Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources:  –  ·  ·  · scholar · JSTOR (June 2017) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)

Cumbres & Toltec Scenic Railroad

Overview
Headquarters	Chama, New Mexico
Reporting mark	C&TS
Locale	Conejos County and Archuleta County in Colorado and Rio Arriba County in New Mexico, United States
Dates of operation	1970–present
Technical
Track gauge	3 ft (914 mm)
Length	64 mi (103 km)
Other
Website	cumbrestoltec.com
Denver & Rio Grande Railroad San Juan Extension
U.S. National Register of Historic Places
U.S. National Historic Landmark District
Colorado State Register of Historic Properties
N.M. State Register of Cultural Properties
Show map of ColoradoShow map of New MexicoShow all
Nearest city	Antonito, Colorado and Chama, New Mexico
Coordinates	36°54′N 106°35′W / 36.900°N 106.583°W / 36.900; -106.583Coordinates: 36°54′N 106°35′W / 36.900°N 106.583°W / 36.900; -106.583
Area	1,430 acres (580 ha)
Built	1880 (1880)
Architect	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad Baldwin Locomotive Works
Architectural style	Late 19th And Early 20th Century American Movements
MPS	Railroads in Colorado, 1858-1948 MPS
NRHP reference No.	73000462[1] (original) 07000374[1] (increase)
CSRHP No.	5AA.664 / 5CN.65
NMSRCP No.	136
Significant dates
Added to NRHP	February 16, 1973
Boundary increase	April 24, 2007
Designated NHLD	October 16, 2012[2][3]
Designated NMSRCP	November 20, 1969

The Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad, often abbreviated as the C&TSRR, is a 3 ft (914 mm) narrow-gauge heritage railroad that operates on 64 miles (103 km) of track between Antonito, Colorado, and Chama, New Mexico, in the United States. The railroad is named for two geographical features along the route: the 10,015-foot (3,053 m)-high Cumbres Pass and the Toltec Gorge. Originally part of the Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad's narrow-gauge network, the line has been jointly owned by the states of Colorado and New Mexico since 1970. Today, the C&TSRR is one of only two remaining parts of the former D&RGW narrow-gauge network, the other being the Durango and Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad (D&SNG), which runs between the communities of Durango and Silverton, Colorado. The railroad has a total of ten narrow-gauge steam locomotives (six of which are operational) and two narrow-gauge diesel locomotives on its current roster. The railroad also operates two smaller former D&RGW steam locomotives, Nos. 315 and 168, for special events.

History[]

On February 20, 1880, track crews of the Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad (D&RGW) began to lay the first rails of the San Juan Extension going south from Alamosa, Colorado, toward Antonito, Colorado, arriving in March of that year. The company chose the narrow gauge of three feet instead of the standard gauge of four feet eight and a half inches. This was because the narrow gauge was cheaper to build, and a narrow gauge railway can accommodate tighter-radius curves. This allowed laying track where the standard gauge would not fit. From Antonito, the line continued west to Chama, New Mexico, arriving there on December 31, 1880. The track had come 64 miles (103 km) through two tunnels, over a 10,015-foot (3,053 m) mountain pass, and skirted a 600-foot gorge.^[4] The line then went on towards Durango, Colorado. The purpose of this extension was to tap into the mineral resources around the Silverton, Colorado area.^[4]

Once the Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad arrived in Chama, other railroad companies were formed to take advantage of the forests around the area. This created a flourishing logging economy for the small town. There were lumber mills located to the west and south of Chama. These mills provided a steady stream of revenue for the railroad, lasting until abandonment in the late 1960s.^[5]

After World War II, there was an oil boom in Farmington, New Mexico. This boom provided a surge of revenue for the railroad. This revenue consisted of 60-car pipe trains going west from Antonito. The Gramps Oil Fields of southern Colorado also provided oil for the trains to carry from Chama to Antonito. The lumber mills also provided a steady stream of revenue, although this was not as important as the oil. This increase in revenue is what saved the line from abandonment.

