Charles Carroll of Carrollton

Charles Carroll
Charles Carroll painted by Michael Laty
United States Senator from Maryland
In office March 4, 1789 – November 30, 1792
Preceded by	Office created
Succeeded by	Richard Potts
Member of the Maryland Senate
In office 1781–1800
Personal details
Born	(1737-09-19)September 19, 1737 Annapolis, Maryland, British America
Died	November 14, 1832(1832-11-14) (aged 95) Baltimore, Maryland, United States
Nationality	Kingdom of Great Britain (1737-1783) United States (1783-1832)
Political party	Federalist[1]
Spouse(s)	Mary Darnall
Alma mater	College of St. Omer Lycée Louis-le-Grand
Signature

Charles Carroll (September 19, 1737 – November 14, 1832), known as Charles Carroll of Carrollton or Charles Carroll III,^[2] was an Irish-American politician, planter, slaveholder, and signatory of the Declaration of Independence. He was the last surviving person to sign the Declaration of Independence, dying 56 years after signing the document, in addition to being the only Roman Catholic signatory.^[3]

Considered one of the Founding Fathers of the United States, Carroll was known contemporaneously as the "First Citizen" of the American Colonies, a consequence of signing articles in the Maryland Gazette with that pen name.^[4] He served as a delegate to the Continental Congress and Confederation Congress. Carroll later served as the first United States Senator for Maryland. Of all of the signers of the Declaration of Independence, Carroll was reputed to have attained the highest formal education and wealthiest of the group. A product of his 17-year Jesuit education in France, Carroll spoke five languages fluently.

Born in Annapolis, Maryland, Carroll inherited vast agricultural estates and was regarded as the wealthiest man in the American colonies when the American Revolution commenced in 1775. His personal fortune at this time was reputed to be 2,100,000 pounds sterling; the equivalent to £269,884,478 in 2019 (US$375 million). In addition, Carroll presided over his manor in Maryland; a 10,000 acre estate that included approximately 1,000 enslaved people (or approximately one-third of the approximately 3,000 people owned by all Catholic slaveholders in the United States at the time).^[5] Though barred from holding office in Maryland because of his religion, Carroll emerged as a leader of the state's movement for independence. He was a delegate to the Annapolis Convention and was selected as a delegate to the Continental Congress in 1776. He was part of an unsuccessful diplomatic mission, which also included Benjamin Franklin and Samuel Chase, that Congress sent to Quebec in hopes of winning the support of French Canadians.

Carroll served in the Maryland Senate from 1781 to 1800. He was elected as one of Maryland's inaugural representatives in the United States Senate but resigned from the United States Senate in 1792 after Maryland passed a law barring individuals from simultaneously serving in state and federal office. After retiring from public office, he helped establish the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad.

Ancestry[]

Carroll coat of arms

The Carroll family were descendants of the Ó Cearbhaill lords of Éile^[6] (Lords of Ely) in King's County (now County Offaly), Ireland. Carroll's grandfather was the Irish-born Charles Carroll the Settler (1660–1720) from ; he was a descendant of Daniel O'Carroll of Aghagurty Clareen, three miles south of Kinnitty, and a clerk in the office of Lord Powis.^[7] Carroll left his native Ireland around 1659^[8] and emigrated to St. Mary's City, capital of the colony of Maryland, in 1689,^[9] with a commission as attorney general from the colony's Catholic proprietor, Charles Calvert, 3rd Baron Baltimore.

Charles Carroll the Settler was the son of Daniel O'Carroll of Litterluna. The "O'" in Irish surnames was often dropped with the anglicisation policies adopted by the English administration in Ireland.^[10] Charles Carroll the Settler had a son, born in 1702 and also named Charles. To distinguish himself from his father he was known as Charles Carroll of Annapolis.^[11]

Early life[]

Doughoregan Manor, the Carroll family seat, now a National Historic Landmark

Carroll was born on September 19, 1737, in Annapolis, Maryland, the only child of Charles Carroll of Annapolis (1702–1782) and Elizabeth Brooke (1709–1761). He was born illegitimate, as his parents were not married at the time of his birth, for technical reasons to do with the inheritance of the Carroll family estates. They eventually married in 1757.^[12]

