Dating the Bible
Part of a series on the |
Bible |
---|
Outline of Bible-related topics Bible portal |
The oldest surviving Hebrew Bible manuscripts—including the Dead Sea Scrolls—date to about the 2nd century BCE (fragmentary) and some are stored at the Shrine of the Book in Jerusalem. The oldest extant complete text survives in a Greek translation called the Septuagint, dating to the 4th century CE (Codex Sinaiticus). The oldest extant manuscripts of the vocalized Masoretic Text (the basis of modern editions), date to the 9th century CE.[1] With the exception of a few biblical sections in the Prophets, virtually no biblical text is contemporaneous with the events it describes.[2]
Internal evidence in the texts suggests dating the individual books of the 27-book New Testament canon in the 1st century CE. The first book written was probably 1 Thessalonians, written around 50 CE.[3] The final book (in the ordering of the canon), the Book of Revelation, is generally accepted by traditional scholarship to have been written during the reign of Domitian (81–96).[4][5]
Since the original recording of the scriptures, various scribes have made numerous copies of the written originals, which are no longer extant. Copies have been made of those copies, resulting in several text types. Archaeologists have recovered about 5,500 New Testament manuscripts: either fragments or complete books.[6] The earliest extant fragment of the New Testament is the Rylands Library Papyrus P52, a piece of the Gospel of John dated to the first half of the 2nd century. Dating the composition of the texts relies primarily on internal evidence, including direct references to historical events—textual criticism and philological and linguistic evidence provide more subjective indications.
Table I: Chronological overview[]
This table summarises the chronology of the main tables and serves as a guide to the historical periods mentioned. Much of the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament may have been assembled in the 5th century BCE.[7] The New Testament books were composed largely in the second half of the 1st century CE.[8] The Deuterocanonical books fall largely in between.
Period | Books |
---|---|
Monarchic 8th–7th centuries BCE c. 745–586 BCE |
|
Exilic 6th century BCE 586–539 BCE |
|
Post-exilic Persian 5th–4th centuries BCE 538–330 BCE |
|
Post-exilic Hellenistic 3rd–2nd centuries BCE 330–164 BCE |
|
Maccabean/Hasmonean 2nd–1st centuries BCE 164–4 BCE |
|
Roman 1st century CE onward after 4 BCE |
|
Table II: Hebrew Bible/Protestant Old Testament[]
Torah | Date or range of dates most widely held by scholars |
---|---|
Book of Genesis Book of Exodus Book of Leviticus Book of Numbers Book of Deuteronomy |
The majority of modern biblical scholars believe that the Torah – the books of Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy – reached its present form in the post-Exilic period.[25]
The five books are drawn from four "sources" (distinct schools of writers rather than individuals): the Priestly source, the Yahwist and the Elohist (these two are often referred to collectively as the "non-Priestly" source), and the Deuteronomist.[37] There is general agreement that the Priestly source is post-exilic, but there is no agreement over the non-Priestly source(s).[37]
|
Prophets | Date or range of dates most widely held by scholars |
Former Prophets:
Book of Joshua |
This group of books, plus Deuteronomy, is called the "Deuteronomistic history" by scholars. The proposal that they made up a unified work was first advanced by Martin Noth in 1943, and has been widely accepted. Noth proposed that the entire history was the creation of a single individual working in the exilic period (6th century BCE); since then there has been wide recognition that the history appeared in two "editions", the first in the reign of Judah's King Josiah (late 7th century), the second during the exile (6th century).[16] Noth's dating was based on the assumption that the history was completed very soon after its last recorded event, the release of King Jehoiachin in Babylon c. 560 BCE; but some scholars have termed his reasoning inadequate, and the history may have been further extended in the post-exilic period.[42] |
Three Major Prophets:
Book of Isaiah |
Scholars recognise three "sections" in the Book of Isaiah: Proto-Isaiah (the original 8th century Isaiah); Deutero-Isaiah (an anonymous prophet living in Babylon during the exile); and Trito-Isaiah (an anonymous author or authors in Jerusalem immediately after the exile).[43]