All of these successes had some drawbacks. The major issue with the line was Cumbres Pass itself. Cumbres Pass is 10,015 feet (3,053 m) above sea level. The high elevation and various other factors lead to many terrible snow storms. This prompted the railroad to purchase machines called “rotary snowplows”. The two that were used on the Cumbres Pass line were Rotary OM and Rotary OY. Both rotaries are still in existence in Chama, New Mexico, but historically they would be dispatched out of Alamosa. Every five or six years, the winter season would see as much as 500 inches of snow fall on Cumbres. These terrible snow storms were a huge financial burden for the railroad. The “Granddaddy of All Snowstorms” ^[6] hit in the winter of 1951–1952. This was the worst recorded winter on the line and one of the deciding factors when abandonment was considered in the 1960s.

In September 1968, the Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad filed for abandonment of its narrow gauge lines. In April 1969, legislation was signed in New Mexico that provided a way for the state of New Mexico to buy the track between Chama and Antonito. In 1970, Colorado passed similar legislation. The two states took joint ownership of the line and, by 1971, the Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad was formed.

Notable incidents[]

2002 shutdowns[]

In 2002, the C&TSRR was shut down twice, first in the spring to resolve track bed issues. In the summer, operations were suspended again because of wildfire dangers.^[7]

Lobato trestle fire[]

On June 23, 2010, an unknown fire severely damaged Lobato Trestle, a deck girder bridge located approximately four miles (6.4 km) east of Chama. While the bridge was out of service, the C&TSRR operated limited services from the Chama end while trains from Antonito only traveled to Osier and back.^[8] After undergoing extensive refurbishment, the bridge was reopened on June 20, 2011.^[9]

National Historic Landmark[]

In 1973, the Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad was listed on the National Register of Historic Places and its boundaries were increased in 2007.^[1] The railroad was designated as a National Historic Civil Engineering Landmark by the American Society of Civil Engineers in 1976.^[10] In 2012, the railroad was designated a National Historic Landmark, for its engineering, well-preserved infrastructure and equipment and the role of the railroad in the development of the region it served.^[11]

Current operations[]

The Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad operates between late May and late October, with two trains (one in each direction) departing each morning from Antonito, Colorado, and Chama, New Mexico. Both trains meet at Osier, Colorado for lunch. At Osier, lunch is served to passengers in a modern dining hall. From there, passengers have the option to continue to the other side of the railroad, or they can switch trains and return to their point of origin. Once the westbound train arrives at Cumbres Pass, passengers have the option to board motorcoaches to return to Antonito, or they can save an hour and continue into Chama. The continental-divide trail brings hikers through Cumbres Pass as well. The railroad offers these hikers a ride down the mountain from the pass if desired. At the end of the day at both ends, motorcoaches are again provided for passengers who came from the opposite end. The motorcoach ride is about one hour long.

In addition to the through service, the C&TSRR operates various special excursions during the season such as dinner trains.^[12] On certain days during the holiday season, the railroad offers special "Santa Trains" from both Chama and Antonito, and guests are encouraged to bring gifts and/or food for the less fortunate.^[13]

Operator changes[]

After the C&TSRR was formed in 1971, a bi-state agency, the Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad Commission was created. Railroad operations were then contracted to third-party rail operators. In 2012, after long discussions with other third-parties bidding to take over, the Commission formed its own operating company, Cumbres and Toltec Operating LLC^[14] They hired John Bush, a veteran of the railroad, to become president on December 13, 2012.^[15] Bush retired on November 14, 2020.^[16]

Friends of the C&TSRR[]

In 1988, a nonprofit organization called the Friends of the Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad was established to preserve the history of the railroad and help maintain infrastructure and rolling stock. The Friends of the C&TSRR also participates in various education programs and provides the railroad guides, known as docents, who inform passengers of historical aspects of the railroad as well as locations of interest.^[17]