The young Carroll was educated at a Jesuit preparatory school known as Bohemia Manor in Cecil County on Maryland's Eastern Shore.^[12] At age 11, he was sent to France where he continued in Jesuit schools; first at the College of St. Omer in Northern France, and later the Lycée Louis-le-Grand in Paris, graduating in 1755. He continued his studies in Europe and read law in London before returning to Annapolis in 1765.^[12][13]

Charles Carroll of Annapolis granted Carrollton Manor to his son, Charles Carroll of Carrollton. It is from this tract of land that he took his title, "Charles Carroll of Carrollton." Like his father, Carroll was a Roman Catholic and as a consequence was barred by Maryland statute from entering politics, practicing law and voting.^[12] This did not prevent him from becoming one of the wealthiest men in Maryland (or indeed anywhere in the Colonies),^[12] owning extensive agricultural estates, most notably the large manor at Doughoregan, Hockley Forge and Mill, and providing capital to finance new enterprises on the Western Shore.^[14]

American Revolution[]

Voice for independence[]

Carroll was not initially interested in politics,^[12] and in any event Catholics had been barred from holding office in Maryland since the 1704 act seeking "to prevent the growth of Popery in this Province".^[15] But as the dispute between Great Britain and her American colonies intensified in the early 1770s, Carroll became a powerful voice for independence. In 1772, he engaged in a debate conducted through anonymous newspaper letters, maintaining the right of the colonies to control their own taxation. Writing in the Maryland Gazette under the pseudonym "First Citizen," he became a prominent spokesman against the governor's proclamation increasing legal fees to state officers and Protestant clergy. Opposing Carroll in these written debates and writing as "Antillon" was Daniel Dulany the Younger, a noted lawyer and loyalist politician.^[16][17] In these debates, Carroll argued that the government of Maryland had long been the monopoly of four families, the Ogles, the Taskers, the Bladens and the Dulanys, with Dulany taking the contrary view.^[17] Eventually word spread of the true identity of the two combatants, and Carroll's fame and notoriety began to grow.^[18] Dulany soon resorted to highly personal ad hominem attacks on "First Citizen", and Carroll responded, in statesmanlike fashion, with considerable restraint, arguing that when "Antillon" engaged in "virulent invective and illiberal abuse, we may fairly presume, that arguments are either wanting, or that ignorance or incapacity know not how to apply them".^[18] Following these written debates, Carroll became a leading opponent of British rule and served on various committees of correspondence.^[19]

In the early 1770s Carroll appears to have embraced the idea that only violence could break the impasse with Great Britain. According to legend, Carroll and Samuel Chase (who would also later sign the Declaration of Independence on Maryland's behalf) had the following exchange:

Chase: "We have the better of our opponents; we have completely written them down."

Carroll: "And do you think that writing will settle the question between us?"

Chase: "To be sure, what else can we resort to?"

Carroll: "The bayonet. Our arguments will only raise the feelings of the people to that pitch, when open war will be looked to as the arbiter of the dispute."^[20]

Continental Congress[]

Beginning with his election to Maryland's committee of correspondence in 1774, Carroll represented the colony in most of the pre-revolutionary groups. He became a member of Annapolis' first committee of safety in 1775. Carroll was a delegate to the Annapolis Convention, which functioned as Maryland's revolutionary government before the Declaration of Independence. In early 1776, the Congress sent him on a four-man diplomatic mission to the Province of Quebec, in order to seek assistance from French Canadians in the coming confrontation with Great Britain. Carroll was an excellent choice for such a mission, being fluent in French and a Roman Catholic, and therefore well suited to negotiations with the French-speaking Catholics of Quebec.^[20] He was joined in the commission by Benjamin Franklin, Samuel Chase and his cousin John Carroll.^[21] The commission did not accomplish its mission.