The Book of Jeremiah exists in two versions, Greek (the version used in Orthodox Christian Bibles) and Hebrew (Jewish, Catholic and Protestant Bibles), with the Greek representing the earlier version.[44] The Greek version was probably finalised in the early Persian period and translated into Greek in the 3rd century BCE, and the Hebrew version dates from some point between then and the 2nd century BCE.[45] The Book of Ezekiel describes itself as the words of the Ezekiel ben-Buzi, a priest living in exile in the city of Babylon, and internal evidence dates the visions to between 593 and 571 BCE. While the book probably reflects much of the historic Ezekiel, it is the product of a long and complex history, with significant additions by a "school" of later followers.[46][47] |
Twelve Minor Prophets | In the Hebrew Bible the Twelve Minor Prophets are a single collection edited in the Second Temple period, but the collection is broken up in Christian Bibles.[48] With the exception of Jonah, which is a fictional work, there exists an original core of prophetic tradition behind each book:[49][50]
|
Writings | Date or range of dates most widely held by scholars |
Wisdom collection: Job, Ecclesiastes and Proverbs |
The books of Job, Ecclesiastes and Proverbs share a similar outlook which they themselves call "wisdom".[56] It is generally agreed that Job comes from between the 6th and 4th centuries BCE.[57] Ecclesiastes can be no earlier than about 450 BCE, due to the presence of Persian loan-words and Aramaic idioms, and no later than 180 BCE, when the Jewish writer Ben Sira quotes from it.[58][59] Proverbs is a "collection of collections" relating to a pattern of life which lasted for more than a millennium, and impossible to date.[60] |
Poetic works: Psalms and Lamentations | The psalms making up the first two-thirds of the psalter are predominantly pre-exilic and the last third predominantly post-exilic.[34] The collected book of Psalms was possibly given its modern shape and division into five parts in the post-exilic period, although it continued to be revised and expanded well into Hellenistic and even Roman times.[61] It is generally accepted that the destruction of Jerusalem by Babylon in 586 BCE forms the background to the Book of Lamentations.[62] |
Histories: Chronicles and Ezra–Nehemiah | Chronicles was composed between 400–250 BCE, probably in the period 350–300 BCE;[30] Ezra–Nehemiah (two books in modern Bibles, but originally one) may have reached its final form as late as the Ptolemaic period, c. 300–200 BCE.[31] |
Miscellaneous works: Book of Ruth, Book of Esther, Book of Daniel, Song of Songs | The Book of Ruth is commonly dated to the Persian period;[63] Esther to the 3rd or 4th centuries BCE; the Book of Daniel can be dated more precisely to 164 BCE thanks to its veiled prophecy of the death of a Greek king of Syria;[64] and the Song of Songs could have been composed at any time after the 6th century BCE.[65] |
Table III: Deuterocanonical Old Testament[]
Book | Date or range of dates most widely held by scholars |
---|---|
Tobit | 225–175 BCE, on the basis of apparent use of language and references common to the post-exilic period, but lack of knowledge of the 2nd century BCE persecution of Jews.[66] |
Judith | 150–100 BCE, although estimates range from the 5th century BCE to the 2nd century CE.[67] |
1 Maccabees | 100 BCE[68] |
2 Maccabees | c. 100 BCE[68] |
3 Maccabees | 100–75 BCE "very probable"[69] |
4 Maccabees | mid-1st century CE[36] |
Wisdom of Solomon | late 1st century BCE/early 1st century CE, on the basis of shared outlook with other works dating from this time.[70] |
Sirach | 196–175 BCE, as the author implies that Simon the high priest had died (196 BCE), but shows no knowledge of the persecution of the Jews that began after 175 BCE.[71] |
Additions to Daniel | Prayer of Azariah (Song of the Three Holy Children); Bel and the Dragon: late 6th century;[72] Susanna and the Elders: possibly 95–80 BCE[73] |
Baruch and Letter of Jeremiah | 2nd century BCE, as Baruch uses Sirach (written c. 180 BCE) and is in turn used by the Psalms of Solomon (mid-1st century BCE). The Letter of Jeremiah, ch. 6:1–73 of the Book of Baruch, is sometimes considered a separate book.[74] |
Table IV: New Testament[]
Book | Date or range of dates most widely held by scholars | Earliest known fragment |
---|---|---|
Gospel of Matthew | c. 80–90 CE.[75] This is based on three strands of evidence: (a) the setting of Matthew reflects the final separation of Church and Synagogue, about 85 CE; (b) it reflects the capture of Jerusalem and destruction of the Second Temple by the Romans in 70 CE; (c) it uses Mark, usually dated around 70 CE, as a source.[76] |