937 1938 1939 1940 1942 1943 1944 1946 1949 1950 1952 1953 1954 1956 1958 1959 1960 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1972 1973 1974 2002 2006 2008 2009 2010 2012 2016 2020
show New York City Characteristics of NYC mayoral elections Mayoral elections Pre-consolidation: 1886 Post-consolidation: 1917 1929 1932 1933 1937 1941 1945 1953 1957 1961 1965 1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013 2017 2021 City Council elections Pre-consolidation: 1808 Post-consolidation: 1897 1927 1929 1931 1933 1935 1937 1939 2013 2017 2021 Public Advocate elections 1897 1929 1933 2009 2013 2017 2019 (special) 2019 2021 Comptroller elections 1929 1993 2009 2013 2021 Borough president elections 1897 1901 1929 1933 2013 2017 2021 The Bronx Brooklyn Manhattan Queens Staten Island
show Albany Mayoral elections 2005 2009 2013 2017 2021
show Buffalo Mayoral elections 1881 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013 2017 2021
show Rochester Mayoral elections 1997 2001 2005 2009 2011 sp 2013 2017 2021
show Syracuse Mayoral elections 2009 2013 2017 2021
v t

Two elections in New York's 29th district were held on November 2, 2010. The candidates vied to replace Eric Massa, who resigned the seat on March 8, 2010 as a result of health issues and allegations of sexual harassment.

The Governor called for a special election to be held simultaneously with the general election on the same day, with the special election determining who would fill out the remainder of Massa's term in the 111th United States Congress (from November 2010 to January 2011) and the general election determining who serves in the 112th United States Congress.

Republican Thomas W. Reed, Jr., the former mayor of Corning, New York, defeated Democrat Matthew Zeller, a CIA analyst and war veteran who was living in Washington, DC at the time of Massa's resignation, and Janice Volk, a write-in candidate.

The old 29th District will be replaced by the new 23rd District and includes Ithaca.

Background[]

Democrat Eric J. Massa won this district by 1.8 percentage points in 2008 over then-two-term incumbent John "Randy" Kuhl. The district leans Republican (CPVI R+5), voted for John McCain over Barack Obama by a 51-48 margin, and, accounting for redistricting, had been held by a Republicans for almost a century, except for Democrat Stan Lundine's time representing the area in the 1970s and 1980s.^[1] Massa, as of early 2009, had an active campaign war chest of over $38,000, most of it from labor union interests,^[2] and intended on using the fund for a 2010 campaign.^[3] At the time of his resignation, he had raised over $600,000.^[4] The NRCC targeted Massa for voting in favor of the Recovery and Reinvestment Act.^[5]

However, on March 3, 2010, Massa announced that he would retire after his first term, following reports that he had suffered a recurrence of cancer and allegations of sexual harassment; Massa later announced his resignation effective March 8.^[6] Governor David Paterson had the option to call a special election (much as resignations in the 20th and 23rd districts prompted), but because it is an election year, Paterson was not compelled to do so immediately. Much speculation was aired over when the special election would occur, but it ultimately was set to coincide with the general election.^[7][8][9]

On April 23, 2010, Steuben County Republican chairman Bill Hatch announced that he would be filing a lawsuit that, if successful, would force the governor to acknowledge the vacancy and call the special election in the immediate future.^[10] Clause I.2.4 of the U.S. Constitution requires the governor of a state issue a "writ of election" for any congressional vacancies, which would technically place Governor Paterson in contempt if he did not recognize the vacancy. The judge hearing the case denied a motion from the Paterson administration to dismiss the lawsuit on May 13.^[11]

On May 12, 2010, Paterson announced that he would set the special election for November 2, 2010, and would not issue the required writ of election until October. This would result in the seat remaining vacant for eight months, far longer than the 30 to 40 days dictated by New York law. It would also result in a general election and special election occurring on the same day, with the winner of the special election serving from the moment the election is certified (or the loser concedes, whichever is first) until January 2011, and the winner of the general election serving from that point until 2013. Furthermore, the redundant election complicates the primary election process: it would be theoretically possible for either Reed or Zeller to be defeated in the primary election in mid-September, but then remain on the ballot for the special election.^[12] On top of this, state law dictates that special elections cannot be held for vacancies acknowledged after July 1, except in special circumstances.^[13] Following the announcement, Angelo Campini, who is challenging Reed in the primary election, stated that he would consider joining the lawsuit or filing one of his own over the date of the election if it resulted in him being pushed off the ballot.^[14]

Judge David Larimer issued a ruling in the case on June 4, 2010, officially acknowledging the vacancy, but ignoring the state law regarding the requirement for calling a special election within 30 to 40 days of the acknowledged vacancy. As such, Larimer would not compel Paterson to call the election before November 2.^[15] The plaintiffs considered an appeal but never followed through.^[16]

Candidates[]

Democratic party[]

The Democrats took longer to choose a candidate for office. After most of the names that were mentioned pulled themselves out of consideration, the party chose Matthew Zeller, a 28-year-old CIA analyst who had not lived in New York since he had left for war. Zeller was an ROTC-trained Army officer who served in Afghanistan and holds master's degrees in international relations and public administration.^[17]

Nominee[]

• Matthew Zeller, former CIA analyst and Afghanistan veteran^[17]

Not running[]