Charles Carroll of Homewood

Carroll was elected to the Continental Congress on July 4, 1776, and remained a delegate until 1778. He arrived too late to vote in favor of the Declaration of Independence but was present to sign the official document that survives today. After both Thomas Jefferson and John Adams died on July 4, 1826, Carroll became the last living signatory of the Declaration of Independence. His signature reads "Charles Carroll of Carrollton," to distinguish him from his father "Charles Carroll of Annapolis," who was still living at that time, and several other Charles Carroll's in Maryland, such as Charles Carroll, Barrister, or his son Charles Carroll, Jr., also known as "Charles Carroll of Homewood." He is usually referred to this way by historians. At the time, he was the richest man in America and had much to lose by identifying himself on the document. Throughout his term in the Second Continental Congress, he served on the board of war. Carroll also gave considerable financial support to the American Revolutionary War.

Senator[]

Carroll returned to Maryland in 1778 to assist in the formation of a state government. Carroll was re-elected to the Continental Congress in 1780, but he declined. He was elected to the Maryland Senate in 1781 and served there until 1800. In November 1779, The Maryland House of Delegates moved to pass a bill confiscating the property of those who had sided with the Crown during the Revolution. Carroll opposed this measure, questioning the motives of those who pressed for confiscation and arguing that the measure was unjust. However, such moves to confiscate Tory property had much popular support and eventually, in 1780, the measure passed.^[22]

When the United States government was created, the Maryland legislature elected him to the first United States Senate. In 1792, Maryland passed a law that prohibited any man from serving in the state and national legislatures at the same time. Since he preferred to be in the Maryland Senate, he resigned from the U. S. Senate on November 30, 1792.

Attitude toward slavery[]

The Carroll family was slaveholders, and Carroll was reputedly the largest single owner of enslaved people at the time of the American Revolution.^[23] Carroll was opposed in principle to slavery, asking rhetorically: "Why keep alive the question of slavery? It is admitted by all to be a great evil."^[24] However, although he supported its gradual abolition, he did not free his own enslaved people.^[25] Carroll introduced a bill for the gradual abolition of slavery in the Maryland Senate, but it did not pass.^[26] In 1828, aged 91, he served as president of the Auxiliary State Colonization Society of Maryland,^[27] the Maryland branch of the American Colonization Society, an organization dedicated to returning black Americans to lead free lives in African states such as Liberia.

Later life and legacy[]

"First Stone" (cornerstone) of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad laid by Carroll on July 4, 1828, now displayed at the B&O Railroad Museum

Carroll retired from public life in 1801. After Thomas Jefferson became president, he had great anxiety about political activity and was not sympathetic to the War of 1812. He was elected a member of the American Antiquarian Society in 1815.^[28] Carroll came out of retirement to help create the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad in 1827. In 1828, he commissioned the Phoenix Shot Tower and laid its corner stone, which was the tallest building in the United States until the Washington Monument was constructed.^[29] His last public act, on July 4, 1828, was the laying of the "first stone" (cornerstone) of the railroad at almost 91 years of age.^[30]

He was admitted as an honorary member of The Society of the Cincinnati in the state of Maryland in 1828.^[31][32] Unlike hereditary members, honorary members are not eligible to be represented by a living descendant.^[33] In May 1832, he was asked to appear at the first Democratic Party Convention but did not attend on account of poor health.^[34] Carroll died on November 14, 1832, at age 95, in Baltimore.^[35] He holds the distinction of being the oldest lived Founding Father. He had outlived five of the first six U.S. presidents. His funeral took place at the Baltimore Cathedral (now known as the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary), and he is buried in his Doughoregan Manor Chapel at Ellicott City, Maryland.^{[citation needed]}

Carroll is remembered in the third stanza of the state song Maryland, My Maryland.

Thou wilt not cower in the dust,

Maryland! My Maryland!

Thy beaming sword shall never rust,

Maryland! My Maryland!

Remember Carroll's sacred trust,

Remember Howard's warlike thrust –

And all thy slumberers with the just,

Maryland! My Maryland!