Route description[]

hide v t Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad
Legend
San Luis and Rio Grande Railroad to Alamosa 280.70 Antonito 306.6 Sublette 311.3 Mud Tunnel 315.2 Rock Tunnel 318.4 Osier 320 Cascade Creek trestle 330.48 Cumbres 339.7 Lobato trestle 344.12 Chama Durango and Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad to Durango

Locations along the line[]

• Chama, New Mexico 36°54′N 106°35′W / 36.900°N 106.583°W / 36.900; -106.583 (Chama)
• Cumbres Pass 37°1′N 106°27′W / 37.017°N 106.450°W / 37.017; -106.450 (Cumbres Pass)
• Osier, Colorado 37°1′N 106°20′W / 37.017°N 106.333°W / 37.017; -106.333 (Osier)
• Toltec Gorge, New Mexico 36°59′N 106°18′W / 36.983°N 106.300°W / 36.983; -106.300 (Toltec Gorge)
• Sublette Station 36°59′N 106°14′W / 36.983°N 106.233°W / 36.983; -106.233 (Sublette)
• Antonito, Colorado 37°4′N 106°1′W / 37.067°N 106.017°W / 37.067; -106.017 (Antonito)

Chama to Osier[]

Chama Yard[]

The Chama yard is located at milepost 344.12. Here, the railroad stores most of its freight cars and both rotary snowplows, Rotary OY and Rotary OM. On the east side is part of the original roundhouse from the D&RGW. A fire burned most of the roundhouse years ago; what remains is used as storage for parts. K-37 locomotive No. 497 is currently stored here.^[18] On the far side of the old roundhouse section are the shops where the engines are serviced and prepared for the next day. The shops have two stalls and can hold up to two engines inside simultaneously. On the west side of the yard is the original depot from the late 1800s, where train tickets can be purchased. There is a gift shop with various items for sale. On the south end of the yard, over 100 freight cars are visible. The yard is open and can be toured by anyone. About 40 of the cars in the yard are operational.^[19]

From Chama, the railroad proceeds northeast after crossing Rio Chama. About one mile (1.6 km) later, the railroad begins up the mountain on a grade averaging 4%. The first siding on the line is at Lobato (MP: 339.99). Here are remnants of a stock pen and a water tank made for a movie in the 1970s. The tank was used later in Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. The water tank was knocked-over in 2006, succumbing to age and high winds. Lobato Trestle is located at Lobato. It the second-highest trestle on the line, built in 1883. Due to weight restrictions, only one locomotive at a time is allowed to cross. Hence, all double-headers must separate and rejoin on the other side. The bridge was rebuilt in 2012 after a fire nearly destroyed it.

From here to Cumbres, the railroad operates on the north side of Wolf Creek. There are several old stations along the line. The first is Dalton (MP: 335.5). There is nothing at Dalton besides the station sign. Next on the journey to the top at Cumbres, the train passes Cresco Siding and water tank (MP 335.5). Just before this, the track crosses the state line for the first time. This water tank is used when operating smaller engines, such as No. 315 and No. 168, and for rotary trains. The route then enters a small canyon past Hamilton's Point. Exiting the canyon, the track makes a turn to the northwest and up Wolf Creek through Coxo. At Coxo, there is a short siding for maintenance equipment and a station sign. At a narrow point of the valley, the track makes a horseshoe turn up to Windy Point. Windy Point is an outcrop of volcanic rock where the wind blows so hard that the smoke from the trains often will blow towards the front of the train instead of the rear. This is less than a quarter of a mile from Cumbres Pass, the highest point on the line

At Cumbres (MP 330.60), elevation 10,015 ft (3,053 m), is the Car Inspector's House, Water Standpipe, remnants of the extensive snow shed and the Section House, which replaced the original depot after it was demolished in the 1950s. Cumbres is the highest point on the railroad and the highest elevation of any narrow-gauge railroad in North America. Upon reaching the pass, the engine must take on water, as it has used about 3⁄4 of its supply. After taking on water and a short brake test, the train departs to the east and begins the downhill section. At “Tanglefoot Curve”, the track doubles back on itself to lose elevation gradually. Here, the trains going downhill will perform a boiler blowdown. This is where the engine releases steam from the boiler to clear sediments at the bottom of the boiler. From there, the track turns north up the Los Piños Valley.