• John Batiste, retired Major General^[8]
• Sandra Frankel, town supervisor of Brighton, former lieutenant governor candidate^[18]
• Mike Green, Monroe County District Attorney^[19]
• Shawn Hogan, mayor of Hornell^[20]
• Susan John, assemblywoman (speculated)
• David Koon, assemblyman^[21]
• Barbara Lifton, assemblywoman from Ithaca^[22][23]
• Michael McCormick, former Allegany County legislator, instead ran for Catharine Young's seat in state senate and lost^[24]
• David Nachbar, Massa's 2008 primary opponent, Bausch & Lomb executive (speculated), instead ran for Joseph Errigo's former seat in state assembly and lost to Sean Hanna^[25]
• Ellen Polimeni, mayor of Canandaigua^[25]
• David Rose, teacher in the Henrietta-Rush School District^[26]
• John Tonello, mayor of Elmira (speculated)^[27]
• Mary Wilmot, regional director for the Paterson administration, heir to the Wilmorite fortune, instead ran for James Alesi's seat in state senate and lost^[25][28]

Republican party[]

Nominee[]

• Tom Reed, former mayor of Corning

Not running, or eliminated[]

• Angelo Campini, pizza shop owner from Henrietta ^[29] Failed to deliver a petition to get onto the primary ballot.^[30] After proposing a write-in campaign, Campini bowed out on September 30, 2010, endorsing Reed.^[31]
• Janice Volk, Cuba resident, alpaca farmer and black conservative community activist^[32][33] Submitted 1,400 signatures to secure primary ballot, but those petitions were challenged.^[34] Enough of the signatures were stricken that could invalidate the nomination, but some were on questionable grounds (such as one that claimed that Gowanda, New York did not exist). Though Volk later announced plans to seek a third-party line,^[35] she was unable to do so. Volk insists she is still in the race through a write-in campaign.^[36]
• Maggie Brooks, county executive of Monroe County^[37]
• Brian Kolb, Minority Leader of the New York State Assembly^[38]
• Randy Kuhl, former congressman and state senator^[39]
• Catharine Young, state senator^[40]

Independence Party[]

• Tom Reed, Republican nominee^[41][42]

Conservative Party[]

• Tom Reed, Republican nominee

Working Families Party[]

• Matthew Zeller, Democratic nominee

Horse Race Metrics[]

At the time of Massa's resignation, the lone announced candidate, Tom Reed, had approximately $120,000 cash on hand.^[4] According to Reed, "in our last report, we raised $233,000."^[43]

As of the first quarter of 2010, Reed has raised $481,879^[44] and had $287,222 cash on hand.^[29]

As of July 2010, Volk had not yet raised enough funds to need to file with the Federal Election Commission, which would indicate less than $5,000 in fundraising and/or spending.^[45] Reed raised $686,449 by that point, approximately $100,000 from his own account, while Zeller had raised $137,885.^[46]

As of September 2010, Reed had raised $809,464 and had $361,315 in cash on hand. Zeller raised $232,425 and had $50,418 in cash on hand.^[47]

With Reed heavily favored, he donated $75,000 of his campaign money to the National Republican Congressional Committee and the New York Senate Republican Committee less than one week before the election.^[48]

Endorsements[]

Tom Reed[]

• James Alesi, state senator
• James Bacalles, assemblyman and former mayor of Corning
• Amo Houghton, former representative
• Randy Kuhl, former representative
• Bill Paxon, former representative
• George Winner, state senator
• Catharine Young, state senator
• Angelo Campini, potential primary challenger
• Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
• Messenger-Post Newspapers (Canandaigua, NY)
• The Leader (Corning, NY)

Matthew Zeller[]

• Louise Slaughter, Member of Congress
• Shawn Hogan, Mayor of Hornell, NY
• The Buffalo News
• 1199SEIU United Healthcare Workers East
• Finger Lakes Times (Geneva, NY)

Janice Volk[]

• Jim Ostrowski, 1994 Libertarian Party gubernatorial candidate and WNY Tea Party Coalition Co-Founder
• Amy McManus/Amy Mikolajczyk, talk show host on WLEA out of Hornell, NY and future Hornell city council candidate
• David Chamberlain, Village of Cuba, NY Mayor (1990–1995)

Polling[]

Poll Source	Date(s) administered	Tom Reed (R)	Matthew Zeller (D)	Undecided
Siena poll	September 21, 2010	44%	30%	26%
We Ask America	April 20, 2010	41.38%	24.01%	34.62%

Results[]

Reed won by a 56%-44% vote in both the special and the general elections. Reed, for the first time since Amo Houghton in 2002, won every county in the district. However, he lost his home city of Corning, as well as the city of Hornell.^[49] All write-ins, including (but not exclusively) Volk's, totaled 527 votes for the general and 510 for the special, less than 0.3% of the vote.^[50]

Hornell mayor Shawn Hogan predicted that unless Zeller were to move back to Washington, DC, that Zeller would run for the seat again in 2012.^[51]

References[]

Specific

General

• Politics Now: Reed gains Paxon's support for Massa seat. The Buffalo News. March 5, 2010.

External links[]

• New York State Board of Elections
  • Official candidate list (general election)
• U.S. Congress candidates for New York at Project Vote Smart
• NY - District 29 from OurCampaigns.com
• House - New York from the Cook Political Report
• Race ranking and details from CQ Politics
• Campaign contributions from OpenSecrets.org
• Race profile at The New York Times

Official campaign sites

• Campini for Congress
• Reed for Congress
• Volk for Congress
• Zeller for Congress