The bronze statue by Richard E. Brooks located in the United States Capitol crypt

Named in his honor are counties in Arkansas, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, Ohio, and Virginia as well as two Louisiana parishes, East and West Carroll. Cities and towns named for him are in Georgia, Kentucky, Maryland, Missouri, and New York, as well as neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Tampa. Charles Carroll Middle School in New Carrolltown, Maryland; Charles Carroll High School^[36] in the Port Richmond neighborhood of Philadelphia; and Carroll University in Waukesha, Wisconsin, are named in his honor.

In 1876, the Centennial Exhibition held to commemorate the birth of the United States was held in Philadelphia. The Catholic Abstinence Union of America commissioned the Catholic Total Abstinence Union Fountain for the Centennial Exhibition. The fountain was commissioned and created by sculptor Herman Kim to promote American morality, and the centerpiece of the fountain is a statue of Moses. There are four other statues that surround it, making up the points of the Maltese cross: Carroll, Father Mathew, Commodore John Barry, and Archbishop John Carroll. The fountain is located in West Fairmount Park.^[37]

In 1903, the state of Maryland added a bronze statue Carroll to the United States Capitol's National Statuary Hall Collection. Sculpted by Richard E. Brooks, it is located in the Crypt.^[19] In 1906, the University of Notre Dame constructed a residence hall known as Carroll Hall.^[38] Paca-Carroll House at St. John's College is named for Carroll and his fellow signer of the Declaration of Independence, William Paca.^[39] The World War II Liberty Ship SS Charles Carroll was named in his honor.^[40]

Family[]

Mary Darnall Carroll (1749-1782), portrait by Charles Willson Peale

Carroll married Mary Darnall (1749–1782), known as Molly, on June 5, 1768. She was a granddaughter of Henry Darnall (Carroll was a great grandson of Darnall).^[41] They had seven children before Molly died in 1782, but only three survived infancy:

• Mary Carroll (1770–1846), who married Richard Caton (1763–1845), an English immigrant who became a Baltimore merchant. From 1820 to 1832, Carroll would winter with the Catons in Baltimore. Their daughters were:
  • Marianne Caton (1788–1853), who married Robert Patterson (brother of Elizabeth Patterson Bonaparte). After his death, she married Anglo-Irish statesman Richard Wellesley, 1st Marquess Wellesley (1760–1842), who was the brother of the legendary military commander Arthur Wellesley, 1st Duke of Wellington, who was believed to have been previously Marianne's paramour.
  • Elizabeth Caton (1790–1862), who married Sir George Strafford, 8th Baron Strafford.
  • Louisa Caton (1793–1874), who married Col. Sir Felton Bathurst-Hervey, 1st Baronet. After his death, she married Francis D'Arcy-Osborne (later the 7th Duke of Leeds).
  • Emily Caton (1794/5-1867), who married John McTavish (1788–1852), who served as British Consul to Baltimore. They were parents of four children including Mary Wellesley McTavish (1826–1915), The Hon. Mrs Henry George Howard (of the Earls of Carlisle).^[42]
• Charles Carroll Jr. (1775–1825) (sometimes known as Charles Carroll of Homewood because he oversaw its design and construction), married Harriet Chew (1775–1861) from Philadelphia. Harriet was the daughter of Benjamin Chew, the chief justice of Pennsylvania, and her sister married John Eager Howard, who had served in the Senate with Charles Carroll of Carrollton. Charles Jr. reportedly consumed up to two quarts of brandy a day. This led to erratic behavior that resulted in his separation from Harriet.
• Catherine ("Kitty") Carroll (1778–1861), who married Robert Goodloe Harper (1765–1826), a lawyer and U.S. senator.

Today, Carroll's descendants continue to own Doughoregan Manor, the largest parcel of land in Howard County, Maryland, with over 1,000 acres (4 km²) of valuable but historically preserved land in Ellicott City, Maryland.

Anne Marie Becraft's grandmother, a free Black, worked as a housekeeper for Carroll and was likely his concubine; Carroll presented Annie Marie's father with several of the Carroll family's prized relics, paintings, and other keepsakes just before Carroll's death in 1842.^[43]

Carroll's signature[]

In the 1940s, newspaper journalist John Hix's syndicated comic Strange as It Seems published an interesting, but apocryphal, explanation for Charles Carroll's distinctive signature on the Declaration of Independence. Every member of the Continental Congress who signed this document automatically became a criminal, guilty of sedition against King George III. Carroll, because of his wealth, had more to lose than most of his companions. Some of the signators, such as Caesar Rodney and Button Gwinnett, had unusual and distinctive names which would clearly identify them to the King; other signators, with more commonplace names, might hope to sign the Declaration without incriminating themselves.