The track continues a gentle descent on the average 1.45% grade to the north until it reaches Los Piños tank. This tank is always full and is used for small engines and rotary trains. The track takes a gentle loop off to the west and comes back to the east at the station of Los Piños (MP: 324.8). There is nothing here except a siding and the station sign. The track then turns back north towards Osier, Colorado. Just before Osier, at Milepost 320, the track crosses Cascade Trestle. This is the highest trestle on the entire line, sitting at 137 ft (42 m) above the river below. The train then stops at Osier, Colorado (MP: 318.40), where passengers are served lunch in a modern, wooden indoor facility.

Antonito to Osier[]

This section covers the eastern portion of the line, from the small cattle and junction town of Antonito to Osier, the mid-point of the line.

Antonito (MP 280.70) is a small company town of the former railroad main line. It is home to the C&TSRR car shop, a water tank and other relics. Most of the facilities were built by the C&TSRR, since the original rail yard, wye, and station were not sold to the states of Colorado and New Mexico.

Shortly after leaving the station, the train heads straight for three miles (4.8 km) until coming into some hills. Shortly thereafter, the train crosses Ferguson's Trestle (MP 285.87), named for a man who was hanged from a locomotive there. The original trestle was featured in the 1988 television movie Where the Hell's That Gold?, starring Willie Nelson and Delta Burke. In filming, an explosion mishap occurred and the bridge was burned-down. Traffic was halted for a week while the C&TSRR built a temporary bridge. Next winter, the trestle was rebuilt, matching the original. About three miles (four point eight kilometres) later, the train makes the first of 11 crossings into New Mexico and climbs a ledge up to a lava mesa. Lava (291.55) has the old water tank from Antonito, which was moved here in 1971. The track goes around a horseshoe curve that is also used as a reversing loop to turn the rotary snow plow trains from Chama.

Heading west, the track rounds Whiplash Curve, a double-horseshoe curve. About one mile (1,600 m) from Whiplash Curve lie the sidings and wye at Big Horn. Past Big Horn, the train loops around the sides of mountains, going through horseshoe curves before reaching the first water stop at Sublette.

Sublette is an abandoned railroad section camp, consisting of a log bunk house, a section house, a siding and other buildings. There was once a water tank at the western end of the siding. Today, in its place, there is a standpipe. After the tender is filled with water, the train slowly creeps into lush aspen groves.

Following Sublette is Toltec Siding, which in the 1950s was the meeting place for oil well pipe trains moving between Chama and Farmington to Alamosa. Shortly afterwards, trains pass through Mud Tunnel, which is unique because it is lined with wooden pillars due to being bored through soft volcanic ash. When the beams in the tunnel collapsed, the D&RGW made a "shoo fly" (a temporary by-pass) to allow passengers and small cars to be moved around the tunnel to an awaiting train. After passing through this, trains pass around Phantom Curve and through Calico Cut, then slow when entering the longer Rock Tunnel. Trains exit the tunnel entering Toltec Gorge, where the track is 600 ft (180 m) above the river. The line then follows the river to Osier.