According to Hix, when it was Carroll's turn to sign the Declaration of Independence, he rose, went to John Hancock's desk where the document rested, signed his name "Charles Carroll" and returned to his seat. At this point another member of the Continental Congress, who was prejudiced against Carroll because of his Catholicism, commented that Carroll risked nothing in signing the document, as there must be many men named Charles Carroll in the colonies, and so the King would be unlikely to order Carroll's arrest without clear proof that he was the same Charles Carroll who had signed the Declaration. Carroll immediately returned to Hancock's desk, seized the pen again, and added "of Carrollton" to his name.

In fact, Carroll had been appending "of Carrollton" to his signature for over a decade, the earliest surviving example appearing at the end of a September 15, 1765, letter to his English friend William Gibson. Carrollton Manor was the name of a tract of more than twelve thousand acres in Frederick County, Maryland, which the Carroll family leased to tenant farmers.^[44]

See also[]

• 1840s Carrollton Inn
• Annapolis Convention (1774–1776)
• Memorial to the 56 Signers of the Declaration of Independence
• Carrollton Manor
• Maryland in the American Revolution
• O'Carroll

References[]

Further reading[]

• Birzer, Bradley J. (2010). American Cicero: The Life of Charles Carroll, Intercollegiate Studies Institute.
• Breidenbach, Michael D. (2013). 'Conciliarism and American Religious Liberty, 1632–1835' (Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Cambridge).
• Carroll, Charles. Unpublished Letters of Charles Carroll of Carrollton and of his Father, Charles Carroll of Doughoregan, United States Catholic Historical Society, 1902.
• Gleeson, John. 1913 'History of the Ely O'Carroll Territory'
• Heaney, Paddy (2004). At the Foot of Slieve Bloom. Kilcormac Historical Society.
• Hoffman, Ronald; Sally D. Mason (2000). Princes of Ireland, Planters of Maryland: A Carroll Saga, 1500–1782. University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 0-8078-2556-5.
• Leonard, Lewis A. Life of Charles Carroll of Carrollton, Moffat, Yard and Company, 1918.
• McDermott, Scott (2002). Charles Carroll of Carrollton: Faithful Revolutionary. Scepter. ISBN 1-889334-68-5.
• Rowland, Kate Mason. The Life of Charles Carroll of Carrollton, 1737–1832, Vol. 2, G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1898.
• Sergeant, John. Eulogy on Charles Carroll of Carrollton: Delivered at the Request of the Select and Common Councils of the City of Philadelphia, December 31, 1832, L.R. Bailey, 1833.
• Smith, Ellen Hart. Charles Carroll of Carrollton. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1942.

External links[]

• United States Congress. "Charles Carroll of Carrollton (id: C000185)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.. Retrieved November 2010.
• Quotes by Charles Carroll. Retrieved November 2010.
• "Charles Carroll of Carrollton and Revolutionary Religious Toleration: The Making of a Founder". Article by Matthew Wigler in the Journal of the American Revolution. Retrieved February 2017.
• A Moment in Time Archives: Charles Carroll of Carrollton. Retrieved November 2010.
• Homewood House Museum. Retrieved November 2010.
• Research into Homewood House. Retrieved November 2010.
• Biography by Rev. Charles A. Goodrich, 1856. Retrieved November 2010.
• ZENIT: How Charles Carroll Influenced U.S. Founding Fathers (Part 1) and (Part 2) (interview with Scott McDermott; McDermott mentions various facts about Carroll). Retrieved November 2010.
• Catholic Encyclopedia: Charles Carroll of Carrollton
• Charles Carroll at Find a Grave
• Charles Carroll of Carrollton historical marker
• The Society of the Cincinnati