• Line's terminus in Antonito
• 

  The entrance to the C&TS yard in Antonito, October 2012

• 

  The station and shed in Antonito, October 2012

• 

  The water tower in Antonito, October 2012

• 

  The yard in Antonito, October 2012

• 

  The station building in Antonito, October 2012

• Line's terminus in Chama
• 

  The coaling tower in Chama, October 2012

• 

  The water tower in Chama, October 2012

• 

  The shop in Chama, October 2012

• 

  The yard in Chama, October 2012

• 

  The depot in Chama, October 2012

Rolling stock[]

Number	Type	Wheel Arrangement	Classification	Builder	Built	Serial Number	Former	Status	In Service	Anticipated Return to Service Date
463	Steam	2-8-2	K-27	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1903	21788	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Operational	Yes	N/A
483	Steam	2-8-2	K-36	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1925	58584	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Stored Undergoing Cosmetic Restoration	No	Unknown Date
484	Steam	2-8-2	K-36	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1925	58585	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Operational	Yes	N/A
487	Steam	2-8-2	K-36	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1925	58588	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Operational	Yes	N/A
488	Steam	2-8-2	K-36	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1925	58589	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Operational	Yes	N/A
489	Steam	2-8-2	K-36	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1925	58590	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Operational, recently returned to service as an oil-burning locomotive.	Yes	N/A
492	Steam	2-8-2	K-37	Baldwin Locomotive Works Burnham Shops	1928	20749	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Stored	No	Unknown Date
494	Steam	2-8-2	K-37	Baldwin Locomotive Works Burnham Shops	1928	20748	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Display	No	Unknown Date
495	Steam	2-8-2	K-37	Baldwin Locomotive Works Burnham Shops	1928	20522	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Display	No	Unknown Date
497	Steam	2-8-2	K-37	Baldwin Locomotive Works Burnham Shops	1930	20521	Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Stored Awaiting Possible Restoration	No	Unknown Date
15	Diesel	(B-B)	44-Ton (Center-Cab)	General Electric (GE)	1943	Unknown	Oahu Railway and Land Company	Operational	Yes	N/A
19	Diesel	(B-B)	44-Ton (Center-Cab)	General Electric (GE)	1943	27539	Oahu Railway and Land Company	Operational	Yes	N/A
168	Steam	4-6-0	T-12	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1883	6670	Denver and Rio Grande Railroad	Operational	Yes	N/A
315*	Steam	2-8-0	C-18	Baldwin Locomotive Works	1895	14352	Florence and Cripple Creek Railroad Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad	Operational	Yes	N/A

* No. 315 is not owned by the C&TSRR, but is included on the current roster due to frequent operations in special excursions and the indefinite loan.

Steam Locomotives[]

All of the steam locomotives operating on the C&TSRR are former Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad locomotives. The railroad owns three classes of steam locomotives. The K-27, K-36 and K-37 engines are all outside frame 2-8-2 "Mikado" engines built by Baldwin Locomotive Works. Of the ten steam locomotives currently owned by the C&TSRR, Nos. 463, 484, 487, 488, 489 and 497 are operational. Locomotive 497, a class K-37 locomotive, was restored to operating condition for the Durango and Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad in 1984 and was traded to the C&TSRR in late October 1991 in exchange for class K-36 locomotive 482. Locomotive 497 was later taken out of service in late 2002 and currently sits in storage in the Chama roundhouse awaiting an overhaul. In late 2019, locomotive 489, a class K-36 locomotive, went down for a Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) mandated 1,472-day inspection and replacement of the smokebox. However, the work was halted due to the Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in March 2020. The work resumed on the 1,472-day inspection and installation of the new smokebox in October 2020. On December 15, 2020, the railroad announced they are converting locomotive 489 to burn oil instead of coal. The decision was made "to ensure viability in diverse environmental conditions."^[20] The conversion of locomotive 489 is currently expected to be completed in time for the opening of the 2021 operating season, although an exact date is still to be announced.

The T-12 No. 168 is a 4-6-0 "Ten Wheeler" type inside frame engine also built by Baldwin Locomotive Works. This is the oldest steam locomotive owned by the railroad. Restoration work on No. 168 was completed in October 2019, and it now continues to operate on occasional special excursions on the C&TSRR. Another engine that operates on the railroad is D&RGW No. 315. No. 315 is a C-18 class inside frame 2-8-0 "Consolidation" type locomotive. It is owned by the Durango Railroad Historical Society, but it is on indefinite loan to the C&TSRR.^[18] Restoration work on No. 315 was completed in August 2007, and it continues to operate on occasional special excursions on both the D&SNG and the C&TSRR.

Diesel Locomotives[]

The C&TSRR owns 2 class DE General Electric 44-ton center-cab diesel locomotives built in 1943, Nos. 15 and 19, for emergency use when the steam locomotives are inoperative. They are also used for operations outside the normal operating season. Both came from the Oahu Railway and Land Company; No. 19 was purchased by the C&TSRR in 1972 and No. 15 was purchased in 2013.

Rotary snowplows[]

The C&TSRR owns two rotary snowplows, Rotary OY and Rotary OM. Rotary OM was purchased in the late 1800s by the D&RGW and has served the line ever since. It has not been run since the 1970s because of mechanical issues. Rotary OY was built in the 1920s and has served in several places on the line. It was last run in late winter of 2020 to begin the 50th anniversary of the formation of the C&TSRR. There are no current plans to run the rotary again anytime soon, but it is in good condition and fully functional.^[18]

D&RGW #168[]

In 2016, D&RGW No. 168 arrived in Antonito from Colorado Springs, Colorado for restoration to working order. The engine had been on display for a long time in a public park, but was in good condition. Restoration began in March 2017 and was completed in October 2019. The restoration project was headed up by Cumbres and Toltec Special Projects department and lead by Assistant General Manager Efstathios Papas. The project cost $508,000 and spanned 27 months. The railroad intends to use this engine frequently in normal excursion service as much as possible.^[18] As of 2021, No. 168 continues to operate in occasional special excursions on the C&TSRR.

Passenger cars[]

For passenger services, the C&TSRR operates a mixture of flat roofed and clerestory cars, with interiors corresponding with the railroad's three classes of service: Coach, Deluxe (formerly Tourist class) and Parlor.^[21] In 2019, the car shop in Antonito, Colorado, finished the first in a line of new clerestory cars that will serve as standard passenger cars and new Parlor cars. This is part of an effort to retire the older flat roofed cars due to their age.^[18] The C&TSRR also operates observation gondolas as well as special coaches configured to accommodate wheelchairs and house concession areas.^[22]

Consist[]

A typical C&TSRR train includes:^[23]

• 1 K-27, K-36 or K-37 2-8-2 steam locomotive (A second locomotive is normally added, depending on the length of the train)
• 3 Coaches (On some days, extra coaches are added to meet demand)
• 1 ADA/Concession coach
• 1 Observation gondola
• 1 Deluxe class coach
• 1 Parlor class coach

Freight cars[]

The Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad also owns a varied collection of former D&RGW narrow-gauge freight cars for display and use in nostalgic railtours.^[24]

In popular culture[]

Over the years, the railroad was featured in several documentaries and films.^[25][26] Among these are:

• The Good Guys and the Bad Guys, 1969
• Shoot Out, 1971
• Showdown, 1973
• The Fortune, 1975
• Bite the Bullet, 1975
• The Missouri Breaks, 1976
• Butch and Sundance: The Early Days, 1979
• Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, 1989
• Ghost Trains of the Old West, 1990^[27]
• America's Historic Steam Railroads: Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad, 1999^[28]
• A Million Ways to Die in the West, 2014
• Hostiles, 2017^[12]

See also[]

• D & RG Narrow Gauge Trestle
• List of Colorado historic railroads
• List of Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad lines
• List of heritage railroads in the United States
• Narrow-gauge railroads in the United States
• San Juan Express
• National Register of Historic Places listings in Colorado § Archuleta County
• National Register of Historic Places listings in Conejos County, Colorado
• National Register of Historic Places listings in Rio Arriba County, New Mexico
• List of National Historic Landmarks in Colorado
• List of National Historic Landmarks in New Mexico

References[]

External links[]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroad.

• Official website
• Cumbres & Toltec Scenic Railroad Photos
• Friends of the Cumbres & Toltec Scenic Railroad